• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

The Dark Knight Lifting the Bat-Bells: Bale's Physique

Lol. Thanks. I actually liked lost boys and parts of 8mm. And I also met a person who worked with him and said he was a nice guy. He should just stay away from Bat movies:woot: .


Lost Boys, Phone Booth, Phantom, I like several of his movies as well. But yeah, Joel wasn't the right person for Batman. Everyone likes a joke every now and then but sometimes people take the gay jokes too far and I get tired of them. That Schumacher comment you made was just an open invitation for them, but no problem though. I know you were just kidding.
 
Lost Boys, Phone Booth, Phantom, I like several of his movies as well. But yeah, Joel wasn't the right person for Batman. Everyone likes a joke every now and then but sometimes people take the gay jokes too far and I get tired of them. That Schumacher comment you made was just an open invitation for them, but no problem though. I know you were just kidding.
I understand what you mean and completely agree with you. :yay:
 
Bale looks leaner indeed but I think I prefer that rather than to heavy. He looks like a mean little bat.:woot:
 
It's stupid to complain about this crap. Even in real life, people's weight changes all the time.
That depends. If Batman, or any athlete is trying to gain lean mass or lose excess pounds, then yes of course, his weight will change. People like Batman have incredible control over their bodies, much like myself and most of my friends in Bodybuilding and modelling. Average people flucuate because they have poor diets and inconsistent activity levels. Aside from water weight, an athlete who is trying to maintain a weight level can do it...and many do.

If Clark Bartram (from Batman: Dead End) were playing the part, I doubt you'd see much flucuation...especially considering his year round career as a fitness personality/model. Bale is a different case though. Bale's weight flucuates yes, but not like a normal person. Most "normal" people don't yo-yo like celebrities do. I need you to play a fattie in this film, they an aging drug addict, they a musical legend, then a 1940s mobster, then an olympic athlete.
Why is it not believable that after doing what he does, Bruce Wayne's physique won't change at all?
Again depends. Batman in comics is typically depicted as a big dude, particularly so with certain artists. You'd have to assume, at least somewhat though, given Bruce's described history that his physique would be somewhere around where he'd want it when he started crime fighting. I don't see the God of prep time deciding to go off crime fighting when he didn't feel is physique was good enough.
And either way he doesn't look to be in bad shape at all. So what's the problem? I doubt few people here could dedicate themselves physically to a role like Bale has.
Bale does what he can, which is pretty good considering he takes on roles like Bob Dylan and POWs.

In the end it's more or less "you get what you pay for". If, god forbid, Vin Diesel or Clark Bartram were playing Batman and he came back all emaciated for the next movie you'd be like "WTF Vin, people PAY you to be big". That's not what people pay Christian Bale for. Christian Bale is a serious actor seeking an oscar nomination right now. I'm sure he takes Batman: The Dark Knight as seriously as he can given all the other things on his plate. True, I'd love it if Bale played Batman and no one else, just devoted all his time to Batman. However, on the same token I genuinely enjoy seeing him in films like Rescue Dawn, The Prestige, The Machinist and I'm Not Here. And of course all those films affected the current Bat franchise.

So the moral of the story is, if you want good acting you might just find yourself sacrificing appearance and physique. Frankly I'd love to have someone who could act like Bale, and could look like an action hero...but those are few and far between if ever.
 
I don't see anything that's been sacrificed. The dude looks to be in fine shape to me.

Almost 20 years ago, in the end almost no one really cared about how fit Michael Keaton looked when they finally saw the movie. They cared that he looked good in the suit, and he did. He sold it.

Bale looks to be in good shape, so he doesn't look like freaking Ed McGuinness style Batman, so what.

Can you guys only get off on this version of Batman if he's freaking ripped to the gills and jakked? And have you even seen pics of him shirtless in the movie to prove this?

Once again, I doubt anyone here can do for a role physically what Bale has.
 
