• The upgrade to XenForo 2.3.7 has now been completed. Please report any issues to our administrators.

Bought/Thought 7/30

....isn't DR. DOOM supposed to be the main villain in Thor now? Isn't Lkoi reporting back to him? It's been so long but I feel like I remember that happening in one of these 10 issues.......
 
No one here is saying the book is bad, or that JMS hasn't done great work on it. The concern is that it is showing NO urgency. Not a drop. Yes, he is building around New Loki vs. Thor but it isn't being built in a hectic, suspenseful way. It should be, "OMIGOD, LOKI IS BACK!" and not, "Loki, do something already". At the very least, if getting Balder as the prince of Asgard frees Thor up a little, so be it.

The Africa issue was good but most of our complaints have been after the Asgardians were revived. THOR is verging on the point of decompression and #10 really hit that home. When an issue only contains one conversation, that is the shining example of decompression. Writers defend it by pointing to Manga, but frankly, manga is released on a schedule beyond 22 pages a month. I wouldn't mind decompression if I got about 50 pages a month in an anthology. But we don't here.

THOR's hype has been epic, but the stories seem to be slowing down, preparing for the slow route. Take your time, see the sights, no need to rush. Which means when Thor needs to interact with other people, it has to happen outside the ongoing, in the hands of other writers. While Fraction is fine, Bendis simply writes everyone as a low-class commoner, and that won't work with Thor (or Dr. Doom).

We're noting the rut now because JMS has a history of being complacent and getting into ruts easily. He stayed on ASM for years beyond when he clearly ran out of ideas. And considering THOR has had a decent ride thus far, it would be bad to see the rut continue. Just because Thor wishes to isolate himself for now doesn't mean word of his return wouldn't spread and he gets reactions from it. There are ways to put urgency into the pace without ruining it. And that's what we're concerned with. The seeming lack of urgency here.

Well, whatever the case me be, I'm still enjoying it. Maybe if it keeps this pace for another 6 or so I'll drop it, but for now I'm having fun with it.

Blue Beetle 29 also reads as a great starting point, for anyone who wants to get into the book.
 
I've read most of my comics already but I'm not in a mood to review. I will say, though, that Thor #10 has finally turned me to the side of those who've been crying for something to happen. Seriously, it finally hit me that we're 10 issues in and all we've seen Thor do is resurrect Asgardians and then sit around on Asgard. Maybe it was a mistake to leave Thor as king of Asgard. The issue is good, and I was genuinely intrigued about what Balder's new status may mean in the future, but that's the whole problem: everything interesting about Thor right now is potential for the future. I'm not saying I advocate Thor turning into a brainless smash-'em-up comic, but something needs to start happening in the present because, quite frankly, even I'm starting to lose interest.

Welcome to the world of JMS... This is how he screwed over Spidey as well.
 
"Sins Past" is how he screwed Spider-Man over. Everything up to that point was pretty good. Not great, more often than not, but still good.
....isn't DR. DOOM supposed to be the main villain in Thor now? Isn't Lkoi reporting back to him? It's been so long but I feel like I remember that happening in one of these 10 issues.......
Loki doesn't "report back" to anybody. He asked for Doom's help on one thing, as far as we know. They may be allies but if they are, it hasn't been revealed yet.
 
"Sins Past" is how he screwed Spider-Man over. Everything up to that point was pretty good. Not great, more often than not, but still good.

Loki doesn't "report back" to anybody. He asked for Doom's help on one thing, as far as we know. They may be allies but if they are, it hasn't been revealed yet.

In your opinion, in mine he had a couple of good arcs and a few stand out issues, the rest was tripe. How long did the new mystical origin drag on for, before coming to a poor unclimatic end, the results of which were pretty much forgotten about - thanks JMS :csad:
 
Wow, I guess I'm the only one not too concerned with thor. I'm still enjoying the read. Could it be faster? Sure, but just to say we've had under a years worth and what's happened? Thor came back as the king of asgard, all the asgardians were brought back to life, donald blake is back and the odinsleep angle has worlds of play, regular people were brought in to counter balance all asgardians all the time which is a problem Thor books have had in the past, loki and Doom are possibly teaming up (loki would be running doom, btw), Iron Man vs. Thor with more to come, and finally loki's scheme seems to have a definate ending in mind. Compare that to 12 issues of something else, let's say ASM and look at the differences. In ASM no questions were answered about the how, why or WTF? a few villians were introduced, Peter Parker is now a *****ebag pappo who doesn't have a concept of what web fluid is. And several people are loving ASM.

