Sequels Survey: What do you want to see most in "X4"?

[Stuart Green]

6/2/2007


Hi, everyone.
I know internet surveys can be a bother, but there's a good reason for this one. See, I'm going send a petition to Fox to make an "X-Men 4", but I also want to be clear to include what people want to see. As a result, I'm asking 20 questions and you guys pick the answers. Among the questions are who should be back, who should be the leader, who should be the villain this time and so on. I know internet petitions rarely work, but sometimes if fans are vocal enough they work (remember "Superman II: The Richard Donner Version"?). You've probably seen this survey I started on a few other websites, too, but what better place to have it up but here too?

So, what're the questions, you ask? Read on and choice...

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- Famke Janssen as Jean Grey
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth
- Ray Park as Toad
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelly Hu as Deathstryke
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man
- Other

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
a.) Yes, he's the star
b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him
c.) No, he has had three movies and a solo film
d.) No, do not include him at all

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
a.) Xavier
b.) Storm
c.) Cyclops
d.) Wolverine

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well
b.) Yes, but in a supporting role
c.) Yes, but for flashbacks and keep him dead
d.) Nope, he's dead, buddy -- let it go, dude

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
a.) Yes, have her as an X-Man and have her be with Cyclops already! It's been three movies, Fox!!
b.) Yes, but as a villain. It's possible she could turn back into Dark Phoenix mode.
c.) Yes, but as a supporting character.
d.) No, have her in flashbacks and let Cyclops mourn her. He ends up with White Queen later anyway.
e.) No, let her rest in peace.

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Angel
b.) Beast
c.) Iceman
d.) Pyro
e.) Colossus

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Storm
b.) Rogue
c.) Kitty Pryde
d.) Jubilee
e.) Mystique

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!
b.) Sure, why not? It's been three movies and some actors would be too costly to get back.
c.) Maybe a few, but there are a few that need to stay.
(If you chose c., say who shouldn't be recast)

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
a.) Mystique
b.) Beast
c.) Nightcrawler
d.) All of the above (so what if the budget explodes?!?)

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
a.) YES!! It's been three movies!! Let's see her fly!!
b.) Yes, but not permanently -- just for a short while.
c.) Nope, but she could absorb Sunfire's powers like her comic counterpart currently has.
d.) No, just keep the absorption power. The other powers aren't necessary.
e.) Nope, she's cured (at least for now).

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!
b.) No, two of them are dead, remember?

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
a.) Yes, how can you have an X-film without him?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.
c.) No, he's been in three movies and he's cured. Have someone new.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)
b.) The H*llfire Club
c.) Apocalypse
d.) Mr. Sinister
e.) The Brood
f.) Other (be specific)

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!
b.) Yes, but as a cameo and give him a bigger role for "X5"
c.) No, there're too many mutants to focus on already

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
a.) Yes!! Why is she with Bobby?!?
b.) Yes, but not in "X4" -- save it for "X5"
c.) No, thanks. She's with Bobby, remember?

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
a.) Yes, keep it true to the comics
b.) Yes, but only for Rogue. Rogue could always be adopted. Besides, isn't Mystique a bit young looking to be his mom? (Thanks a lot, Brett Ratner!!)
c.) Yes, but only for Mystique. Isn't Rogue not related to any of them 'cause of her home with the D'Ancantos in "X-Men"?
d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
a.) Yes, I'd love to see the metal wings in "X4"
b.) Yes, but in another sequel
c.) No, I like the angelic wings fine

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)
a.) Storm's weather control powers
b.) Colossus's armored form
c.) Iceman's ice powers, including the ice sled (Why wasn't it in "X3"? What a gyp!!)
d.) Kitty Pryde's phasing ability
e.) Cyclops's optic blast, if he returns
f.) Other

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
a.) Havok
b.) Forge
c.) Polaris
d.) White Queen
e.) Magneto's grown-up children, twin siblings Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch
f.) Other

