Okay, well, now that I've sifted through the dim-witedness and shortsightedness and, in The Guard's case -- HYPOCRISY -- on these boards, I'll move on to trying to explain this.
First and foresmot, I remember distinctly arguing that things could've been done differently in X3 with many of the same people here (The Guard included) and being told (The Guard saying) that I was substituting the actual film with my vision, amoutning to nothing more than "If I did it..."
That's al lthis is. A bunch of fanboys whining about how they would've done it if they were in control. For X3, we're suppose to understand budget constraints, time tables, schedules, etc....here, people were just expecting the world to explode in jubilation. It's a pathetic showcase of hypocrisy in almost every form.
BUt, let's move onto the plan, which really in terms of plot is no better or worse than the villian plan in such other acclaimed Comic-Book movies:
Luthor jacks Superman's technology to build his very own continent. Now, apparently, most of you have forgotten that America is not the center of the world. So, really, Luthor probably didn't care all that much about America's deaths and what would happen. He realized and knew he had an entire SIX CONTINENTS left over who would probably want to buy into that land eventually and yes people, despite its rather digusting and horrid look and arrival, the greedy of the world would've bought into the land Luthor made. Believe it or not, there are few countries out there that'd probably be thrilled (North Korea, Iran, Syria, China in some ways) that'd be gleefully happy with such open real estate and would buy into it without pause, especially if it gave them more technology overwhich to slam each other around and conquer. It'd be like reigniting the arms race between nations. Luthor knows this -- sadly, you guys do not.
The New World was created through such greed and scams -- Luthor is simply continuing a long tradition of imperalism started by us all long ago. Yes, billions would die, but billions more would need a new place to live and Luthor would be able to provide that in spades. Why would they bomb him at that point? Why? Becuase at that point the world needs the land just as much as Luthor does -- the land is now a valued object for millions of displaced people. Nuking it's not going to do a damn thing.
Now, Luthor creates his own continent and is doing it on the surface to make a huge amount of money. However, notice his particular attention. Notice how he does it....? Someone said it's not the villian's ACTIONS, not his plans that create a good villian -- well, Luthor doesn't just make a new landmass or blow up the coast. No. He steals his mortal enemies birthright, poisons it, and creates a bastardization of his homeworld that will foresake him through its very core. Yeah, that's not a good plan or anything....**rollseyes** He's creating a World Wihtout a Superman and in doing so, as many seemed to have missed, he's lost sight of it as well. Is his planned fall? Yes, very much so -- all villian's plans are flawed. If they weren't, they wouldn't be villians. They'd be leaders. Even Hitler, as effective as he was, had flawed plans -- it's all just a matter of time. Some of the most well-regarded mlitary strategists in our time all advocated plans that at one time or another would ultimately fail. What people are doing here is the equivalant of someone looking at American today and calling the Founding Fathers idiots for the way it turned out. At the time, and to this day in some ways, what they dsicovered was an AMAZING idea. Luthor's plan, while ultimately probably flawed in that he'd lose control in the end (a control he doesn't even notice due to his more IMPORTANT BLIND HATRED OF SUPERMAN), resonates with the human fallacy of leaping before you look ,or of going on your instinct, being driven by greed without thinking about the consequences.
Luthor is a genius. But he's not perfect. His plan is pretty genius. To figure out and understand the Kryptonian techonology is genius. However, his application would eventually self-destruct...or would it? With enough technology, it'd be over. But even as he says that, whiny fanboys have to go on and on about every single possibility? "Well, if a F-14 dropped a single-yield nuclear bomb on quadrant four, Luthor's plan would be foiled!!!!!!!!" Yet, I don't see people talking about Doc Ock's plan being stupid in the end, or Green Goblin's lack of goal being some sort of weakpoint, or -- since some of you think X3 was so genius -- Magneto's blind march on Alcatraz to do...what exactly? Oh yeah, kill his own kind and destroy a cure that's already being spread across the country...yeah, that makes a whole lot of sense!
Hypocrites much, The Guard especially?
So, no government response being shown...? I wondered this as well. But then again, we have a whole slew of things to consider. One: jurisidiction. Which government? Of course America could take the most pertinent interest. However, up until that point, Luthor's actions are not technically illegal. He's going out into open waters and creating his own landmass. I don't think the legal codes of war or civility have that covered or anticipated such a thing. My wager: Singer didn't show the gov't reaction because the reaction would be boring and confused and simply that -- a wait and see what's happening. For all they know, it could just be a general landmass growing. Either/or, it's not worthy of our attention in the movement of the action. Also, if you watch closely, the news IS covering the event and speaking of a general disturbance. However, I suppose all you close observors who love to nitpick every detail MISSED that detail.
So, Luthor is creating a landmass and some of you say its ugly. Well. Yeah. It's going to be. In fact, to most humans, Krypton itself looks pretty damn inhospitable and unfriendly. This was no different. And as an EMERGING landmass, that was continoually growing throughout the third act into something we never see, to judge it is being presumptous and somewhat ignorant.
However, remember, we're seeing Luthor in the very beginning of this landmass. For him to have made wepaons prior to the landmass rising would be a bit foolish considering he didn't even know exactly how the landmass would appear. Kryptonian weaponry would need a Kryptonian foundation from which to operate, thus while vulnerable for those few days, Luthor would have a great deal of time to orchestrate the next phase in his plan before or even as the government was attacking him. Remember, the gov't's not going to know exaclty what's going on. It could just be a new land mass...not Luthor. So they may not suspect ill-intent until its too late, by which time, as New Krypton starts breaking through hte East Coast, Luthor's got the weaponry ready to secure his landmass. To me, this all seems very self-obvious and easy -- to some here, not.
Lastly, this whole thing of border patrol and the like. Did it occur to anyone what Lex said in the first place? That he had alien technology BEYOND anything the world has ever seen. Just because he hadn't used it yet, doesn't mean he wasn't going to. In a day, not everyone's going to die, regroup, migrate, and get on his land. It'd take months for such a thing to begin happening, not to mention that New Krypton was alreayd sending out EMP pulses that deativated everything around it -- imagine once it breaches the coast what happens? Panic is always underestimated in cases like these.
The question everyone needs to be asking howeve,r in the end, is why does Luthor do this?
He says its becuase he wants "his cut." But is that really the case? In S:TM, Superman is a side-issue to LUthor, a mere obstalce to a larger goal. In SR, this is far from the case. Far from it. Luthor, from the get go, is OUT TO GET SUPERMAN. He goes to HIS FORTRESS. Steals HIS TECHNOLOGY. Gets KRYPTONITE! Poisions this new land mass to prevent him from being anywhere near it. It's that its so understated, so subtle that he's doing this, that most everyone misses it. It's not being thrown in your face. However, Luthor's first and foremsot goal was to make a world where Superman would not be able to reach him. He didn't want to make his own FOrtress, where he'd be confined from the world in fear of Superman, he wanted to make his own continent, an entire free-roaming wolrd where Superman would be powerless. His plan is maniacal and insane -- but LUthor isn't exactly sane in the first place. We don't go around critiquing Joker for his lack of sanity in scheming -- sometimes, the lack of sanity is the point. Yet, alas, whiny fanboys...