Well I haven't seen it here(at all), it's a loin cloth warrior approach, if anything they are showing as much skin as gladiators and gladiators didn't dress they way they did for the cold weather.
Well Raph's get up has been likened to a gladiator by fans and I'd say that's accurate but doesn't that devalue the designers defense that these designs are to reflect their
ninja background.
It also devalues the other defense quoted by people who defend these designs that the turtles are influenced by human society in how they dress. You can get a way with that with Michelangelo even if "look" is very dated but the others particularly Raphael don't seem to be influenced by human society they grew up next to unless there are many guys in loin cloths walking around NYC that I am unaware of.
When it comes to realism in regards to their accessories/attire, it's a simple matter of how is this any less real than what they had on in the original film? Are shoulder pads, leather wraps around the arms soles on their feet a step towards internal logic or is it literally a step away. I'd argue the former.
Like the bandannas the pads are a conceit, I freely admit that. A relatively small one.
If you took the pads are wrist straps away I don't think many fans would mind. On the flip side I don't think many mind them having straps around their feet, these are minor things that I don't think many have much of an issue with either. (
Although I don't know why Don has colored ones his shoulders and why Raph has one leg covered and the other not - stuff like that is were it gets stupid)
As for the loin cloths, like gargoyes, I rather like the idea that intelligent anthropomorphic characters make an attempt to make themselves decent. I find it adds "realism" if you will.
Surely the turtles are already decent. They have no visible genitalia or other body parts considered shameful to cover up.
If it's simply that you feel they would look at humans above and feel the need conform to how they dress (not something I agree the characters should feel) then why not go the whole way with tops, jackets, proper shoes and socks etc?
Not sure what you are saying here. First you say that you don't think they will be wearing back packs and such while chilling in their lair(makes sense), then you say that the idea that they are dressed for battle doesn't fly? Which is it? Do you think they will be dressed like this the entire film? If not, what's the issue?
I'll try and explain better.
If you look at the maquettes compared to everything else we've seen in regards to the turtle designs they are clearly the same but the former are missing.
I'm guessing that in scenes in the lair and similar settings the turtles will of course be clothed but missing those few extra elements. The equivalent of Thor not having his cape in the helicarrier scenes in The Avengers movie.
Secondly, like Leo during that
city fall story, it's not so far fetched or beyond fanboy's ability to accept.
An arc were Leo is brainwashed into becoming a Foot Ninja and was provided with the equivalent of a uniform. That had a point to it, a concrete logic.
Not to mention that it is nowhere near as overly complicated as these movie designs hence why fans actually liked that look.
I mean the fact that shredder is a practicing ninja and he wears clanky armor. If you can accept that he does it in any capacity 'and it still makes sense' you shouldn't have a double standard when the turtles do the same.
Most versions of TMNT Shredder doesn't actually wear armor. He wears a cloth costume resembling a ninja gi which he sometimes adds a helmet and bladed gauntlets so it's not like it detracts from his ability to be stealthy.
Shredder wears his costume "24/7" in the new series as well, I wouldn't go so far as to say the nick show is 'supposed to be goofy. I digress, since when has nonsense ever stopped fans/purists from wanting their source material on the screen...There are fans that still want megatron turning into a gun.
Well I think the new series being very anime inspired is a mix is deliberately goofy and serious but I digress.
The trend of Shredder wearing full on armor started with the 2003 series were again he only wore it during the really epic battles. I think that's why the full on armor is more accepted as it lends itself to an big final battle were the bad guy conveying strength is more important and stealth is not exactly a priority.
Like I said, fans do this time and and again and only history will show if they were right. The batman films are a master class on this, especially when it comes to character origins.
The current success of the Nolan Batman movies and indeed the current crop of super hero movies I believe in part is due to them being true to the source material. Some liberties are taken yes but for the most part Nolan draws a lot from the comics as do the Marvel movies.
Ever stop to wonder why we humans even wear clothes? I mean why did we even start wearing them, in the summer that is? Why, in the original 'planet of the apes' films, are all wearing clothes and such? Apply your answer for that to the turtles, themselves intelligent individuals of 16 or so years...This is literally what the General Audience will do. Fans of course have other plans.
I'm not so sure that's true really. I'm sure the general audience will be somewhat divided on the issue. Comparing it to characters in an anthropomorphised version of ancient Japan is a bit different than characters in a real world setting were they are separate to society.
Also remember it isn't just the idea that the turtles will be wearing it's
these specific clothes that are an issue.
Also it's not just even that it's the whole hulking turtles design. The whole thing is reminiscent of what old men think kids find cool. The kind of thinking The Simpsons parodied back in the day with Poochie the Dog (jeans and shades hmm) and reminiscent of what everyone on Ninja Turtles: The Next Mutation did with their designs (hulking turtles with individualized looks hmm) and we all know how that turned out.
Now I'm sure that if the majority of the rest of the movie is good then I'm sure most people wont mind so much but then....I think you know were I'm heading with this.
Early March he said....you can bank on it he said. I'm still waiting on those magazine covers someone said would be coming out early this month. I guess they were wrong...typical around here. Oh well, what's another 2 weeks supposedly gonna hurt? That is if that producer guy was actually right when he said April 4th for the teaser trailer
He's taken his post off facebook so I'm guessing we shouldn't take for granted we'll be getting then either.