TheCorpulent1
SHAZAM!
- Joined
- Jun 20, 2001
- Messages
- 154,474
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 31
Pretty appropriate for Marvel's US government these days.
Haha, would that make Hank Saruman?Yeah, oddly, the government is not YET to the point of Supreme Power where the United States might as well be controlled by Sauron from the Tower of Minas Morgul but its getting there.
Tony Stark: Wormtongue!
Reed: Yes master!

My whole original point was that Gauntlet and Hank and the other adults seem to be pretty quick to point fingers at Armory and declare her the wild threat in this, and pretty damn slow to look at their own accountability for this mess. So a kid screws up and hurts people with her powers. Okay. But isn't that what they expected to happen? Isn't that what this place was built for in the first place? Isn't it their jobs to make sure it doesn't happen? So when accidents like this actually happen, does it say more about the kid or about their inability to train the kid? They knew and we knew that superpowered teens are dangerous. That was never in doubt, or at least it shouldn't have been. The only real question here was whether or not the adults in question would be able to "housebreak" these kids. Signs so far? Point to no.
Speaking of the training...I gotta ask, what training? Their whole original complaint was that kids who aren't trained will make mistakes in bad situations. So they don't train this kid Armory, immediately place her in a bad situation mere hours after primary assessment and...what? Never once accounted for the fact that she's gonna make a big mistake? But...hello, big smart army science people, remember the part where she's untrained? I never suggested that these kids should never fight any real battles during their stay -- which I'd assume is reasonably lengthy and not just a week or a month or so -- but you're telling me that to place them all in a direct combat situation without any training whatsoever on the first day is smart now?
They treat the kids like walking time bombs. So why are they surprised when one goes off? And on that note, four other trainees were just...what? Just standing in the exact same room with utterly no means of protection whatsoever? And apparently they weren't even remotely briefed on the abilities of their peers and what dangers they could present to each other? What if one of them had fire powers and another had gas powers?...which, lo and behold, was pretty much exactly what happened! Fire and gas mixed, and sht blew up. I thought the whole point was "safety first." The pro-regs made the biggest fuss in the world about proper procedure and regulation and training...and a kid gets his face blown off on the very first day of this great operation through a combination of stupid mistakes made by a variety of people, including those who were supposed to be implementing proper procedure and regulation and training in the first place. Yeah, hardly the shiny happy picture of law and order that was promised to the voting public, is it?
^I get that. But I'm questioning just how culpable Armory is for the incident at all. How has she "washed out" of this training program when she hasn't even been trained? Was she so much of a bad seed that the behavior couldn't have been trained out of her...y'know, like the program is supposed to be doing? Aren't they under the assumption that every recruit and trainee is a "bad seed" in a way, as per the dictates of the SHRA in the first place?
Here is the fact: a guy got his head shot off in the very first day. The very. First. Day. In probably what was one of the very first training sessions. More people could have died that day. And guess what? They were supposed to be watching for exactly this. This exact, precise situation of a young hero losing control of her dangerous powers and hurting or killing people is the exact thing that they were supposed to prevent. They, the pro-reg side and the government and SHIELD and every last person on-site, are the ones who promised that they would. They fought a war on the backing of this promise that they would be able to do it.
You wanna talk big about safety and security and proper protocol, then you better make dang sure that you're capable of delivering on safety and security and proper protocol. You wanna talk big about accountability and culpability for these mistakes, then here is the question: who made the mistake? "They didn't know how she would react." "They didn't know how his powers worked." "They didn't know this would happen." They didn't know? Well they're SUPPOSED TO KNOW! That's what they guaranteed; I'm not expecting anything from them that they didn't promise to deliver.
I absolutely agree: Dan Slott seems to have a much clearer and consistent idea of what the SHRA actually is than, well, most anyone else at Marvel does. So maybe what we're getting here is exactly how the SHRA would actually work.
.Oh yes, good point.
