The Dark Knight Joker Casting Threads [merged-30]

The Joker

  • Lachy Hulme

  • Johnny Depp

  • John Tuturo

  • Jude Law

  • Adrian Brody

  • Jim Carrey

  • Tim Roth

  • Steve Buscemi

  • Crispin Glover

  • Bruce Spence

  • Benicio Del Toro

  • Willem Dafoe

  • Vincent Cassel

  • Christopher Eccleston

  • Mark Hamill

  • Paul Bettany

  • Jason Lee

  • Lachy Hulme

  • Johnny Depp

  • John Tuturo

  • Jude Law

  • Adrian Brody

  • Jim Carrey

  • Tim Roth

  • Steve Buscemi

  • Crispin Glover

  • Bruce Spence

  • Benicio Del Toro

  • Willem Dafoe

  • Vincent Cassel

  • Christopher Eccleston

  • Mark Hamill

  • Paul Bettany

  • Jason Lee


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Brian2887 said:
Kind of big names for what I assume is a small, supporting role.

Watts is Australian, I think. Elizabeth Hurley comes to mind. Minnie Driver.. Piper Perabo isn't British, but she's in Nolan's The Prestige, and seems like a good candidate..

No, Watts was born in England and then raised in Australia.

Hurley and Driver should be kept in mind, but I don't think it will be Hurely only cause she's 40 and this rumor posted clearly states someone in her late thirties. Perabo is in fact starring in The Prestige, but she's not in her late thirties yet nor is she British.

Right now, I think Driver and Winslet are two big bets. Though Rachel Weisz is currently rumored for Talia by some, she does match up to who the actress might be.

Anyone else have someone in mind?
 
Brian2887 said:
Kind of big names for what I assume is a small, supporting role.

A small role with potential for further development in sequels. They may just introduce her here, then bring her back later on in a larger role.

I still dont like the idea of a late 30's Harley. I was thinking more mid/late 20's. I just cant see Harley being older than Joker (Bettany and Hulme are like 35, Brody is 33).
 
We can pretty much assume Joker will be captured and placed in Arkham in the film. I like the idea of having Dr. Quinzel being his treating physician. They could show her sympathizing with him. Like it was said earlier, larger development in a later sequel. She should look young though (late 20's, early 30's).

I do not like Gyllenhaal as Dent. Too young.

Bettany seems to be the man right now. Can't say I have a problem with it (especially from those manips).
 
sinewave said:
while i agree that gylenhaal isn't right for the role of dent, i do think he's an excellent actor, he's just too young for the role. trust me, he's an amazing actor. just watch donnie darko or moonlight mile if you don't believe me. he's done a lot great movies other than brokeback mountain.

Come on man lol, I know who Jake is, I have seen all his films INCLUDING Bubble boy (on tv for lack of bordem and curiosuty as to how the hell this guy came from that to where he is), I still think he is not a good actor and should not be in Batman, especially as Dent.

This whole Joker thing is giving me a headache. If he is just a really white guy who looks nothing like The Joker I will be pissed. I WANT A DAMN CRAZY CLOWN WHO KILLS PEOPLE! Not some British arms dealer who juses the name Joker!
 
Jett clarified over at the BOF forums that he meant the skin would be more "natural" looking. Though the origin of how he got that pasty white skin is still left unanswered.

I'm going to take a guess that Joker, from the accident, was left completely white, including body hair. Something snaps in his head, and he takes up the image of a Joker card (theatricality comes into play here, just like Batman) by dying his hair and putting on lipstick. Probably something along those lines is what Nolan is going for. But personally, I'd prefer if his whole origin was left unsaid.
 
BK said:
Jett clarified over at the BOF forums that he meant the skin would be more "natural" looking. Though the origin of how he got that pasty white skin is still left unanswered.

I'm going to take a guess that Joker, from the accident, was left completely white, including body hair. Something snaps in his head, and he takes up the image of a Joker card (theatricality comes into play here, just like Batman) by dying his hair and putting on lipstick. Probably something along those lines is what Nolan is going for. But personally, I'd prefer if his whole origin was left unsaid.

Me too. As for looks, I hope it's the traditional green hair and white skin. I'd like it too look a little different from Nicholson's though, maybe with the hair being black with green highlights (like B:TAS), and maybe a dark, kind of grayish white.

Anyway, since I'm nored, I'd like to post my update for my ever changing top five choices.

5. Sean Penn
3024123_10.jpg

He has yet to show his potential to play a truly sick and demented character like The Joker, but since Penn has already proven himself to be such a great actor, there's no doubt in my mind he can pull off The Joker. There's only one qualm I have with casting him, and that's what puts him at the bottom of my list: Sean Penn would never do a comic book movie. Still, I think he'd be an amazing Joker.

