A totally freaking late B/T from me, covering two weeks of stuff and even then I probably forgot about something.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer #9
End of the age of magic? My mind went totally Fraywards. Nice Big Bad, btw.
I didn't expect Gigi to die, though in retrospect I'm not sure why I didn't expect it. Vaughan finishes up this arc in a spectacular way, not necessarily in terms of action and shock (although there is that here too), but emotionally. The littlest things mean the biggest things for these characters and BKV totally gets it.
And he
really gets Faith, as we've established by now. Her admission that even today she always felt nothing but love from the Mayor...it's so simple, and yet it's so good.
I'm glad this divide between Buffy and Giles occurred. It may not be a direct continuation of the s7 events, but it inforces the notion that not everything is fluffy happy bunnies (
) with these two and for good reason. A potential criticism of this s8 is that since everything takes place an indeterminate length of time after s7, any grievance can just be forgotten, any status quo can just be shrugged off, and any character quirk can just be pulled out of thin air for any reason 'cause, hey, it's been a while right? Such was the case with Kennedy, for example. But no, this shows us that events which took place before is still relevant today. If you don't know what happened before, you probably don't know why this thing happened today. Continuity. Learn to love it like I do, as in slowly and with lube.
(9 out of 10)
Green Lantern Corps #18
Wow. Gibbons just totally pulled a Ninja Vanish on us now didn't he? It was his book just a month ago and now it's...not.
Tomasi takes the reins of this book, and while it's too soon to tell what he's bringing to the table what with this being a complete crossover issue and all, signs are looking acceptable enough. He took what he was given here and crafted a good enough story around it. Hell, it might as well have been his idea alone to give AnalFun here an actual backstory and personality, considering that said backstory/personality was more or less absent under Gibbons.
This is a sort of weird issue as well, in the grand scheme of things. The entire issue focuses on TakenFromBehind and his much-hyped "epic" fight against Superboy-Prime. Except that...the fight ends up being anything but epic. InThePooper flails about like a drunken sailor, don't use a
tenth of what we know the power of Ion is capable of even in this diluted form -- hell, he barely uses any of his Green Lantern powers -- and basically ends up at the receiving end of the pwnstick.
Which is strange because...this is kinda exactly what I wanted, isn't it? I was blabbing from day one about how much DroppingTheSoap doesn't deserve his status and how he doesn't deserve to be the one to one-up Prime. He's too new. He's too undeveloped. This would be, what, his sixth issue of appearance? His
fifth, maybe? You can't just appear in a total of five issues and then proceed to finish off the Final Boss. That would be cockdickery on every level.
Well, it turns out that
someone out there agrees with me. BendingOver's performance here is exactly like how you'd expect a n00b to perform. He thinks exactly like a n00b, he fights exactly like a n00b, and he ends up exactly like a n00b. Which is
good. Which is exactly what
should happen. Except..it feels a bit awkward, because it's so sudden and it doesn't really feel right with how he's been portrayed in issues prior. In the issues prior, he's been flawless. He fights amazing, he's ridiculously efficient, he makes no mistakes, and his achieved victory through prodigious ways...he basically outHals Hal Jordan. Everything we've read up to this point tells us that he
should beat Superboy-Prime, and then there's suddenly this. "This" may make more sense, but it sure wasn't organically flowing out from preceding issues. Which leads me to suspect that maybe Gibbons and Tomasi don't entirely agree on DoggieStyle's presentation.
So what next? He gets trained by Kyle, as per solicits suggest? It would definitely make sense; I'm thinking the Guardians would be more than a bit disappointed in their project and would want some help in getting it fine-tuned.
Speaking of which, I've never really paid much mind to Daxamites in the DCU before, but now that they're firmly New Earth canonized, I can't help but feel a bit uncomfortable about the whole idea. What we have here is an entire race of beings -- thousands if not millions in number -- who are basically Superman. It's questionable whether they can reach his precise power levels what with Supes himself recently becoming more Silver Age in his scope, but here is an entire planet with potentially invincible powers...they're not in danger of extinction and they're not in middle of wars and they're not being hunted down or anything, it's just that they only thing which prevents an entire planet-full of people from becoming Godlike Beings is that they're all xenophobic. That's it. That's the only reason.
...
I have a really hard time swallowing that. It's really the same sort of plot bunny which begs the question of why no Kryptonian ever became superpowerful in the entire history of their people -- same answer is given, they're just xenophobic -- but at least we can accept that those Kryptonians are all bloody well dead now. These Daxamites aren't. They're alive and well and currently just chilling in the DCU. I don't know why it gets to me, but it does. It...throws things out of whack. Upsets the balance or whatever. Brings disharmony to my chi. Etc etc.
(7.5 out of 10)
What if...Uncanny X-Men
Someone's going to have to remind me why I bought this. Liefeldian anatomy, a completely irrelevent storyline about an antagonist that I hate with dark fire, and more disruptive advertisements per square page than a Michael Bay movie.
