Crook
Avenger
- Joined
- May 20, 2007
- Messages
- 16,297
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 31
I just told you in one sentence why the shot would be more significant than the rest; that if the scene is true, then most than likely Nolan will make sure it's not a throwaway scene.That is not even remotely the same.
Gordon and Batman are talking about a murderer. Showing the card to reveal who it is.
Anthony Michael Hall is playing a character name Mike Engel. Write on a piece of paper is what everybody does like everyday. Nobody is gonna pay attention on a very minor character writing on a piece of paper. Some people think that AMH can be somebody else and thats why you think it would be easy to get. But if you think some random person would get that AMH would just suddenly be somebody else by writing on a piece of paper, then you ARE a moron. How many times has a character become a different character like that? And how many of those times wasnt the character mentioned or dressed as the character? Seriously, get real!
I dont see a difference between Rachel feeding her cats and Engel writing on a piece of paper. What if Rachel drew a little kitty, would that make everybody go 'So Rachel is Catwoman ey'? And dont say that's not the same thing. Like I said, the only reason you see it working is that you see AMH playing a different character than he is even before the movie starts, and that you are prepared to see some sort of reveal.
This wouldn't be a case of an audience member picking something up at 2 hours 26 minutes and 3 seconds in, at the far right of the screen. That's precisely what you would be describing because those are shots that aren't supposed to be anything. However, for such a crucial moment, Nolan would not simply flash a clue only the die-hard fans would get.
A simple panning shot on Engel, building music, "Who is the Batman?" boldly written on paper, a slow zoom on the question mark finally taking up the entire screen to which the music blares triumphantly..... something like THAT, you're honestly gonna tell me that's not not gonna make people think: "hrm, you know, maybe the director is trying to tell us something here?"