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
a.) X1's team of writer David Hayter and director Bryan Singer
b.) X2's team of writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Bryan Singer
c.) team of X3 writers Zak Penn and Simon Kinberg and director Brett Ratner
d.) writer David Hayter and director Brett Ratner
e.) writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Brett Ratner
f.) writers Zak Penn and Simon Kinberg and director Bryan Singer
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new


Thanks for reading and, hopefully, for your answers. When I get enough replies, I'll start the petition and then I'll put up a post with the link where people can sign it. By the way, don't forget about the other petitions already out:

"Give Rogue her other powers in 'X-Men 4'"
http://www.petitionthem.com/?sect=detail&pet=2762

"Make Cyclops a lead character in 'X-Men 4'"
http://www.petitionthem.com/?sect=detail&pet=2763


Thanks again and have a good evening.



Sincerely,
Stuart Green

 

[flavio_lebeau]

1)
-Halle Berry
-James Marsden
-Anna Paquin
-Ellen Page
-Shawn Ashmore
-Kea Wong
-Daniel Cudmore
-Kelsey Grammer
-Ben Foster

2) d

3) b/c

4) a

5) e

6) b

7) a/b

8) a

9) b

10) d

11) b

12) c

13) a/d

14) A

15) c (Just quick flriting scenes, no Gambit/Rogue drama)

16) I don't want him back (d)

17) c

18) a/e

19) Psylocke

20) b (Impossible)

I dn't think you'll get many responses

 

[RogueSB]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- Famke Janssen as Jean Grey
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut


#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him


#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
c.) Cyclops


#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well


#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
b.) Yes, but as a villain. It's possible she could turn back into Dark Phoenix mode.


#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Beast


#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Rogue


#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!


#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
d.) All of the above (so what if the budget explodes?!?)


#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
a.) YES!! It's been three movies!! Let's see her fly!!


#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!


#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.


#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
d.) Mr. Sinister


#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!


#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
b.) Yes, but not in "X4" -- save it for "X5"


#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
c.) Yes, but only for Mystique. Isn't Rogue not related to any of them 'cause of her home with the D'Ancantos in "X-Men"?


#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
b.) Yes, but in another sequel


#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)
c.) Iceman's ice powers, including the ice sled (Why wasn't it in "X3"? What a gyp!!)


#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
e.) Magneto's grown-up children, twin siblings Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch


#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
b.) X2's team of writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Bryan Singer

 

[November Rain]

a decent story...

some sort of time travelling story line involving apocalypse, a failed cure, and sentinels.

 

[Canemacar]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
c.) No, he has had three movies and a solo film

I chose C instead of D because I knew he'd have to be in it.

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
b.) Storm

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
d.) Nope, he's dead, buddy -- let it go, dude

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
e.) No, let her rest in peace.

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Beast

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Storm

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
b.) Sure, why not? It's been three movies and some actors would be too costly to get back.

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
b.) Beast

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
d.) No, just keep the absorption power. The other powers aren't necessary.

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
b.) No, two of them are dead, remember?

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
d.) Mr. Sinister

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
-For the love of God, and all that is holy, NO!!!

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
c.) Yes, but only for Mystique. Isn't Rogue not related to any of them 'cause of her home with the D'Ancantos in "X-Men"?

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
a.) Yes, I'd love to see the metal wings in "X4"

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
f.) Other - Gambit's kinetic manipulation

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
b.) Forge

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new

 

[alfmartinez]

1)
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel

2) c

3) c

4) b

5) d

6) a

7) d

8) b

9) b

10) b

11) b

12) b

13) c

14) a

15) a

16) c

17) a

18)
b
c

19) f: Cable!!!

20) a

 

[Hulkster]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Famke Janssen as Jean Grey
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Kea Wong as Jubilee

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
c.) No, he has had three movies and a solo film

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
c.) Cyclops

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
a.) Yes, have her as an X-Man and have her be with Cyclops already! It's been three movies, Fox

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
c.) Iceman

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Rogue

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
b.) Beast

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
a.) YES!! It's been three movies!! Let's see her fly!!

