Solidus
Knights of Ren
- Joined
- Dec 26, 2003
- Messages
- 21,806
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 56
I am not really defending Stannis here, but at the very least he is consistent. He doesn't speak out of both sides of his mouth, nor does he ask his men to do things he does not understand.
Dany talks of love and caring for people, and yet she wages war for the desire to conquer. Dany has no concept of battle, of war and what it does to people. And yet she still wages for her own vanity and it is at the expense of others.
Then you probably haven't been reading Sansa's chapters or watching her scenes on the show. Sansa internalizes more pain and anguish then Dany could ever dream. She does so too survive while learning the game.
Dany is no military leader, much less a queen. She plays at it. She only started standing up for what she "believes" in once she gained power. Stick Dany in the Lannister's home without her dragon. Hell she couldn't even handle her brother. And she just sat their as her husband murdered him.
It is not complex. She has a taste of glory and power, and she can't handle it like so many in her family in the past.
If she wanted her people to live happy, safe lives, she'd have settled with the slaves and dragons, and set up a community for them to live. Instead she focuses on conquering. She has the same desire as Viserys. How can this even be denied?
Are you talking books or show here? Book Stannis is a God to his men. They all look at him like Davos does.
And uh no, Stannis doesn't let Mel do whatever she wants.
You are basically claiming people are sexist, while not acknowledging that characters like Arya, Joan, Brienne and others are beloved.
Dany doesn't get a bad wrap because she is powerful and beautiful. It is because she is put on a pedestal while doing horribly stupid things. While being selfish. And to claim she is young and naive in the world of ASOIAF does that wash. Not when she has made these decision when she didn't have to. Not on the same show with the Stark children, who have witnessed and confronted situations that would make Dany crumble and still they persevere.
LOL. Again I could not disagree more. First Dany is not have a bad wrap...it's just here that I see it. And the difference I was speaking of sexism, is because Dany is beautiful, I don't see the same said about Arya/Brienne.
Yes I've read the books, and yes I know Sansa internalizes, but that means nothing. Dany does as stupid things as the others do is my point. She does realize/starting to learn (as the young do) the consequences, and that's where I just wonder if you read the books lol. [BLACKOUT]When Drogon possibly killed a little boy/girl she had the damn dragons locked up when everyone advised against it. [/BLACKOUT]It's like you ignore massive elements of what she's done. She cared so much about what could happen down the road with [BLACKOUT]her dragons she locks them up.[/BLACKOUT];
And I laugh about the vanity part, you could replace the name Stannis there with Dany and it's the same. Dany is learning the concept of war in ADWD it's what most of her problems are, with the conspiracies that happen, her anger. That's all Dany does in ADWD is worry about her actions, and what they have done. I just don't get how you say she doesn't when honestly that is what she thinks about 90% of the time in ADWD.
I'm not saying that Dany does not has a dark side. Maybe again you should look at what I said above about how she is torn of two worlds, one of the innocent slave she has been her whole life under her brother, and the Targaryen anger/temper/desire to rule. Which again I've talked about lots in the past pages. I've never claimed her to be perfect, and that's what you keep trying to make arguments against. None of the characters are, and that's what I say again and again. She makes mistakes just as they all do, and it creates the conflict. Dany should have just settled down? She just like Stannis (even more so then Stannis) has a damn right to the freaking throne. She wants to rule, it is her right. I've never denied the Targaryen in her, you just said that and acted like I was saying she was some perfect individual. I originally said she was a conflicted, naive young girl with a vision, but behind it is strength and good in her.
Dany is young, and that is part of her feature, she is "learning" how to become queen, she is conflicted about it all the time. Even in parts of the book she talks about how she simply wants to be back with Drogo, or just go back to the house with the red door and leave all of it. In ADWD she talks about that alot to her self. She doubts her self, but it's human. And it makes her to many a complex, interesting character. She's not perfect, and no one on here has said that including me. But she is learning the hard way. Stannis especially when younger was not as great of a military leader. When he met Davos, and all the men were starving because he would not give up..(I want to say it was Storm End...or was it Dragonstone?) the castle. You can claim it's because of his vision of justice, Dany would see it that way too, but on both parts war is rarely justified and fought by the innocent while the leaders suffer least.


