kguillou
Avenger
- Joined
- Dec 30, 2005
- Messages
- 26,932
- Reaction score
- 25,622
- Points
- 103
I remember hearing this complaint when it came out, and it never really bothered me. I guess because if I were to reverse the scenario, and resources my people desperately needed were on a planet that was otherwise covered in 70% molten lava or poisonous gas or something, I'd still believe if was worth going if options were sufficiently limited. If they were even here for resources, that is.
I haven't seen it in at least 10 years, though, so I'm not necessarily denying it's dumb AF, lol.
To each his own, but I ain't following you to no lava planet.

But even besides that, the movie's plot is nonsensical. Lawd, did I groan when the "twist" happens and its that Mel's wife's last words were a premonition telling Joaquin Pheonix to SWING A DAMN BAT at the aliens. I'm--I'm sorry, what? I'm not a stickler for script contrivances in movies usually but to me that was just plain B.A.D. Like, you would get an F in film school if you turned that script in bad.