Superman Returns Man of Steel: The Official Brandon Routh Thread

Favorite Moment Featuring Routh As Superman

  • Plane Sequence

  • Lois & Superman Flight

  • Saving Metropolis

  • Other (Describe In Thread)

  • Plane Sequence

  • Lois & Superman Flight

  • Saving Metropolis

  • Other (Describe In Thread)


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
^True. It's not Nolan or Snyder or anyone else but Singer and his blatant COPY of Donner's films!

Routh's at least getting some roles out there and seems to be doing okay. From what he's said, he has a good outlook on it and realizes the opportunity it gave him. He's a good kid, and we can at the very least wish him well.
 
Welling was never in consideration for Superman since the old days, 03ish.

Routh was WB's guy up until last year.

The gameplan changed with DC Ent was formed, Robinov stepped into Horn's shoes, and Nolan was brought in. Robinov, Nelson and the other players at DC Ent have no connection to Routh. The top brass that wanted Routh as Superman are irrelevant nowadays.

It's essentially a different situation for the two of them.

He was "there guy" until his contract expired. If they had known what in the hell they were going to do with the franchise (sequel, reboot, etc.) then maybe Routh might have had a legitimate shot since he was already under contract. Routh was convenient.

Also, I am not a Routh hater by any means. In all honesty, I thought he did pretty well overall with what he had to work with. I just don't think Nolan will choose him seeing as he has ties to SR. It's the same reason I know Tom Welling won't get it despite how much I wish otherwise. You can't really compare Welling/Routh to Nicolas Cage in terms of reprising roles. No offense to Ghost Rider but...well, did any of you all see it? Look at both movie franchises. Ghost Rider the movie is not even close to being in the same league as the Superman franchise.
 
He was "there guy" until his contract expired. If they had known what in the hell they were going to do with the franchise (sequel, reboot, etc.) then maybe Routh might have had a legitimate shot since he was already under contract. Routh was convenient.

Also, I am not a Routh hater by any means. In all honesty, I thought he did pretty well overall with what he had to work with. I just don't think Nolan will choose him seeing as he has ties to SR. It's the same reason I know Tom Welling won't get it despite how much I wish otherwise. You can't really compare Welling/Routh to Nicolas Cage in terms of reprising roles. No offense to Ghost Rider but...well, did any of you all see it? Look at both movie franchises. Ghost Rider the movie is not even close to being in the same league as the Superman franchise.
He was only under contract for a sequel though, right? I mean, if they reboot, or whatever one wants to call something that's not a sequel...then it's a completely new set of contracts et al, no?
 
I really feel for Routh. the guy is a huge fan just like us, and he did whatever he could with the limited time he had on screen in Superman Returns.

WB are a real *******s.

Routh deserves better. He IS Superman. Its a damn shame if we don't see Routh again.

Reboot, remake ffs whatever you want to call it, I still say Routh should be top choice.

WB are a disgrace, they themselves were happy to spend big money on Singer's movie, and then when it didn't make a billion dollars they cried like *****es.

disgraceful.

WB is a joke when it comes to Superman. They don't deserve to have this property, they can't do anything properly with it.

Seriously? It would be one thing if the movie destroyed the box office, ala Inception, but it didn't even double it's own production cost! The WB and Snyder, as much as you want to deny it, are doing the right thing by trying to distance itself from any previous take. Why in the world would they make another sequel to the Donnerverse when it failed the first time?? :doh:

No logical person would drop that kind of money on such a risk...
 
He was only under contract for a sequel though, right? I mean, if they reboot, or whatever one wants to call something that's not a sequel...then it's a completely new set of contracts et al, no?
It probably wouldn't have been a guaranteed deal, anyway. Seeing as he was coming in as a nobody he probably had zero leverage in the agreement and they had all the power, anyway.
 
Seriously? It would be one thing if the movie destroyed the box office, ala Inception, but it didn't even double it's own production cost! The WB and Snyder, as much as you want to deny it, are doing the right thing by trying to distance itself from any previous take. Why in the world would they make another sequel to the Donnerverse when it failed the first time?? :doh:

No logical person would drop that kind of money on such a risk...
Well, it also didn't help that Singer went and pulled a crafty move like completing a $10 million Return to Krypton sequence that ended up on the cutting room floor. Singer would probably still have the director's spot if he would have been fiscally responsible like he was on the X-men films instead of them giving him the keys to the family sedan with no curfew, so to speak.
 
i don't see problem if brandon to play superman again in the reboot, revamp or whatever.
 
Well, it also didn't help that Singer went and pulled a crafty move like completing a $10 million Return to Krypton sequence that ended up on the cutting room floor. Singer would probably still have the director's spot if he would have been fiscally responsible like he was on the X-men films instead of them giving him the keys to the family sedan with no curfew, so to speak.
Don't make too much of the alleged $10M cost of the cut scene. Scenes get cut all the time in movies, even big ones, and because of creative reasons, not price tag. The rest of the stuff that didn't make the final film, combined, could easily reach that amount...and in terms of percentage of overall budget, other movies can have have cut material which exceeds it. The cur RTK stuff only really matters to core fans who knew about it and wanted to see it.
 