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
c.) No, he's been in three movies and he's cured. Have someone new.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
f.) Other (be specific) - Mr. Sinister & Hell Fire Club

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
b.) Yes, but as a cameo and give him a bigger role for "X5"

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
b.) Yes, but not in "X4" -- save it for "X5"

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
c.) Yes, but only for Mystique. Isn't Rogue not related to any of them 'cause of her home with the D'Ancantos in "X-Men"?

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
b.) Yes, but in another sequel

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
e.) Cyclops's optic blast, if he returns

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
a.) Havok

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new

 

[Wicked]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
c.) Cyclops

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
e.) No, let her rest in peace.

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Beast
and/or
d.) Pyro

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Rogue

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
b.) Beast

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
d.) No, just keep the absorption power. The other powers aren't necessary.

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
b.) No, two of them are dead, remember?

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
c.) No, there're too many mutants to focus on already

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
c.) No, thanks.

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
b.) Yes, but in another sequel

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
c.) Iceman's ice powers, including the ice sled (Why wasn't it in "X3"? What a gyp!!)
and/or
e.) Cyclops's optic blast, if he returns

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
e.) Magneto's grown-up children, twin siblings Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
b.) X2's team of writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Bryan Singer
or
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new

 

[Majik1387]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth
- Ray Park as Toad
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelly Hu as Deathstryke
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man
- Other

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
c.) No, he has had three movies and a solo film

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
c.) Cyclops

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
e.) No, let her rest in peace.

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Angel
e.) Colossus

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Rogue
c.) Kitty Pryde
d.) Jubilee

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
c.) Maybe a few, but there are a few that need to stay.
(If you chose c., say who shouldn't be recast)
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth
- Ray Park as Toad
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelly Hu as Deathstryke
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
d.) All of the above (so what if the budget explodes?!?)

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
f.)Let her powers be latent

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
b.) No

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
a.) Yes!! Why is she with Bobby?!?

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
c.) No, I like the angelic wings fine

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)
b.) Colossus's armored form
c.) Iceman's ice powers, including the ice sled (Why wasn't it in "X3"? What a gyp!!)
d.) Kitty Pryde's phasing ability
e.) Cyclops's optic blast, if he returns

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
a.) Havok
b.) Forge
c.) Polaris
e.) Magneto's grown-up children, twin siblings Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch
f.) Other - Hellion, Rictor, Avalanche, Siryn, Banshee

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new

 

[Feyd Rautha]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Kelly Hu as Deathstryke
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
b.) Storm


#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
d.) Nope, he's dead.

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
e.) No, let her rest in peace.

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Beast

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
c.) Kitty Pryde

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!


#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
b.) Beast

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
d.) No, just keep the absorption power. The other powers aren't necessary. They should however do something effective rather than have her sit around.

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
b.) No, two of them are dead, remember?

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
c.) No, he's been in three movies and he's cured. Have someone new.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)
d.) Mr. Sinister

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
a.) Yes.

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
c.) No, I like the angelic wings fine

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
a.) Storm's weather control powers

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
d.) White Queen

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
b.) X2's team of writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Bryan Singer

 

[Angamb]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?

- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
c.) No, he has had three movies and a solo film


#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
b) Storm
c.) Cyclops

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
e.) No, let her rest in peace.

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Angel
e.) Colossus

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
b.) Rogue
d.) Jubilee
e.) Mystique

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
d.) All of the above (so what if the budget explodes?!?)

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
d.) No, just keep the absorption power. The other powers aren't necessary.

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)
b.) The H*llfire Club
d.) Mr. Sinister

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
b.) Yes, but not in "X4" -- save it for "X5"

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
d.) No, not for any of them.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
b.) Yes, but in another sequel

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)
a.) Storm's weather control powers
c.) Iceman's ice powers, including the ice slide (Why wasn't it in "X3"? What a gyp!!)
d.) Kitty Pryde's phasing ability
f.) Angel

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
d.) White Queen

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new (Whedon)

 

[Angamb]

What about a compilation? The results to date?

