I thought Daredevil was a reasonably solid and faithful interpretation of the character.
I'd put it this way: When I walked out of the Daredevil film, I felt that I had seen the character I knew from the comics . . . I didn't have that same sense after I walked out of X-Men, for example. But I would also say that I thought the X-Men movie was a little bit more entertaining film compared to Daredevil.
So it probably depends on what you're looking for in a film, and I think part of the problem with Daredevil is the character is somewhat understated, so you're not going to get a big, spectacular, blockbuster film based on that character.
. . . if X-Men had really been done right - with a huge budget, faithful design and a great director, that would have just knocked people's socks off. Daredevil probably just doesn't have the potential to make that kind of spectacular film.