4. Paul Bettany
paul+bettany.jpg

I have, to date, only seen Bettany in one movie (Master & Commander), and I was initially against casting him for the part. However, the more pictures I see of him, including some excellent manips, the more I think Bettany could really pull off an excellent Joker. His roles in Firewall and The Da Vinci Code should make him more well known, and prove that he could do a good villian. Plus, he definitely has the eyes. He's not my top choice, but I wouldn't mind Bettany at all.

3. Adrien Brody
adrien-brody02.jpg

For a short while, Brody was actually my top pick. He has since fallen a bit, but I still think he'd be an awesome Joker. He's a great actor he's one of the few actors who has The Joker's long chin and nose, and he's an Oscar winner. But most importantly, he's actually expressed interest in doing the role. My only qualm is that he's yet to show us that he can convincingly pull off an over the top lunatic like The Joker. He proved that he can do quiet creepy in The Village, but he has yet to show us he can do lively and energetic creepy. That being said, there's no doubt in my mind that he could do the part.

2. Tim Roth
tim_roth_01.jpg

Man, could he do this part. For the longest time, Roth was my top choice, unil my head told me that it would be a safer bet to go with someone who's actually in the running. Roth is such an amazing actor, especially when it comes to playing villians. Only his good friend Gary Oldman (aka Jim Gordon) is better than Roth at playing villians. He's a bit old for the part (he's turning 45 this year), but he has far more than enough talent to pull off the role.

1. Johnny Depp
depp_johnny-Johnny%20Depp.jpg

C'mon, he's the man. If there's one actor who can do just about everything, it's Johnny Depp. He proved in Once Upon A Time In Mexico (and to a lesser extent, Charlie & The Chocolate Factory) that he can do creepy, and his grin as Captain Jack Sparrow would look so awesome as The Joker. He would define The Joker for a new genration. In reality, Depp probably won't get it because he's too big a name, but the mere fact that he's rumored for the part makes him my top choice for the role.
 
That would suck still, he should be reconfigured, not play dress up with lipstick and ware regular clothes, I bet he wouldn't even be in purple. I remember way back when the rumor was that he would be a British arms dealer and not e The Joker we have grown to know and love.

Like I posted before, DAVID GOYER HIMSELF said that when it comes time to do the Joker he would not let us down because of the '89 film, cause he is himself a fan. I seriously doubt that we will get this stuff from BOF. I'm almost poistive we will get The Joker we have grown to know and love.

Rumors are rumors....like The Reaper.....like the red baron....like Clint Eastwood as Mayor of Gotham.

It's way to early to specualte and they don't have the license to make up to much more stuff like the origin film. Remember he is already made by the end of the "Begins" and Batman has no idea who he is, so he obviously has nothing to do with Joker's origin, we won't get the red hood or anything from "The Killing Joke". As far as I am concerned his origin is going to be a mystery still, in film and in print. We should not speculate som much or we will drive ourselves crazy lol.
 
spanish39, no one has ever at any point in time said that Joker would be a British arms dealer. It was PENGUIN who was (still is) rumored to be a british arms dealer. You really need to read this stuff more carefully before jumping to conclusions. Next you'll be telling me you're upset that Bob Hoskins is a Joker candidate and you dont think Harvey Dent should be played by a late 30's British actress.
 
You can't say NO ONE at any point in time has said that cause I clearly remember reading it here. It's not my fault if someone else miscommunicates information from BOF to SHH! but I don't have all the free time int the world to read all the news on all the Batman sites like some people, just this one. Besides what do you care if I have the wrong idea? Is that any reason to be rude and saracatic when you tell me to get my facts straight before jumping to conclusions? If thats the idea I had then thats the opinion I had of it so I posted it wether it's the fact or not. There are much nicer ways of putting things besides being an a$$ ya know. Maybe next time you post towards me you won't be so negative about it. Simply tell me that it's not the right facts and nicley tell me what it is without trying to show me up or put me in my place, I was misinformed this time.

I don't know why everyone buys in too all this stuff, you all think Penguin, Joker, Two-Face, Earl, Maroni, and maybe Talia will all be in the next film together?....come on now, thats just too much and wishful thinking now. I could see Joker as the villian, DENT as a lawyer (not two-face), and a cameo of Penguin (very brief) talking to Earl, and Hoskins as Maroni or Thorne maybe as the mob boss in the background as a secondary villian, but even thats all stretching it. It's my dream to see all the villans attacking Batman and Gotham all at once like a comic, just like everyone else, but as of now it is only speculation and wishful thinking.