When I see threads like this and with so many post looking the same, I never read all, so would be nice to see how is going the survey.

________________________________________________________

Here are some of the first questions (I'll add the rest later):

RESULTS TO DATE


#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST? (Bold= the 5 most wanted)

- Anna Paquin as Rogue (9)
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast (9)
- Ben Foster as Angel (9)
- James Marsden as Cyclops (8)
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde (8)
- Ian McKellen as Magneto (7)
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique (7)
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman (7)
- Kea Wong as Jubilee (7)
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine (6)
- Halle Berry as Storm (6)
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier (6)
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus (6)
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro (5)
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler (5)
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man (4)
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth (3)
- Famke Janssen as Jean Grey (2)
- Ray Park as Toad (1)
- Kelly Hu as Deathstryke (2)
- Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut (2)

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
a.) Yes, he's the star
b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him (3)
c.) No, he has had three movies and a solo film (5)
d.) No, do not include him at all (1)

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
a.) Xavier
b.) Storm (4)
c.) Cyclops (7)
d.) Wolverine

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well (6)
b.) Yes, but in a supporting role (1
c.) Yes, but for flashbacks and keep him dead
d.) Nope, he's dead, buddy -- let it go, dude (2)

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
a.) Yes, have her as an X-Man and have her be with Cyclops already! It's been three movies, Fox!! (1)
b.) Yes, but as a villain. It's possible she could turn back into Dark Phoenix mode. (1)
c.) Yes, but as a supporting character.
d.) No, have her in flashbacks and let Cyclops mourn her. He ends up with White Queen later anyway. (1)
e.) No, let her rest in peace. (6)

 

[TKing]

*Red indicates my answers*

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier (as a cameo, reintroduced fully in X5)
- Famke Janssen as Jean Grey
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth
- Ray Park as Toad
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelly Hu as Deathstryke
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man
- Other

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
a.) Yes, he's the star
b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him
c.) No, he has had three movies and a solo film
d.) No, do not include him at all

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
a.) Xavier
b.) Storm (until X5, when Cyclops takes over his rightful duty)
c.) Cyclops
d.) Wolverine

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well
b.) Yes, but in a supporting role
c.) Yes, but for flashbacks (not dead, but like Xavier, more so a cameo, and then in X5, expand on his return)
d.) Nope, he's dead, buddy -- let it go, dude

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
a.) Yes, have her as an X-Man and have her be with Cyclops already! It's been three movies, Fox!!
b.) Yes, but as a villain. It's possible she could turn back into Dark Phoenix mode.
c.) Yes, but as a supporting character.
d.) No, have her in flashbacks and let Cyclops mourn her. He ends up with White Queen later anyway.
e.) No, let her rest in peace (you can have too much of a good thing).

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Angel
b.) Beast
c.) Iceman
d.) Pyro
e.) Colossus

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Storm (a personality and a purpose to go with those powers)
b.) Rogue
c.) Kitty Pryde
d.) Jubilee
e.) Mystique

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!
b.) Sure, why not? It's been three movies and some actors would be too costly to get back.
c.) Maybe a few, but there are a few that need to stay.
(If you chose c., say who shouldn't be recast)

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
a.) Mystique (leave her for a later sequel)
b.) Beast
c.) Nightcrawler
d.) All of the above (so what if the budget explodes?!?)

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
a.) YES!! It's been three movies!! Let's see her fly!!
b.) Yes, but not permanently -- just for a short while.
c.) Nope, but she could absorb Sunfire's powers like her comic counterpart currently has.
d.) No, just keep the absorption power. The other powers aren't necessary. e.) Nope, she's cured (at least for now).

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!
b.) No, two of them are dead, remember?