You claim that I'm holding them to impossible standards, except that they themselves set those standards. You yourself held them to those standards many times. And now they've failed to meet those standards. What are you trying to say...that they did meet their standards? If we're going to talk about arguing in the name of pride, maybe we should be a bit more inclusive, hmm?
What exactly am I not understanding about the military process here? I expected them to not end up with a headless kid on the floor because another kid screwed up. I don't think that's a particularly unreasonable expectation to have considering that the point of the Initiative is to have less headless kids on the floor due to kids screwing up. In this issue they utterly, completely failed in their primary purpose, and I don't see a single one of them taking any responsibility for it.
Please, tell me where I'm getting the wrong impression here. Preferably in a more succinct way than "You just don't get it."
4.I was looking forward to the backstory of MVP,... I bet that all he was was a child who was exposed to a variation of the Super Soldier formula in vitro.
7. Cloudnine = Squirrel Girl w/o the burning need to be a Super Hero. They need to define her more.

Edit: Btw, what the hell was the government thinking building this thing in Stamford? I assume the people outside were the justifiably p**** off citizenry whom now have more superheroes in their backyard than ever before.
Isn't this a bit like building an Anti-Terrorist training camp on the Oklahoma City Federal Building's ruins?
Squirrel Girl is sort of a symbol for superheroines who really shouldn't be but you love anyway.
She's a Silver Age heroine and should be left as such.
2. The death in the first Issue was unrealistic in that as Paranoid and heavyhanded as the government hjave exibited before,.. They wouldn't make the mistake of having a superpowered TEEN activate or be the catalist for another superpowered TEEN.
Too bad they "HAD" to kill him. (sigh - I'd already had thoughts of him and patriot becoming this generations Cage/Fist.)
7. Cloudnine = Squirrel Girl w/o the burning need to be a Super Hero. They need to define her more.
8. What?? The Govenment can't design a better Danger Room? C'MON!!!!!.
9. No inferrences if there is a power exchange system in place or at least a couple of egg-heads looking at powers and pairing off people who's powers cancel out. It just read ,............. meh. Decades of devices produced by scads of folk that inhibit or neutralize powers, and you see Nary a one in place.
10. Where are the Sentinals,.. how did they get past the town with it's hatred of Supers to make this camp?
Actually, I think its important to think it IS the very first day.
For me, the idea behind the Initiative is that while Tony Stark may have a very good idea about how to handle these trainees. The people that are currently in charge of the Initiative are certainly the least capable of being the ones to put it into affect.
Peter Gyrich is attempting to treat this as the breeding grounds for the United States army. It's a mini-draft an option for going home, but the option is to never use your superpowers under any circumstances...ever again. I think it's a little like Babylon Five and Psi-Core. I don't necessarily think that's EVIL but for someone like Cloud9 its definitely worth the signing on for a United States tour of duty.
Except, here's the problem. Peter Gyrich's military experience and Gauntlets are for dealing with conventional weapons and situations. There's a solid military doctrine in the United States of America for dealing with regular people and their armaments. That doesn't apply with all the weird sh** that an Avenger will encounter.
Let's face it, there'd be a lot more accidents on the battlefield if you had a top of the line soldier otherwise then confronted with a gigantic 19 foot tall spider. Charles Xavier knows how to handle this sort of stuff because he's a sympathetic and caring man that prepares for failure.
However, that goes against Gyrich and everyone's problems because its a civilian mindset than military. I think its fully possible to hate Peter Gyrich and Gauntlet as utterly the wrong people for the job (ditto Hank Pym because everything Hank Pym does turns to ashes) without being against the Initiative as an idea.
Edit: Btw, what the hell was the government thinking building this thing in Stamford? I assume the people outside were the justifiably p**** off citizenry whom now have more superheroes in their backyard than ever before.
Isn't this a bit like building an Anti-Terrorist training camp on the Oklahoma City Federal Building's ruins?
wasn't she created by steve ditko in the early 90s?