I don't see anything that's been sacrificed. The dude looks to be in fine shape to me.
He's in good shape. He's not in Batman's shape. Clark Bartram and the people used by BatintheSun films are in Batman's shape.
Almost 20 years ago, in the end almost no one really cared about how fit Michael Keaton looked when they finally saw the movie. They cared that he looked good in the suit, and he did. He sold it.

Bale looks to be in good shape, so he doesn't look like freaking Ed McGuinness style Batman, so what.
I mean as I say, that's the sacrifice. Rarely if ever can big guys act. Why? Because they spend all their time gettin' big while guys like Bale and Keaton take acting lessons. No surprise there.
Can you guys only get off on this version of Batman if he's freaking ripped to the gills and jakked? And have you even seen pics of him shirtless in the movie to prove this?
Bale might be ripped, he certainly isn't big though. Although I can't weigh him without knowing how dense his bones are or how much he naturally weighs, he's not over 200...that's for damn sure (BTW he wasn't in the first film either, at least not in his shirtless scenes...that was some bullsh** lying...I remember the article quoting him "between 200-220" according to his publicists, like they don't have a goddamn scale lying around).

Honestly, I guess I would say I'd rather a good actor who maybe isn't as big as I like is preferable to a bad one who can get as big as he wants.
Once again, I doubt anyone here can do for a role physically what Bale has.
Physically I'm bigger and in better shape than Bale is. My friend Dan, who works out with me, looks like Jim Lee draws him.
 
He's in good shape. He's not in Batman's shape. Clark Bartram and the people used by BatintheSun films are in Batman's shape.

This is based on what? Who the hell is Clark Bartram and BatintheSun?

I mean as I say, that's the sacrifice. Rarely if ever can big guys act. Why? Because they spend all their time gettin' big while guys like Bale and Keaton take acting lessons. No surprise there.

:whatever:

Why does Batman need to look like he's on roids for you to like his physique?

Bale might be ripped, he certainly isn't big though. Although I can't weigh him without knowing how dense his bones are or how much he naturally weighs, he's not over 200...that's for damn sure (BTW he wasn't in the first film either, at least not in his shirtless scenes...that was some bullsh** lying...I remember the article quoting him "between 200-220" according to his publicists, like they don't have a goddamn scale lying around).

Seriously, what is this big flipping concern with his weight? Do you watch a Tom Cruise movie thinking about how short the guy really is? Does Tom Cruise come off like 5'7" in all his movies to you?

I don't understand why he has to be over 200 lbs. for you to accept the role.

I see guys in ridiculous shape on THE ULTIMATE FIGHTER that weigh in at 155-170, that have amazing physiques. So why does he have to be 200-220?

Honestly, I guess I would say I'd rather a good actor who maybe isn't as big as I like is preferable to a bad one who can get as big as he wants.

So you wouldn't rather have this Clark Bartram scrub?

Physically I'm bigger and in better shape than Bale is. My friend Dan, who works out with me, looks like Jim Lee draws him.

So maybe you should play Batman. But until I see you beat Bale in a 100 yard dash, I don't believe a word of this.
 
This is based on what? Who the hell is Clark Bartram and BatintheSun?
batinthesun.jpg

clark_4_big.jpg

Bartram you probably know from "Batman: Dead End"...which was a horrible film and I don't know why Batman fans like it *shrug*.
Why does Batman need to look like he's on roids for you to like his physique?
Because of this.
Batman%20655.jpg

Batman's a big guy. He's drawn big, he's always been drawn big. Superman's always been drawn big. If this were a Spider-Man movie or a Speedball movie I'd wouldn't want Jacked McJackenstien playing the lead role. Same logic applies.
Seriously, what is this big flipping concern with his weight? Do you watch a Tom Cruise movie thinking about how short the guy really is? Does Tom Cruise come off like 5'7" in all his movies to you?