Last edited:
Tomorrow October 9 is Brandon's birthday. He'll be 31.

Happy Birthday to our AWESOME SUPERMAN! :supes:

BRANDON-ROUTH-superman-returnsjpg.jpg


gotmilklargev2.jpg
 
The fact that Joseph Gordon-Levitt is in that list (because of reader suggestions, no less!) makes it completely ridiculous.
 
Joseph Gordon-Levitt for Mxyplyzyk or Toyman ( he's about the same size as them).
 
Don't make too much of the alleged $10M cost of the cut scene. Scenes get cut all the time in movies, even big ones, and because of creative reasons, not price tag. The rest of the stuff that didn't make the final film, combined, could easily reach that amount...and in terms of percentage of overall budget, other movies can have have cut material which exceeds it. The cur RTK stuff only really matters to core fans who knew about it and wanted to see it.
If I were a businessman, I'd make plenty of it. Not just the cost, but the time and manpower that had to be mobilized, only for it to end up being completely for naught in the end. I've not a single doubt that the other stuff nixed from the final cut cost them time and money as well. Unnecessary dialogue sequences and stuff like that being trimmed are commonplace in any movie. Not saying that the RTK sequence was this all-important thing, but how many employers do you know of that would be thrilled to know you pissed ten million down the commode because you didn't have the foresight during the scripting phase to realize a scene of that magnitude was just plain unnecessary? That's all I'm saying, I guess.

I'm willing to bet they chewed Singer a new one and yanked the choke chain on his leash so he threw a fit and took his ball and went home. I mean, that money could've at least helped to bolster the underwhelming finale sequence with Superman in the city. I liked the movie, but I'll be the first to admit that the plane sequence was the true finale...for me, at least. Anyways, sorry to ramble. I miss Routh...blah, blah, blah...:yay:
 
If it was Kingdom Come, I could see Hamm in the role in a heartbeat. Gordon-Levitt doesn't have the presence to fill the shoes and for as pretty as Bomer is, he's just shy of Ewok height. Welling won't touch the role with a two-meter cattle prod for some reason and as much as it irks me, I think the ship has sailed where Routh is concerned. I'm hoping for another unknown, because the last time the WB cycled through name actors the results were gag-worthy, at best (I'm looking at you Mr. Walker).
 
casting a new guy would get the public confused as the general public have accepted routh as the new superman after Reeve. news related to superman, the media will post pic of routh.

therefore, WB should stick with routh.

the disappointment of SR isn't because of him. so if the wheel isn't broken, why change it?

lastly, Happy Bday to Mr. Routh
 
He's the next George Lazenby, who played Bond only once and was (for the longest time) forgotten till the cult status of his Bond film "On Her Majesty's Royal Service".

This will only get worse IF this new Superman ends up being a hit and popular among fans and movie goers alike. And here's the saddest thing but it's kinda true: I don't think People talk about Superman Returns all too often. And because of that, if they replaced Routh, I don't think will notice or care. I'm talking about the public mind you. Time probably won't be too kind to it.
 
i understand that. i just don't think they should recast the role. and routh looks much much better and manly than previously.

but if they do, i wish the best for the new guy, hoping it is a great hit and popular. afterall, i'm a superman fan first.
 
There isn't anything wrong with loving Routh in the role but it's just silly to believe that re-casting the role will confuse audiences more than keeping him on and making a completely different other Superman movie.

Unfortunately for him they are going a different direction and they have obviously realized that they can't fully go that direction with him onboard. It would be too confusing and the moviegoing public is confused enough as it is so it's dumb to confuse them anymore than you have to.

It's a wrong place at the wrong time situation for Routh. He played in a movie that made some money but was recieved in a meh fashion by atleast half of the audience and then the director started having problems with the studio after they signed him for a sequel. It's just one of those situation where things don't work out.
 
Those who love the movie WILL continue loving it and Brandon's take in it (and whether some like it or not, many people loved the movie, and especially Brandon's performance. The movie was a blockbuster for a reason). I don't see how that will change just because there will probably be a new franchise with a new guy in the tights. I still love Reeve's Superman and some of his movies.

That said, Bring Routh Back please! He Is Superman.
 
He's the next George Lazenby, who played Bond only once and was (for the longest time) forgotten till the cult status of his Bond film "On Her Majesty's Royal Service".

This will only get worse IF this new Superman ends up being a hit and popular among fans and movie goers alike. And here's the saddest thing but it's kinda true: I don't think People talk about Superman Returns all too often. And because of that, if they replaced Routh, I don't think will notice or care. I'm talking about the public mind you. Time probably won't be too kind to it.
Whats that movie then, i dont think ive seen that one??
 
Whats that movie then, i dont think ive seen that one??

It's after You Only Live Twice. Connery left, Lazenby came, movie didn't do well, Lazenby got fired, Connery was begged to come back and was offered a lot of money. He came back and we got that abomination of a Bond movie, Diamonds are Forever.
 
He was being cheeky Giankin, he and I have had some pretty deep Bond conversations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,288
Messages
22,079,779
Members
45,880
Latest member
Heartbeat
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"