Personally I see this as ending with balder as the new king with thor giving his excessive power to him. This would lead to a less godly thor, who could get tangled up in superheroics more reasonable than he is now and a loki manipulated balder to ensure shenanigans. (shenanigans!!!) All and all, not a bad read or setup. It could move faster, but slower with a purpose is so much more long term and I like that idea more. Also, no I do not want to see Thor get mixed up with simple crimes like some people have mentioned. Gods should not deal with purse snatchers, their concerns should be natural disasters and tyrants. Just my thoughts and I know I'm in the minority, but I find after reading each issue of thor I'm entertained, find complexity and future mysteries and that's what I go for in my comics so I don't mind this wait and see approach since it has progression and answers unlike another comic mentioned in comparison here.
 
In your opinion, in mine he had a couple of good arcs and a few stand out issues, the rest was tripe. How long did the new mystical origin drag on for, before coming to a poor unclimatic end, the results of which were pretty much forgotten about - thanks JMS :csad:

He wrote the 911 issue. I cried. That alone should secure his place in comic history. Oh, and requiem, can't forget requiem.
 
In ASM no questions were answered about the how, why or WTF? a few villians were introduced, Peter Parker is now a *****ebag pappo who doesn't have a concept of what web fluid is. And several people are loving ASM.

To be fair, Pete's not a pappo anymore, he's unemployed again:whatever:
 
The Mummy-The Rise And Fall Of Xango's Ax #4: Skip it! If you love the Mummy movies, there isn't much here that resembles them, besides having a couple of the characters within the book. The art isn't very good, and the price too high for 22 pages. Also, the main villian isn't anywhere near as threatening as Imotep. 2/10

Project Superpowers #5: This title has been pretty good so far; but, you kind of get lost with all of these new characters coming at you each issue. This issue, we get more of the superpowers coming together and finding each other, while new heroes get introduced. This is one of those titles that will benefit more when combined in a total package...because, right now, we've had 5 issues of pretty much the same thing, past hero meeting past hero, cursing the Yank for trapping them and bringing them back from the Urn. 8/10

Caliber-First Canon Of Justice #4: This is one of those titles that looks beautiful, but I never know what's really going on. It's just amazing to look at the art, especially this front cover with the three gals. Radical Comics has gotten my interest (especially when they offered the first issue for both of their books for only 99 cents each), and I've enjoyed very much what they've been putting out. Hercules is the better title, though. 7/10

Hercules-The Thracian Wars #4: I was thinking when this title came out, "How many damn Hercules characters do we really need from all the comic companies??!!??" Now, I say, I'll gladly take one more if the stories are this good. This title has been amazing, both to look at and to read. In this issue, Hercules and his fellow men have learned that Cotys has plans to march on Greece and attack his countrymen, and in the process of trying to escape and warn Greece, Hercules learns of two betrayals. Like I said, this is just an awesome book, and I hope Radical Comics plans on making more Hercules' adventures after this one is finished. 10/10
 
Catwoman #81: The second to last issue of this series sets up for a Catwoman vs. Batman showdown. Originally slated to be the final issue, DC graced Catwoman fans with one more before she goes silently into the night. All I could think about is how good this series used to be for the first 50 issues, and how it's slowly gone downhill from there. Catwoman used to have one of the best supporting casts in DC comics; but, after One Year Later, it was all sent into a new direction, with Catwoman having a baby. Truth be told, Catwoman had one of the best OYL surprises...but, it was soon ditched, the baby "thrown out with the bathwater," and lately, this title has been devoid of any of it's previous brilliance. Still, I found it much better than Nightwing or Robin. I guess since it's lead character is female, it might say something about it's longevity. I'll miss this issue, but relish the fact there will be one more next month.