I don't understand why he has to be over 200 lbs. for you to accept the role.
I never said I didn't accept the role, I said I didn't accept it physically. What's your hang up on Bale needing to fit that aspect. There are other aspects to a role besides physique. Acting for example. The ability to interact well with your co-stars. The chemistry you have with your director. Your dedication to learning your lines and showing up on time. All of which, by the way, are much more important to pulling off a role than physique. Acting is a craft of illusions. Just like Keaton made me accept a guy who I could crush with one hand could be a vigilante, so too can Bale convince me a guy who doesn't train for twenty years is in fact a man who trained for twenty years. Movies always have suspension of belief, it comes with the territory. If Bale actually threatened to beat me up in a Bat costume, I'd laugh at him in real life...but it's not real life so I can deal with it.
So you wouldn't rather have this Clark Bartram scrub?
Again, you've missed my point, I'd much prefer an oscar caliber actor. What does that mean, it's means I'm not ever gonna get Clark Bartram unless by some fluke a man who spends his life training magically pulls oscar acting ability out his ass.


So maybe you should play Batman. But until I see you beat Bale in a 100 yard dash, I don't believe a word of this.
I outlift him, I outrun him, I outperform him. Why? Because I spend all my time training for athletics. He spends his time training for acting. There is nothing wrong with having different lifestyle. Bale himself admits he hates working out, but unless being thin is a sign of athleticism (which, BTW, it isn't), Bale isn't honestly that athletic. Bale likes reading, practicing accents, spending time with his kids, researching new roles...wow, acting stuff. It's almost like, instead of wanting to weight train all the time he wants to act...astonishing.

But I'll take that back when Bale gets two Rugby National Championships under his belt, One Bodybuilding competition, four years of High School Soccer, Six years of cross country running and five years of weight lifting and two years of boxing under his belt. Honestly, though, I don't think Bale would trade his passion for mine.

BTW, if Bale was an athlete, you'd probably have to ask yourself why he needs another athlete to come in and do all his "stunts" for him? I don't need another guy to come in and run a race for me, or box a match for me because I couldn't do it myself.
 
batinthesun.jpg

clark_4_big.jpg

Bartram you probably know from "Batman: Dead End"...which was a horrible film and I don't know why Batman fans like it *shrug*.

Batman's not a body-builder, I don't know why he has to look like this.

Because of this.
Batman%20655.jpg

Batman's a big guy. He's drawn big, he's always been drawn big. Superman's always been drawn big. If this were a Spider-Man movie or a Speedball movie I'd wouldn't want Jacked McJackenstien playing the lead role. Same logic applies.

Sorry, but that doesn't look like Clark Batram to me. Bale looks a lot more like this image in the costume than Batram in DEAD END to me.

I never said I didn't accept the role, I said I didn't accept it physically. What's your hang up on Bale needing to fit that aspect. There are other aspects to a role besides physique. Acting for example. The ability to interact well with your co-stars. The chemistry you have with your director. Your dedication to learning your lines and showing up on time. All of which, by the way, are much more important to pulling off a role than physique. Acting is a craft of illusions. Just like Keaton made me accept a guy who I could crush with one hand could be a vigilante, so too can Bale convince me a guy who doesn't train for twenty years is in fact a man who trained for twenty years. Movies always have suspension of belief, it comes with the territory. If Bale actually threatened to beat me up in a Bat costume, I'd laugh at him in real life...but it's not real life so I can deal with it.

You are the only person that seems to have a hang-up about it. I have no hang-up because from everything I've seen he seems to be in good shape, and I don't know what you are basing on the fact that he isn't.

In real-life the concept of a guy dressing up as a bat and fighting criminals is rather silly.

Again, you've missed my point, I'd much prefer an oscar caliber actor. What does that mean, it's means I'm not ever gonna get Clark Bartram unless by some fluke a man who spends his life training magically pulls oscar acting ability out his ass.

Yet I still don't see why his physique is not to your liking.

I outlift him, I outrun him, I outperform him. Why? Because I spend all my time training for athletics. He spends his time training for acting. There is nothing wrong with having different lifestyle. Bale himself admits he hates working out, but unless being thin is a sign of athleticism (which, BTW, it isn't), Bale isn't honestly that athletic.

Yet I doubt you would look better in a bat-suit than Bale :p .