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
a.) Yes, how can you have an X-film without him?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary. (not as an adversary at all, he can see the error in his ways)
c.) No, he's been in three movies and he's cured. Have someone new.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)
b.) The H*llfire Club
c.) Apocalypse (for later sequels)
d.) Mr. Sinister (for X4)
e.) The Brood
f.) Other (be specific)

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!
b.) Yes, but as a cameo and give him a bigger role for "X5"
c.) No, there're too many mutants to focus on already

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
a.) Yes!! Why is she with Bobby?!?
b.) Yes, but not in "X4" -- save it for "X5"
c.) No, thanks. She's with Bobby, remember?

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
a.) Yes, keep it true to the comics
b.) Yes, but only for Rogue. Rogue could always be adopted. Besides, isn't Mystique a bit young looking to be his mom? (Thanks a lot, Brett Ratner!!)
c.) Yes, but only for Mystique.
d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
a.) Yes, I'd love to see the metal wings in "X4"
b.) Yes, but in another sequel
c.) No, I like the angelic wings fine

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)
a.) Storm's weather control powers
b.) Colossus's armored form
c.) Iceman's ice powers, including the ice sled (Why wasn't it in "X3"? What a gyp!!)
d.) Kitty Pryde's phasing ability
e.) Cyclops's optic blast, if he returns
f.) Other

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
a.) Havok
b.) Forge
c.) Polaris
d.) White Queen
e.) Magneto's grown-up children, twin siblings Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch
f.) Other

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
a.) X1's team of writer David Hayter and director Bryan Singer
b.) X2's team of writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Bryan Singer
c.) team of X3 writers Zak Penn and Simon Kinberg and director Brett Ratner
d.) writer David Hayter and director Brett Ratner
e.) writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Brett Ratner
f.) writers Zak Penn and Simon Kinberg and director Bryan Singer
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new

 

[pyro9vivacita]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- Famke Janssen as Jean Grey
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Aaron Stanford as Pyro
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelly Hu as Deathstryke
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Vinnie Jones as Juggernaut


#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?

b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him
Alot of times I get really sick of him.

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
Not Wolverine!!!!!!!!! Cyclops then Storm but since Cyc is dead I would put Storm in lead .......If I was director I would have Jean and Cyc come back and have Storm and Cyc fight for the leader position.

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
a.) Yes, have her as an X-Man and have her be with Cyclops already! It's been three movies, Fox!!

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
e.) Colossus... It's about time now and give him some action not just throw wolvie around or throughing a couple of punches.

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
d.) Jubilee....I love her soooooooooo much...This is what I think... let Rogue be a woman and have her powers and let jubilee be in rogues place now.


#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
b.) Sure, why not? It's been three movies and some actors would be too costly to get back.


#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
a.) Mystique well all three blue mutants are really good fighters and kicks butt but I'm thinking Mystique because she's a classic!!!


#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
a.) YES!! It's been three movies!! Let's see her fly!!


#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!


#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.
.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)
b.) The H*llfire Club
With the sentinels let Magneto help the X-men at the end of the movie
and Hellfire club with the Pheonix

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!
and let him be with Rogue.....

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
a.) Yes!! Why is she with Bobby?!?

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
c.) No, I like the angelic wings fine

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)
a.) Storm's weather control powers
Come on she controls the weather not just lighting and wind...I want to see hail, heavy rain to blind her enemies, more fog!

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
c.) Polaris
d.) White Queen


#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
a.) X1's team of writer David Hayter and director Bryan Singer

 

[FaT_tONle]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:

- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?

d.) No, do not include him at all

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?

c.) Cyclops

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?

a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.

e.) No, let her rest in peace.

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?

a.) Angel

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?

b.) Rogue

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?

b.) Sure, why not? It's been three movies and some actors would be too costly to get back.

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?

b.) Beast

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?

b.) Yes, but not permanently -- just for a short while.

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?

b.) No, two of them are dead, remember?