Oh, wait, now I remember...the last page of Jean in her decked out White Phoenix prom dress was totally worth it. I can be such a fan****e sometimes.
(6.2 out of 10)
Justice League of America #15
Pretty much just a big action issue interspersed with quips and ass shots. It's...good enough, I suppose. But I have to start agreeing with people that this is kinda watered-down JLA, kinda standardized and not very interesting on any level beyond "hey look it's Batman." It's better in a lot of ways than Meltzer, and yet lacks a lot of what Meltzer had in very significant ways.
What we have here is basically the cartoon, in theme and scope and execution. Which is just fine for the cartoon...hell, it's
better than fine for the cartoon, performing far and beyond what the cartoon might be expected to do...but only because it's the cartoon. This is the comics. It's expected to do...different things. And we need to start seeing some of
those things. McDuffie's wedding special made me so excited for all this because of exactly those things.
(7.6 out of 10)
(6.9 out of 10 for the whole arc)
Justice Society of America #11
Aww. Power Girl X-Raying her dead relatives' corpses through the ground. How heartwarming.
Lotsa great character bits and good storytelling. But is it a good story? This entire arc is basically built on The Hype of seeing Kingdom Come Superman in current continuity, and I think we do see bits of The Hype falling away and breaking down at this point. And what we're left with is...an odd little story where nothing's really happening. There's no threat, no overarching goal, no nothing.
On the other hand...to his credit, Geoff Johns is still Geoff Johns. Even in a story where nothing really happens, he still manages to cram a lot into the issue. Little things like Starman and Bats: The Musical. And larger things like the Flashes' interaction. It does fit together nicely. And the next issue looks quite interesting.
(7.1 out of 10)
Annihilation: Conquest #2
See, the book immediately begins to pick up when the Star-Lord crew comes along.
Things move both quickly and slowly in this issue. Quasar and Moondragon -- who seems way smaller now than she was in the mini -- basically spend the whole issue talking about with the High Evolutionary, but they talk about reasonably significant stuff so it's tolerable. Ronan officially joins coalitions with the Annihilation Wave, which is so totally not going to end up badly at all. And Star-Lord's team, who I am having the hardest time calling by any name but the Zoo Crew, comes up with a plan that actually doesn't suck. Ultron shows up in a cape and busts sht up, and while he's cool at the moment I
would like to see him do some bigger, badderasser things than merely ripping out a furry lesbian's heart for shts and giggles.
Up next: Adam Warlock does...something!
(8 out of 10)
The Trials of Shazam #10
I'm actually sort of impressed by Winick's reinvention of Tawky Tawny. I certainly don't know if I
like it, but it actually
felt like a reinvention, as in something with actual direction which at least
implies an idea of what the hell he's doing, instead of the rest of this series which has felt at best like throwing darts at a board to see what happens.
On the downside, still so much Sabina. Oh Winick.
NO ONE FCKING CARES ABOUT HER. She has passed the thin line of being an unremarkable, one-note character. It frankly astounds me that Winick could have any illusions at all about this, and yet issue after issue of this mini is still jam-packed with her zero-dimensional antagonist ass ****ing up space which she hardly needs in a series which hardly has room to waste. Seriously, Winick has
two issues left to make anyone care about Freddie or this new status quo. I've been dubious that he could accomplish it in the first place, much less now.
(6.2 out of 10)
The All New Atom #18
Aka Simone Writes Wonder Woman...Round 3.
It comes off better than the last issue, which is a very good thing since the last issue wasn't too bad. At times the humor feels forced (She's licking him? What?), and I think the whole "makes people tell the truth" thing is overexaggerated a bit here for the lulzes, but mostly it's just damn right. Nowhere else are we going to get WW's opinions on "those" Power Girl rumors (and y'all know exactly which ones I'm talking about), communing with a giant talking head, and death by the Ted Grant Grill. Lifetime guarantee!
(8.5 out of 10)
Blue Beetle #21
Ah, this book. So good no matter who writes it.
Jaime and Traci are so cute right now, I'm almost certain they're going to break up. Shucks.
(9 out of 10)
Teen Titans #53
First of all? Yes for DARK VENGEANCE.
Second of all, whoa there guys. What's going on with the plot now? I mean, I understand what's going on with the plot, I'm just a bit jilted by how weirdly we arrived at this point. Of course Jaime makes everything better, but seriously we were just fighting a while ago and then suddenly Starros? I usually wouldn't advocate
more exposition for any comic, but this seems to be the one time where we really could have used some.
And yeah, Kara taking Conner out in one punch is...irritating...but let's just chalk it up to Tim's sucky cloning skills.
It's basically good though. I'd like to see better, but it's basically good. Looking forward to next ish.
(7.5 out of 10)