BTW, Smallville is one of the top rated syndicated series in America. It's not a failure at all.
Thursday, 10/4
1. "CSI" (CBS) 20.81
2. "Grey's Anatomy" (ABC) 18.13
3. "Without a Trace" (CBS) 14.54
4. "Survivor: China" (CBS) 14.07
5. "Ugly Betty" (ABC) 9.78
6. "ER" (NBC) 9.00
7. "Big Shots" (ABC) 8.66
8. "Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?" (FOX) 8.53
9. "The Office" (NBC) 8.49
10. "My Name Is Earl" (NBC) 8.00
11. "30 Rock" (NBC) 7.38
12. "Don't Forget the Lyrics" (FOX) 5.78
13. "Smallville" (CW) 4.56
14. "Supernatural" (CW) 2.97
Thursday, 9/27
1. "CSI" (CBS) 24.85
2. "Grey's Anatomy" (ABC) 20.48
3. "Without a Trace" (CBS) 16.73
4. "Survivor: China" (CBS) 14.16
5. "Big Shots" (ABC) 11.56
6. "Ugly Betty" (ABC) 11.05
7. "ER" (NBC) 9.93
8. "The Office" (NBC) 9.67
9. "My Name is Earl" (NBC) 8.52
10. "Are You Smarter Than a 5th Grader?" (FOX) 7.35
11. "Don't Forget the Lyrics" (FOX) 5.39
12. "Smallville" (CW) 5.08
13. "Reaper" (R, CW) 2.53
Its not a dud; but not even breaking top 10 for its night when it is premiering isn't anything to brag about.