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?

c.) No, he's been in three movies and he's cured. Have someone new.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?

d.) Mr. Sinister

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?

a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?

b.) Yes, but not in "X4" -- save it for "X5"

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?

d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?

b.) Yes, but in another sequel

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?

e.) Cyclops's optic blast, if he returns

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?

d.) White Queen

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?

g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new


http://www.petitionthem.com/?sect=detail&pet=2762

 

[javphonic]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Tyler Mane as Sabretooth
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel

#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
b.) Storm

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?

e.) He's hinted at being alive, not seen

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
e.) No, let her rest in peace. for now

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Angel
e.) Colossus

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Storm

#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
b.) Beast

#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
b.) Yes, but not permanently -- just for a short while.

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
b.) Include him, but not as the main adversary.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
a.) Sentinels (The Danger Room training session in "X3" doesn't count)

f.) Other
Senator Craydon Creed: son of Mystique + Sabretooth, angry at mutants because they abandoned him, plans to use Lang's sentinels to wipe out mutant populace

Steven Lang: the inventor of the Sentinels

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
b.) Yes, but not in "X4" -- save it for "X5"

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
a.) Yes, keep it true to the comics

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
b.) Yes, but in another sequel

#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)
a.) Storm's weather control powers

#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
d.) White Queen

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
a.) X1's team of writer David Hayter and director Bryan Singer

 

[Angamb]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ian McKellen as Magneto
- Rebecca Romijn as Mystique
- Alan Cumming as Nightcrawler
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel
- Eric Dane as Multiple Man

Only 5 x-men? curious.... hehe

And apart from this, I updted the most wanted returning characters. Nice to know who they are. See a few posts back.

 

[Canemacar]

Only 5 x-men? curious.... hehe

And apart from this, I updted the most wanted returning characters. Nice to know who they are. See a few posts back.

You going to tally up the rest of the answers too?

 

[Angamb]

Yes, I'll be adding the rest of the results in the next days. I can't do it all together, it needs time.

And Canemacar, do you only want to see in X4 those 5 x-members?

 

[Canemacar]

Not just them, some of the others could be re-cast. I just thought those actors captured the essence of their character pretty well (just remove Anna P, I forgot to take her out of that list).

 

[Angamb]

I'd love to see Anna again, and with a better role, a sexier look a good action sequences. I think X4 will be the film that will give us a good Rogue, my opinion, of course.

 

[Canemacar]

I'd rather she just have a bit part. I'm tired of Rogue and all that self-absorbedness that goes with her.

Hopefully, Gambit won't be paired with her if they do deign to put him in a film.

 

[MrSinisterX3]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:
- Hugh Jackman as Wolverine
- Halle Berry as Storm
- Patrick Stewart as Xavier
- Famke Janssen as Jean Grey
- James Marsden as Cyclops
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Kea Wong as Jubilee
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel


#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?

b.) Include him as a lead, but don't have it revolve around him


#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
a.) Xavier


#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
a.) Yes, and as not only the leader, but a main character as well


#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
a.) Yes, have her as an X-Man and have her be with Cyclops already! It's been three movies, Fox!!



#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?

e.) Colossus

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?

d.) Jubilee


#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!



#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?

b.) Beast



#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?
a.) YES!! It's been three movies!! Let's see her fly!!



#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
a.) YES!! That'd be SWEET!!


#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?

c.) No, he's been in three movies and he's cured. Have someone new.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?

d.) Mr. Sinister


#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!


#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
a.) Yes!! Why is she with Bobby?!?


#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
d.) No, not for any of them. Just have him back.

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
a.) Yes, I'd love to see the metal wings in "X4"


#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?
Choosing from any of the following, as many as you want
(Rogue isn't included 'cause of her own category)

e.) Cyclops's optic blast, if he returns


#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?


d.) White Queen


#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?

b.) X2's team of writers Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty and director Bryan Singer

 

[Stuart Green]

6/8/2007


Thanks for all of your comments and answers so far, everyone. I really appreciate it. Remember, you have until Saturday to reply to this survey, because that's when it closes. The actual petition goes up on Sunday and I'll link you to where you can find it then. Thanks again and have a good evening.


