If AVI ARAD and FOX were to read this, what would YOU say to them?!

[psylockolussus]

make the movie great!

 

[Kirk Langstrom (2)]

I'd say "You dropped the ball"...

 

[BT18]

I'd say:

 

[Timstuff]

I'd say

KURT WIMMER FOR DIRECTOR DANGIT!

 

[Timstuff]

Thank a lot. Now I need therapy..............and a bottle of Pepto Bismol.

Ugh, my sympathies! I think that a kitten just died because of that.

 

[larryfilmmaker]

.... haha and NOW what would you say to Avi and Fox in regards to a possible X4, Wolverine, and Magneto movie?!?!

 

[La_She-Beast]

FOR GOD'S SAKE; DO NOT RUSH X4!!!!!
And no more Ratner.

Spoiler

Make sure Hank appears

 

[CapBeerCino]

It's old, but I never read it before. Anyone knows if it's true?

http://www.**************.com/news/articles/3185.asp

 

[flavio_lebeau]

FOR GOD'S SAKE; DO NOT RUSH X4!!!!!
And no more Ratner.

Spoiler

Make sure Hank appears

I think the line is "MAKE X4!!!!!!"

And then when it's confirmed, we can start pleading for things we want in it

 

[flavio_lebeau]

It's old, but I never read it before. Anyone knows if it's true?

http://www.**************.com/news/articles/3185.asp

it was taken as true on the time it came out. But they never touched this again (about the "revealing in good time" thing).

 

[UraniaChang]

I think the line is "MAKE X4!!!!!!"

And then when it's confirmed, we can start pleading for things we want in it

And get us disappointed again?

 

[flavio_lebeau]

And get us disappointed again?

Don't be so pessimist

 

[Storm22]

Make more X-Men movies!!

Forget about the spinoffs!

 

[Nell2ThaIzzay]

Meh, I'm still weary about another X-Men movie.

Yea, certain things in the COMICS could happen to allow for a 4th movie, but what happens in comics isn't always good in film. The story has been wrapped up. I don't consider a couple shock value scenes to be justification for a new movie.

 

[Neto Magnus]

isn't there a penalty on bumping old ass threads?

 

[gambitfire]

get it right, find a good director and put him on a dam contract.

 

[Madmax308]

Don't be so pessimist

It's not pessimist, it 's common sense, and i agree with them.

There is no point of making a X4 when X3 was the end of trilogy, and doing a reboot is just not a good idea, whenever most broader audience think this was the last X-men film for quite sometime. I don't think 6 or 7 years will make a difference either. I think it would take 20 -25 years quite sometime before ever making another X movie, and to get most broader audiences interested again.

 

[flavio_lebeau]

It's not pessimist, it 's common sense, and i agree with them.

There is no point of making a X4 when X3 was the end of trilogy, and doing a reboot is just not a good idea, whenever most broader audience think this was the last X-men film for quite sometime. I don't think 6 or 7 years will make a difference either. I think it would take 20 -25 years quite sometime before ever making another X movie, and to get most broader audiences interested again.

It took about 7 years to get the general audience interested in Batman again, after the horrible B&R. The general audience actually liked X3 a lot. And I don't think it's common sense to assume that because X3 was bad, X4 is bound to have the same fate. If they keep the same creative team? yes, I agree it will be horrible, but as of now, it's all assumption.

 

[Madmax308]

It took about 7 years to get the general audience interested in Batman again, after the horrible B&R. The general audience actually liked X3 a lot. And I don't think it's common sense to assume that because X3 was bad, X4 is bound to have the same fate. If they keep the same creative team? yes, I agree it will be horrible, but as of now, it's all assumption.

well it is part asumption on my part but don't be surprised either if it's not just assumption. My mother was one of the general audience and never picked up a X-men comic in her life, watched X2 and later when X3 came out and actually hated X3, and i had some friends who were just broader audience that liked X2 but hated X3 because they thought the story and main characters being killed off ruined the movie franchise, and said they didn't expect a sequel, and if there was a sequel they wouldn't bother.

 

[flavio_lebeau]

well it is part asumption on my part but don't be surprised either if it's not just assumption. My mother was one of the general audience and never picked up a X-men comic in her life, watched X2 and later when X3 came out and actually hated X3, and i had some friends who were just broader audience that liked X2 but hated X3 because they thought the story and main characters being killed off ruined the movie franchise, and said they didn't expect a sequel, and if there was a sequel they wouldn't bother.

Here comes the "I have two friends who" argument. That doesn't prove anything, unfortunately. I don't like X3, my friends all enjoyed it. And? Not meaning to be rude or anything, but I've seen months of the same "My parents and my friends liked/hated it". And it doesn't make anyone's point correct. Yes, an X4 might suck harder than Batman and Robin. But it might. It might also be the best of the series.

 

[Lord Doom]

Apacolypse now.

 

[Madmax308]

Here comes the "I have two friends who" argument. That doesn't prove anything, unfortunately. I don't like X3, my friends all enjoyed it. And? Not meaning to be rude or anything, but I've seen months of the same "My parents and my friends liked/hated it". And it doesn't make anyone's point correct.

I know your not trying to come off rude and i understand what you are saying, but i also posted in my upper post that it was part assumption on my part, but don't be surprised if it isn't just part assumption.

I understand also that you have seen boardmembers post this before for months about using their friends and family as refferences but they are also part of a genreal audience as well, especially if i'm not the only board member who has brought up that their family and friends who aren't comic readers but are part of the general audience, and didn't like X3 must have some truth to it in it as well.

 

[flavio_lebeau]

I know your not trying to come off rude and i understand what you are saying, but i also posted in my upper post that it was part assumption on my part, but don't be surprised if it isn't just part assumption.

I understand also that you have seen boardmembers post this before for months about using their friends and family as refferences but they are also part of a genreal audience as well, especially if i'm not the only board member who has brought up that their family and friends who aren't comic readers but are part of the general audience, and didn't like X3 must have some truth to it in it as well.

most people who use the friends argument actually say they liked X3. The best word to describe the reactions on X3 is mixxed. Not hated, not loved, just mixed views. I guess X2 is the only film of the trilogy that most people agree on being great.

 

[Madmax308]

most people who use the friends argument actually say they liked X3. The best word to describe the reactions on X3 is mixxed. Not hated, not loved, just mixed views. I guess X2 is the only film of the trilogy that most people agree on being great.

and if X4 does get made, and comes out, and with a good story to boot, good charterizations form the cast that makes the characters that you and others want. i hope that your dreams come true and you get the movie you been waiting for.

 

[flavio_lebeau]

and if X4 does get made, and comes out, and with a good story to boot, good charterizations form the cast that makes the characters that you and others want. i hope that your dreams come true and you get the movie you been waiting for.

Thank you. Root for me