But I'll take that back when Bale gets two Rugby National Championships under his belt, One Bodybuilding competition, four years of High School Soccer, Six years of cross country running and five years of weight lifting and two years of boxing under his belt. Honestly, though, I don't think Bale would trade his passion for mine.

Man, why didn't WB hire you as Batman, you seem almost resentful of Christian Bale not having the dedication to athleticism that you do.
 
No body here is claiming bale is a bad actor guys but his physique does leave alot to be desired in this movie. He looks to be in the 165-175 range. That is small in Batman world sorry. Batman is usually in the range of 6'2-6'4 and well over two hundred pounds he is supposed to be big. It is much easier to knock someone out with a single blow if you have an extra 30 pounds of functional muscle thats just the facts. Now I don't have the link but from what I remember bale was at 220 about 2 months before fimlming and he admits he could not do a single pushup. As filming progressed he had gotten down to about 190 which for him is a good size. Bale is not a professional athlete and you can't expect the same kind of dedication as what he did for the first movie but he should have taken at least a cycle to get ready it seems to me like he just ran for this. I'm not saying this destroys the movie I'm just saying this dedication everyone keeps talking about is not there this time. It takes a month at optimum protein levels and proper dieting and lifting to gain 3 pounds of muscle I think he had enoug time to at least gain ten to twelve pounds and ad to that a cycle and he would have been just as big or bigger for this movie. Part of the appeal of begins was his size. He was bigger then everyone else and that drew you to him now it seems we are going to be ore surprised by the villain and that is pretty lame. Batman needs to be the center of the story he needs to be larger then life and I'm sorry part of that is physique.
 
Batman's not a body-builder, I don't know why he has to look like this.
Actually Batman is a bodybuilder, as are almost all Superheroes. The bodybuilder physique template is what's used to draw them. This even goes back to Jack Kirby. There's a reason comics so heavily advertised the "Charles Atlas" and "Steeve Reeves" characters back in the day...because they were inspired by the same Herculean forms that inspired bodybuilders.
Sorry, but that doesn't look like Clark Batram to me. Bale looks a lot more like this image in the costume than Batram in DEAD END to me.
That's a fairly tradition most muscular pose. Perhaps here is a better picture to show you want Clark Bartram really looks like.
bartram01.jpg

He's not flexing to the hilt there.
You are the only person that seems to have a hang-up about it. I have no hang-up because from everything I've seen he seems to be in good shape, and I don't know what you are basing on the fact that he isn't.
He's certainly a skinny guy. He's probably looks good with his shirt off. No arguement there. But is he in the shape of a costumed vigilante who has been training since his parents got shot back when he was nine? No! But Clark Bartram, who BTW has several black belts in several martial arts, has been training that long. He, like me, grew up reading Batman and wanted to look like that. Again, I don't fault Bale for not being Batman's size, or cut, or strength, or speed, or being as good of a fighter. Of course not....if he was all those things I wouldn't be called acting because he wouldn't have to act in the first place.
In real-life the concept of a guy dressing up as a bat and fighting criminals is rather silly.
True, but if Bartram came up to me dressed in a bat costume and wanted to kick my ass...while I might find that Bat costume rather silly...I still wouldn't want to take my chances with him.
Yet I still don't see why his physique is not to your liking.
...Because that's not Batman's physique. But again, that's really a non issue. Movies always are known for finding ways around these things. Just like they find a way to kill a guy in a movie and make him appear dead without actually killing him, they find ways to make skinny actors appear to be action heroes with a little movie magic.
Yet I doubt you would look better in a bat-suit than Bale
I have 8% bodyfat. A six pack. Trained bodybuilder. In Bale's suit I'd probably look no different because Bale's suit has all that mesh and plastic molded padding. But in terms of walking around with my shirt off...I'm better looking body wise than he is in that Ring of Fire picture.
Man, why didn't WB hire you as Batman, you seem almost resentful of Christian Bale not having the dedication to athleticism that you do.
I'm not. I'm glad they hired an actor. I'd make a terrible Batman...might make a good stunt man, but that's about where my acting range would end. Jump through a window, I'm on it. Give a speech about my motivation as a character...uh, no thanks. I'd never want them to hire Tom Brady, Clark Bartram or the BatintheSun guys no matter how much more they look like Batman. They can't act. The only people I resent is FOX for not having the smarts to cast me as Cyclops.
 