Sincerely,
Stuart Green

 

[X-Maniac]

#1.) WHO SHOULD RETURN IN THE CAST?
Pick from any of the following, as many as you want:

- Halle Berry as Storm
- Anna Paquin as Rogue
- Ellen Page as Kitty Pryde
- Shawn Ashmore as Iceman
- Daniel Cudmore as Colossus
- Kelsey Grammer as Beast
- Ben Foster as Angel


#2.) SHOULD WOLVERINE BE THE MAIN CHARACTER AGAIN?
d.) No, do not include him at all

#3.) WHO SHOULD LEAD THE X-MEN?
b.) Storm

#4.) LET'S SAY CYCLOPS SURVIVED. SHOULD HE RETURN?
d.) Nope, he's dead, buddy -- let it go, dude

#5.) OKAY, THEN. SO, IF CYCLOPS DOES RETURN, SHOULD JEAN GREY COME BACK TOO? AFTER ALL, SHE IS NAMED PHOENIX FOR A REASON.
e.) No, let her rest in peace.
(* in my X4 script she might 'appear' in one flashback/dream scene)

#6.) WHICH MALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Angel
e.) Colossus
* both need more character development

#7.) WHICH FEMALE X-CHARACTER SHOULD HAVE A BIGGER ROLE THIS TIME?
a.) Storm
b.) Rogue


#8.) SHOULD ANY ONE BE RECAST?
a.) NO WAY!! Most of the cast wants to return anyway, so let 'em!!
(I'd rather they weren't recast, but it depends on the story, availability, contracts, cost etc)

#9.) WHICH BLUE MUTANT SHOULD RETURN IN THE FILM?
b.) Beast


#10.) SHOULD ROGUE RETURN, SHOULD SHE PERMANENTLY GET MISS MARVEL'S POWERS SOMEHOW EVEN IF THEY MAKE UP A NEW CHARACTER WITH HER POWERS (A LA NEW CHARACTER JASON STRYKER WITH MASTERMIND'S POWERS IN "X2") THAT SHE ABSORBS THE POWERS FROM OR BY SOME OTHER MEANS?

* none of your answers, i have something else in mind

#11.) IF CYCLOPS AND JEAN RETURN, WOULD YOU LOVE TO SEE A SCENE WITH THE ORIGINAL X-MEN (XAVIER, CYCLOPS, JEAN, ANGEL, BEAST AND ICEMAN) TOGETHER?
b.) No, two of them are dead, remember?

#12.) SHOULD MAGNETO BE THE MAIN VILLAIN OR NOT?
c.) No, he's been in three movies and he's cured. Have someone new.

#13.) IF MAGNETO ISN'T BACK AS THE MAIN VILLAIN, WHO SHOULD BE?
f.) Other

#14.) AS IF I HAVE TO ASK THIS. SHOULD GAMBIT BE INTRODUCED?
a.) YES!! I've been waiting since the first movie, so please bring him in!!

#15.) IF GAMBIT IS INCLUDED, SHOULD HE END UP WITH ROGUE?
c.) No, thanks. She's with Bobby, remember?
(not at this point anyway)

#16.) IF NIGHTCRAWLER RETURNS, SHOULD HIS FAMILY TIES TO ROGUE AND/OR MYSTIQUE BE EXPLORED?
* I don't really want him back, it's time to move on

#17.) IF ANGEL RETURNS, SHOULD HE BECOME ARCHANGEL?
b.) Yes, but in another sequel


#18.) WHOSE POWER(S) WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE MORE OF MOST ON FILM?

a.) Storm's weather control powers
c.) Iceman's ice powers, including the ice sled (Why wasn't it in "X3"? What a gyp!!)


#19.) WHICH NEW CHARACTER (BESIDES GAMBIT) DO YOU WANT TO SEE MOST?
d.) White Queen
f.) Other

#20.) FINALLY, WHO SHOULD WRITE AND DIRECT "X4"?
g.) None of 'em -- give it to someone new (I should write it! And someone new should direct it. Wonder if Sam Raimi or Gore Verbinski fancy it?