• The upgrade to XenForo 2.3.7 has now been completed. Please report any issues to our administrators.

General Trek Talk Are you a Star Trek fan? The official Star Trek thread where no fan has gone before..

Are you a Star Trek fan? Favortie series?

  • I'm a star trek fan, but I can't pick a favorite

  • The Next Generation

  • Voyager

  • Enterprise

  • Deep Space Nine

  • The original series

  • I'm not a star trek fan

  • I'm a star trek fan, but I can't pick a favorite

  • The Next Generation

  • Voyager

  • Enterprise

  • Deep Space Nine

  • The original series

  • I'm not a star trek fan


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Or you could...


Destroy Earth...
Split up the Federation...
Take a technological step back due to resources and loss of records...



Tons of stuff can solve that problem. They had concrete in Rome but once that civilization fell, most of the world didn't know how to replicate that tech.


:ST: :ST: :ST:

That's an interesting idea. But it might invite unfavourable comparisons to another Gene Roddenberry franchise.



The best part of that show was the Rush-inspired opening theme, and they even got rid of that after season 1!
 
That's an interesting idea. But it might invite unfavourable comparisons to another Gene Roddenberry franchise.



The best part of that show was the Rush-inspired opening theme, and they even got rid of that after season 1!


t'was to what i was refering... it's quite obvious what this show was meant to be... but for some odd reason, it wasn't.

I'd actually like to see a 'post' TNG about a renegade Federation ship, running around trying to save the quadrant from itself. A little more space pirate, and a little less pijama communist. I'd go with a 'Tom Paris like' character (that doesn't wimp out after the first episode) who maintains a 'criminal' perspective as Captain... prolly let out of prison like Paris, as a consultant, but then takes command after it's revealed that elements within the federation cannot be trusted. An ex-con captain (call him Han Solo of the STU) with his drunken Klingon honor guard, leading a ship of pijama wearing nancies. I think this could work as long as the two (captain and buddy) maintain the idea of criminality, unlike Voyager, where that theme seemed to evaporate as soon as the cast boarded voyager.
 
t'was to what i was refering... it's quite obvious what this show was meant to be... but for some odd reason, it wasn't.

I'd actually like to see a 'post' TNG about a renegade Federation ship, running around trying to save the quadrant from itself. A little more space pirate, and a little less pijama communist. I'd go with a 'Tom Paris like' character (that doesn't wimp out after the first episode) who maintains a 'criminal' perspective as Captain... prolly let out of prison like Paris, as a consultant, but then takes command after it's revealed that elements within the federation cannot be trusted. An ex-con captain (call him Han Solo of the STU) with his drunken Klingon honor guard, leading a ship of pijama wearing nancies. I think this could work as long as the two (captain and buddy) maintain the idea of criminality, unlike Voyager, where that theme seemed to evaporate as soon as the cast boarded voyager.

Ah yes, Voyager. If you find the characters of TNG too edgy, Voyager's the show for you. :P
 
Well B'Elana Torres was always riding the ragged edge, untill she settled down with her milksop, Tom.

Regardless, I kind of like the idea of what was presented above. Maybe add another officer who acts Vulcan, but is really Romulan. Sometimes he/she feeds the info to the elements in the Federation the captain is working against about what they are trying to do. Sometimes his/her obvious affection for this renegade captain get in the way of the duty of being a spy. Someone who you never know who's side they'll end up on.
 
t'was to what i was refering... it's quite obvious what this show was meant to be... but for some odd reason, it wasn't.

I'd actually like to see a 'post' TNG about a renegade Federation ship, running around trying to save the quadrant from itself. A little more space pirate, and a little less pijama communist. I'd go with a 'Tom Paris like' character (that doesn't wimp out after the first episode) who maintains a 'criminal' perspective as Captain... prolly let out of prison like Paris, as a consultant, but then takes command after it's revealed that elements within the federation cannot be trusted. An ex-con captain (call him Han Solo of the STU) with his drunken Klingon honor guard, leading a ship of pijama wearing nancies. I think this could work as long as the two (captain and buddy) maintain the idea of criminality, unlike Voyager, where that theme seemed to evaporate as soon as the cast boarded voyager.

they did that in ds9, with the maquis,red squad, and even an episode when thomas riker shows up to expose the obsidian order's plans.also dukat did something similar for the cardassian union when the klingons were at war with the quadrant.
 
i'd like a change in ships there are plenty of designs out there.
 
It's got to have The Enterprise.


:ST: :ST: :ST:

no it doesn't, but I like the idea of a regular guest star starship as the ship in charge of hunting down the renegade ship and crew. Could be the enterprise, from a different perspective.


Actually, I always liked the thought of Riker being the advesary. Still a captain, work for starfleet, the Fed, trying to do the right thing, even though he also recognizes the growing flaw (whatever it is) in the federation. Have him in charge of the hunt for the renegade ship, until a couple seasons in, where he becomes a active protagonist. A semi regular thing.

this way they can play that standard game of cat and mouse hunt, then riker begins to suspect that the renegade crew might be more important than he was lead to believe... eventually Riker being forced to give up the hunt and help them, for the sake of the federation. At this point, more devilish and higher up villains will have surplanted Riker as the antagonist etc.