Batman is a bodybuilder? There was no proof he is. They just draw him big in comics to look heroic. If he was a bodybuilder, he was have done bodybuilding compeition then. But since he hasn't, he just a man who has some muscles. But that doesn't mean he is a bodybuilder.
 
No, he's not a 'bodybuilder', but he does lift weights and he is very big.


Just as he is skilled at many different areas of science, but that doesn't make him a chemist.
 
Batman is a bodybuilder? There was no proof he is. They just draw him big in comics to look heroic. If he was a bodybuilder, he was have done bodybuilding compeition then. But since he hasn't, he just a man who has some muscles. But that doesn't mean he is a bodybuilder.
He may not compete in bodybuilding...that's kind of irrelevant though..., but the way he is drawn is based on Bodybuilder physique.
Mr. Socko said:
No, he's not a 'bodybuilder', but he does lift weights and he is very big.
Bodybuilders are the only weight lifters who care about size, shape and proportion. They train for it since all their training revolves around hypertrophy. Ironically so do comic artists, though not for the same reasons. Art is all about aesthetics, making something appealling to the eye. Comic artists choose a very dramatic, large and sculpted look for comic characters all of which comes from bodybuilding roots.

Batman may not himself be a Bodybuilder, but in real life if you wished to appear as Batman did in the comics you'd have to take up bodybuilding...or at least apply the same principles to your workout as a Bodybuilder would. Simply weight lifting wouldn't cut it.
 
Wow, this has got to be the dumbest argument I've ever seen here.

VileOne, no one's saying that Bale's size ruins the movie. We're just saying that he doesn't look the part as well as he did for Begins. And it doesn't help that the suit makes that very apparent.

Newsflash : Batman is big. No, he's not a damn bodybuilder, but he's a guy who's physical presence should be intimidating. Nobody wants the Dead End guy to play Batman in a real movie, but Bale set the bar pretty high in Begins and has obviously failed to match that in TDK.

No one's ever gonna match the exaggerated proportions of the comics, but when Batman looks like pencil-neck wimp, it takes away from the effect.
 
When I look at Bale playing Bruce Wayne or Batman, pencil-neck wimp doesn't come to mind. So I don't get where this nitpicky crap is coming from.

Yeah Bartram is not a guy that looks like Batman to me with those kind of guns, maybe Superman, but whatever.
 
All people woried about his physique are moaning about nothing is bales sizr gonna make you boycott the movie if it isnt up to your silly standards? no i thought not.
 
All people woried about his physique are moaning about nothing is bales sizr gonna make you boycott the movie if it isnt up to your silly standards? no i thought not.

That sentence was absolutely stunning until "bales sizr". Anyway, I'd prefer Bale looking as he did in the first film. Either way, I'm happy.
 
I suppose Michael Keaton was a f'n stud.

This whole thread is kind of gay I mean the suit really makes Batman not the actors muscles.

West, Keaton, Kilmer, Clooney...

None of them are body builders or even have a six pack so why are you people analyzing every detail of another mans body like this?

It's the Suit always has been and always will be. Now whether you like the suit being muscular, nipply, puffy, or trim that's a whole new discussion and thread.

But definitely a discussion that makes more sense.
 
There are going to be people that like the suit and hate the suit, even for the first movie.

A lot of people thought it was an amazing improvement over the older movies, other people thought it was too bulky and constraining or whatever. Apparently this new suit is more maneuverable, people still don't like it.

I think the suit looks cool, the manga and anime influences are undeniable. However I also wouldn't have minded a less high-tech looking and simpler design scheme, though not quite like Dead End, better than that.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
201,549
Messages
21,987,952
Members
45,780
Latest member
TaciturnTerror
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"