I would recommend picking up the final one or two issues from most series, simply for the fact that final issues are hard to come by, and generally cost quite a bit to purchase at a later date. It's a motto I've lived by for quite some time, and has paid dividends. Just look at the final issues of cancelled Marvel series, like G.I. Joe, Transformers, or Conan The Barbarian. They all go for over five bucks an issue with most online comic sites. 7/10

DC Special-Cyborg #3: Last issue revealed that Cyborg's best friend, Ron Evers, was in fact the person resposible for the various attacks being blamed on Vic, and in this issue, it's Cyborg against Cyborg, and we get answers to what's happened to Ron since we last saw him. The story is pretty good, as is the art. In fact, this story is better than most I've read in Teen Titans. 7/10

Green Lantern #33: Hal Jordan's origin continues, as Sinestro and he learn of Abin Sur's final mission before his death and subsequently Hal becoming Green Lantern. The beauty of the story is how Sinestro steals the story, as if Geoff Johns respects and identifies with his character more than Hal's. I've always found Sinestro more interesting than the other Green Lanterns, mainly because I find the Guardians a bunch of pains in the butts who deserve to be rebelled against. 8/10

Superman/Batman #50: I never buy this comic, unless it's a special anniversary issue. The reason is the stories are rarely good enough that it's warranted me buying an additional issue. With this issue, we learn that Bruce Wayne's parents were traveling through Metropolis when he was just a fetus in his mother's belly, and they saw a meteor crash to Earth. Picking up what was left behind, Bruce has something in his Batcave he does not know will eventually cause much havok. (Yeah, how convenient, huh? And, why would Batman keep an unknown object in the Batcave?) Of course, it becomes activated, and from there we learn that Batman's father met Superman's father after being transported in spirit to Krypton, and from that encounter, Jor-El decided to send Superman to Earth. (Again, how convienent. Don't you hate when writers feel they need to change history to suit their story?) I just found myself scoffing at this story too much to enjoy it. 4/10

Only seven more comics to read from this week: Huntress-Year One, Joker's Asylum-Two-Face, Justice Society Annual, Reign In Hell, Teen Titans, Trinity, and Batman-Death Mask.
 
Superman/Batman #50: I never buy this comic, unless it's a special anniversary issue. The reason is the stories are rarely good enough that it's warranted me buying an additional issue. With this issue, we learn that Bruce Wayne's parents were traveling through Metropolis when he was just a fetus in his mother's belly, and they saw a meteor crash to Earth. Picking up what was left behind, Bruce has something in his Batcave he does not know will eventually cause much havok. (Yeah, how convenient, huh? And, why would Batman keep an unknown object in the Batcave?) Of course, it becomes activated, and from there we learn that Batman's father met Superman's father after being transported in spirit to Krypton, and from that encounter, Jor-El decided to send Superman to Earth. (Again, how convienent. Don't you hate when writers feel they need to change history to suit their story?) I just found myself scoffing at this story too much to enjoy it. 4/10

Why do so many issues of Superman/Batman read like someone's ridiculous internet fanfiction inexplicably put into an actual comic?
 
Teen Titans #61: A throw-away issue that isn't that bad. In this, Kid Devil and Blue Beetle are forced to team up, a combination that's like oil and vinegar. They both want revenge against Shockwave embarrassing them in Teen Titans #56, and must learn to work together in order to take him down. Of significance is Kid Devil gets a new name, Red Devil, and a new costume. Also, Blue Beetle becomes an official member of the group. 7/10

Reign In Hell #1: This eight-issue mini-series begins with a bang, as Lord Satanus and Lady Blaze, the rulers of Purgatory, attack Hell, specifically the Odium, declaring a war whose purpose will transform Hell, not into a place of Eternal Damnation, but a "dominion of penance served and trespass forgiven." This first issue was a bit confusing, mainly because many of these characters I don't know, and we do meet quite a few. By the end, all of DC's Hellish characters are called upon to repay all debt's owed by Hell, for battle and dominion of the neatherworld. How good this is will depend on future issues. 7/10
 
I had high hopes for Skaar: Son of Hulk, when they announced his title, and i'm pleased with how well the book has been handled thus far. Albeit i haven't actually read the entire book yet, with it being in it's second issue and all, but i loved Planet Hulk, and Skaar is picking up where that great story arc left off. Thanks for the positive feedback with your reviews.
 