All I'm saying is don't get your hopes up, thats all I'm saying nothing more or less so please don't jump me with words that I'm pi$$ing on the party here please.
 
don't know why everyone buys in too all this stuff, you all think Penguin, Joker, Two-Face, Earl, Maroni, and maybe Talia will all be in the next film together

The Talia rumor is most likely false, and Two-Face isn't unitl the third film. That leaves us with Joker, Penguin, Earle, Maroni, and Black Mask which you forgot to mention. It's entirely possible that they could be villains in the next film and work just fine together, although I see no reason to bring Earle back. Save Talia for a later film and bring Ra's back with her.
 
Like I said, I would love to see all of them but I personaly won't get my hopes up till it gets closer, it would be great. I did forget Mask in that long list of hopefuls, I think cause I have only read it once after that post or something, anyway,

I also would love to see Black Mask on film....along with Hush of course cause Hush is a bad a$$, but mask seems to new to be on film already, I would presume anyway. It just seems like a lot but would be nice if written properly. My only concern is that Joker won't get as much screen time as he deserves in my opinion if he has to share with Batman and all the other hopefuls, if it does all fall together than I would hope Joker would be #1 king and end up at the top at the end without dying or having to guess if he is dead, (like Ra's). One thing that would not make sense for Mask is if this is right after "Begins" than Mask does not really fit into the mythos of Batman's early work. I see Joker and Dent and maybe Penguin, but Mask would not make sense unless he was called by his real name and did not wear the mask, maybe a hentchman or something who later down the road is the guy who becomes tha Black Mask. But I don't think they have creative control over that stuff, (like Raimi and Spider-Man), how they take on a life of their own. DC and WB is very strong like that with their films and materil....just a though or observation or whatever.

Also, I just remember all the B.S. (even from Jett) way back when I first came here, all the rumors like Eastwood and Reaper and Clock King and Red Baron and on and on....I bought into alot of it so thats why I am so reluctant to not buy into it this time. Not that everyone thought it was B.S. at first, it just tuned out that way in the long run. So please don't take it personal if I play the skeptic to such wonderful news because I have been bitten by the Batman rumor bug too many times in the last 3 years to get my hopes up...again though...it would be great :up:
 
I'm very glad to hear that Paul Bettany's name is in the front running for the Joker (as I would much rather see him than Lachy Hulme), but it's STILL no contest for me...

:joker: VINCENT CASSEL AS JOKER! :joker:
vincent_cassel_00290010.jpg
 
he is cool, but and a great actor, like him in Ocean's 12, but he does have a very heavy French accent that would probably be hard to mask, but I never know so.....I bet Nolan and everyone have not even looked him up yet.
 
I am not it has been mentioned (do not have to look back at the threads) is that after watching the Green Mile last night, another actor should be considered. Sam Rockwell! His performace so nutty and insane even his look semi-screamed the Joker.

people-304-samrockwell.jpg
zapod.jpg
 
tecnowraith said:
I am not it has been mentioned (do not have to look back at the threads) is that after watching the Green Mile last night, another actor should be considered. Sam Rockwell! His performace so nutty and insane even his look semi-screamed the Joker.

people-304-samrockwell.jpg
zapod.jpg

I really like Rockwell, he is tied with Brody at second place for me. Bettany though just owns the role IMO.
 
Shoemeister said:
I'm very glad to hear that Paul Bettany's name is in the front running for the Joker (as I would much rather see him than Lachy Hulme), but it's STILL no contest for me...

:joker: VINCENT CASSEL AS JOKER! :joker:
vincent_cassel_00290010.jpg
Another great choice. That picture symbolizes the Joker perfectly, it screams out Joker and he's not even in any prosthetics, makeup, etc. I saw a great manip from that picture once but I don't know where it is.
 
tecnowraith said:
I am not it has been mentioned (do not have to look back at the threads) is that after watching the Green Mile last night, another actor should be considered. Sam Rockwell! His performace so nutty and insane even his look semi-screamed the Joker.

people-304-samrockwell.jpg
zapod.jpg
I can't see him as The Joker, but he would make a great Creeper.
 
There are a lot of posts for actors that look like Joker but not many of them can act the part. Mark Hamill proves he can deliver both qualities. Vincent Cassel looks great but he's freakin' French. They would have to hire Mark Hamill anyway just to dub in the voice. The pics I posted of Mark Hamill look pretty good. If you notice the poll at the top of the thread Mark comes in fourth. He should have an opportunity to show what he can really do with the character.
 
Here are a couple quick manips I did of a Bettany pic that I found. The costume and hair of course are not right for the movie but I liked his facial expression here. I am going to play around with photoshop and do some more manips I think, they are so much fun!

creepy_1.jpg

creepy_3.jpg

creepy_2.jpg

creepy_4.jpg
 
Is that really Bettany? Funny, doens't quite look like him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,359
Messages
22,092,060
Members
45,886
Latest member
Elchido
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"