I like the idea of a consultant criminal, turned captain, to lead a new (standard issue Harry Kim nerd/dork like) crew, when they are branded renegades for doing the right thing. The crew would resist the new captain's ways for a while, and there'd be conflict... but they'd realize after a season or two, that his way of thinking is the only way they will survive to save the federation. The issue with trek, is that the characters have always assimilated into the standard trek formula for a crew member within the timespan of an episode. Voyager is the perfect example of what not to do... all these Maquis criminal/rebels, were suddenly like any other starfleet crew, within the timespan of the premier... and their pathetic single serving episodes trying to play the social conflict up, were pretty poor, and few in number.

It also allows one to look at the underbelly of the STU, as well as a ship starved for supplies and fuel. Always on the run. (Voyager attempted to do this, but failed miserably, as their arcs never lasted for more than what, 3 episodes at the most, then everything went back to standard STU happy town by the end of the episode/short arc).


and what would be my wet dream, is if the events of a story like this one, lead into the events that resulted in the creation of Abrams new universe/timeline... Spock 'dying' to save the galaxy. It is also my hope that Andy Dick and Robert Picardo are ever present in any post voyager central timeline series in the STU.
 
Last edited:
It is also my hope that Andy Dick and Robert Picardo are ever present in any post voyager central timeline series in the STU.

Um, an emphatic no on the first name there. I don't necessarily need to see a man sexually assault a Horta on TV. :(
 
They could have the Enterprise as a symbol of hope for the crumbling Federation as it trys to rebuild from the ashes. It would be more than a flagship, but the ship that inspires others to try for the future.
 
They could have the Enterprise as a symbol of hope for the crumbling Federation as it trys to rebuild from the ashes. It would be more than a flagship, but the ship that inspires others to try for the future.

GROWLY VOICE: The people of this city, I mean galaxy, are crying out for a symbol. An incorruptible beacon shining in the blackest night. We can't be the heroes they want, but we can be the heroes they need. growl growl growl ;)
 
Y'know... maybe it's just me, but I LIKE the idea of ubertech Star Trek. It makes me happy inside.

I also love the idea of Abramsverse Trek, I'd like to see the Defiant (Same class as the Abramsverse Ent), running around on missions, every once in a while sending up a classic TOS eppy, perhaps guest starring one of the movie actors during the season finale. I'd love to see Several races put in there as well. I'd do the Romulan-pretending-to-be-Vulcan Captain, a human first officer, Andorian,

But yeah, the renegade ship with the Enterprise as their main rival/hunter sounds incredibly cool. Not what I'd do, cuz I think Firefly is all that and several bags of chips, but still cool.
 
Why would you want the Defiant to be the same class as the Enterprise? One of the coolest things about it was how unusual a ship it was compared to the other Starfleet designs. :huh:
 
Why would you want the Defiant to be the same class as the Enterprise? One of the coolest things about it was how unusual a ship it was compared to the other Starfleet designs. :huh:

It was? I guess I missed that part, it looked cool, but like standard Trek at the same time.
 
Most of the Starfleet designs I've seen look like polygonal saucers attached by stalks to some kind of body with the main engines attached to that. A couple reverse that design and make the saucer section the main body and put the engines on stalks. But the Defiant was the first one I saw that was completely compact, no stalks, just a sleek, "sports coupe"-style saucer ship.
 
Most of the Starfleet designs I've seen look like polygonal saucers attached by stalks to some kind of body with the main engines attached to that. A couple reverse that design and make the saucer section the main body and put the engines on stalks. But the Defiant was the first one I saw that was completely compact, no stalks, just a sleek, "sports coupe"-style saucer ship.


OH! Yeah, the DS9 Defiant was WAY cool for that, I was thinking about the TOS Defiant, which was Constitution class. That was just for my Abrahmsverse idea.
 
They could have the Enterprise as a symbol of hope for the crumbling Federation as it trys to rebuild from the ashes. It would be more than a flagship, but the ship that inspires others to try for the future.

that sounds, stupider than my idea, go watch andromeda, and get your fix
 
I started watching TNG the other day, I'm about six episodes in, the Ferengi episode is my favorite so far.
 
I didn't realize Data is in Superhero movie as the doctor....
 
I started watching TNG the other day, I'm about six episodes in, the Ferengi episode is my favorite so far.

you make it to the second encounter with the borg at the end of 2 beginning of 3, and the new uniforms and you'll be locked.

favorite notable episodes that you'll be approaching soon. Best of Both Worlds, and the Booby Trap (I think my all time favorite episode, you know when the captain takes the helm, the **** is about to hit the fan)
 
you make it to the second encounter with the borg at the end of 2 beginning of 3, and the new uniforms and you'll be locked.

favorite notable episodes that you'll be approaching soon. Best of Both Worlds, and the Booby Trap (I think my all time favorite episode, you know when the captain takes the helm, the **** is about to hit the fan)

If you mean Best of Both Worlds as the second encounter, then that's season 3&4.

Unless you meant Q Who (and the first 'encounter' as the season 1 finale). I can never remember how late in 2 that episode is.
 
How many episodes in the entire Star Trek has a plot about a virus going around in the ship? I know theres one in TNG (Which causes them to act weird) and one in DS9 (which cause them to not talk?)...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"