Batman-Death Mask #4: A reader's enjoyment of this miniseries might depend on how much they enjoy manga versions of their superheroes. I found it very entertaining, and this last issue packs it all in, with action, drama, and explaining all the questions the reader might have. And, while Yoshinori Natsume might not be the best drawer of Bruce Wayne, he does an excellent Batman. As Batman stories go, it's much, much better than what Morrison is currently doing with Batman R.I.P.. 8/10

Joker's Asylum Two-Face: This final Joker's Asylum story, featuring Two-Face, is set up by an administrator's decision to try peer counseling in dealing with the inmates. Two-Face's peer counselor is a firefighter who suffered a similiar fate as Harvey Dent, but has chosen to still look on the bright side of life. Two-Face, naturally, decides to make the firefighter see the other side, after he escapes from Arkham. It's a pretty good story, that lets the reader decide the outcome in the end. (Yep, I flipped a coin, and things did not come out well for the firefighter and his wife.)

This was a pretty good series, and one that I'd love to see become a series. A title that focused on the bad guys of Gotham would be pretty interesting...and, nice to see the bad guys come out on top in the end every once in a while is nice. 8/10
 
....isn't DR. DOOM supposed to be the main villain in Thor now? Isn't Lkoi reporting back to him? It's been so long but I feel like I remember that happening in one of these 10 issues.......

Loki was working with Dr. Doom. That was before the Mighty Avengers arrested him and then he got kidnapped from jail by the "New" Defenders, though. Who knows if this plot-line is still valid.

Well, whatever the case me be, I'm still enjoying it. Maybe if it keeps this pace for another 6 or so I'll drop it, but for now I'm having fun with it.

Blue Beetle 29 also reads as a great starting point, for anyone who wants to get into the book.

I agree on Blue Beetle.

As for THOR, yesterday I went to a shop called COSMIC COMICS in Manhattan and they have a habit of writing little "signs" beneath their new comics on the racks that note whether a book is "hot" and offer some observation or opinion from the owner/staff. Sometimes it can be a verification of awesomeness and sometimes a criticism.

For THOR #10?

"Nobody can stretch a 4 issue storyline into a year long arc quite like JMS!"

I found it funny because it was true. That isn't to say it is a bad story. But it is being stretched.

The book I did buy was:

DYNAMO 5 #15: It still is a drag to pay $3.50 for 20 pages of story, but one look at the sales figures for the title kind of justifies it. When a book barely sells in the Top 130, it needs all the things it can get to stay viable. It isn't the same as, say, charging $3.99 per issue of SECRET INVASION simply because it is an event book, especially as it sells over 200k. And Image is hardly as dominating as Marvel, cornering a whopping 4% of the market vs. Marvel's, what, 35%-40%? While not to ignore that it is annoying, Image tried selling this comic at $2.99 and it didn't last beyond 2-3 issues, because apparently the book doesn't sell well enough to forgo the extra .51 cents. At least I can forgive a comic company that is smaller these days than Dark Horse in market share gouging prices a bit on some titles. It is less forgiveable when it is the #1 company in the biz with an A-List team on the #1 book of the summer.

Besides, the trade for the first 7 issues was uber cheap to make up.

This issue continues the "Dynamo 5 No More" esque storyline. After the revelation that Myriad is an alien and the destruction of their aquarium base (which leaves Maddie in a coma) by an attack of villains breaks up the team, Tower City is in shambles due to metahuman crime. A new female vigilante named Vigil tries to hold up the slack, and gets some timely aid by Scrap, the lone team member still wearing a costume and intent on doing good. The pair manage to pummel some new villains (as well as a few crossing over from Faerber's other superhero book, GEMINI), but Scrap quickly sees that the two of them cannot handle the load and organizes a new Dynamo 5 alongside the Firebirds and Quake (circa issue #3, Capt. Dymano's ex-sidekick). I have been waiting for Quake to make a return and this makes perfect sense, so long as he is on his meds (he tends to go on rampages without 'em). I don't expect the team to last with this roster, but it will be fine for the arc.

Gage and Chang make up the issue's subplot, with the former Visionary spotting one of Gage's games and suspecting him of "cheating" by using his telepathy to read the other team's moves to win a tight game. Gage insists that it isn't "cheating" because he considers his powers just a part of him as his muscles (even if they needed a dose of radiation to unlock). To Gage's credit, he could have simply read the other team all game to amass a score of, like, 70-0, but didn't. Gage puts his half-brother in an uncomfortable spot by daring him to squeal about it. As seen in the last issue, Slingshot is taking care of her adopted father (who was recently kidnapped and saved) and Myriad has become disillusioned with the team, thinking they're hypocrites for taking his deception so personally. The villain at the heart of this, Widowmaker, has been tasked to hire supervillains to take over the city and kill Vigil (or any other straggler heroes) by a mysterious boss.

What I like about this book is that situations that once seemed simple become more complicated, and as an independent franchise, Faerber & Asrar can shift things as they fit. Who knew Myriad was an alien? But it works and adds some diversity to the team. The first issues were very "threat of the month" but as things have wore on, things have become more complicated for our heroes, with reactions and responses from villains who aren't about to let Dynamo 5 enforce justice easily. I wholly expect the Dynamo 5 half-sibs to return to each other, but for now the idea of them breaking up and Scrap gathering an ad hoc team works out. The only wild card is Vigil, who may be an old or new character. She claims to be a concerned citizen "standing up" after two generations of Dynamo's seemingly left the city to rot, but who knows. Besides, most teams these days have their first "break up" before issue #24. Hell, the Avengers did far sooner.

Faerber cites in his monthly column inspiration by Fab Nic's 50 issue run on NEW WARRIORS, which he felt at the time was better than Teen Titans (by 1991) and liked the concept of Vance Astrovik actually taking responsibility for his crime of accidentally killing his abusive father. Which makes me wonder if any of the Dynamo 5 will take the rep for a crime, or at the very least leave active duty for a while. At the very least, he is all about allowing resolutions to reach a logical conclusion, which is cool. And Asrar's art is solid on the book, as always. Hopefully it can maintain a better schedule, as promised in the letters page.
 
I want to think of Thor as JMS' attempt at telling a more story-based, mythological story. Like turning Thor into Sandman or something.

However, at this rate, if JMS had written Sandman, we'd still be at the part where Dream is escaping from the cult.
 
I'm not saying I advocate Thor turning into a brainless smash-'em-up comic, but something needs to start happening in the present because, quite frankly, even I'm starting to lose interest.

Like I said, I don't want Thor's comic to lose its intelligence and become, in effect, Jeph Loeb's Hulk series, but an issue or two of fisticuffs would not be amiss.

As luck would have it.....

Got my issue of Hulk in the mail over the weekend. Lots of Verily's and Hammer-smashing! [BLACKOUT]Rulk finds some technicality in the whole "only the worthy can wield Mjolnir" thing and jumps up into space (or the upper atmosphere) with Thor. [/BLACKOUT]Hey, it's Loeb. And he has the pre-excuse of "But I INTEND for it to be over-the-top! Therefore, I can do anything, no matter how ridiculous. Like punch the Watcher. I plan on making Galactus do a spit-take next! Wait 'til you see what I have planned for Eternity"
 
Yeah, someone posted scans of the fight already. It was pretty stupid.
 
And forget about a six-pack. I think Rulk was drawn with an 18-pack on the cover.
 
Loki was working with Dr. Doom. That was before the Mighty Avengers arrested him and then he got kidnapped from jail by the "New" Defenders, though. Who knows if this plot-line is still valid.

They arrested a Doom-bot.

You heard it here first.
 
That would make more sense, actually. Blame the "cow" line on faulty wiring.
 
The Final Three

Trinity #9: Sure, I'm loving this title...but, just like with 52 and Countdown, I wonder if we're just getting a whole lot of filler until we get to the end. So far, each issue is a whole lot of the same thing: some action sequences involving Superman, Wonder Woman, and Batman, with them all wondering about their trinity traits. We do get to meet a new villian, Swashbuckler, a find out that not only are new items gone missing, but a whole lot of people, too. The backstory was pretty interesting, with Swashbuckler making another appearance, and Joker getting his laugh stolen. 8/10

Huntress-Year One #6: The conclusion to Huntress's origin ends, and it was only ok. Of course, you can't help but notice that origin stories that used to take an issue or two gets dragged out for six, and sometimes that only hurts it a bit more than it normally would. I was ready for this to conclude a couple issues ago. 6/10

Justice Society Of America Annual #1: The mystery of Power Girl's disappearance by Gog in the regular series gets explained, and if you're not already a fan of Justice Society Of America, how can you not be after reading this issue?? It's one of the five best issues from this week, and could possibly even be on my top spot. (I'd have to relook at what I read this week.) It was great to be reintroduced to Earth 2 and some old characters I remember from years ago. Plus, the ending has me dying to find out what the hell is going on with the shocking ending I wasn't expecting. I'm such a humongous fan of this series, and have been since I read JSA, when the tie-ins to Infinite Crisis was going on. 10/10
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"