WHF I like you man, but since you said BB is the best superhero movie ever....
I think my friends were probably spot on. Everything I've seen about SR makes it look like the worst ''mainstream'' movie I have seen in a while...everything about it looks pretty poor.
See, X Men had several scenes with heart....like Wolverine and Jean's final moments together. And in Spiderman 2, the scene where the passengers on the train he saves vows to keep spidey's secret. That, for me, is why marvel in general is so wonderful, and so much better than dc. DC are pretty much cookie cutter heroes....Burton beat that with Batman, but thats because he took it in his own direction and didnt try to copy tthe comics too much. DC movies lack the passion and heart (with the odd exception) of the best marvel movies.
Marvel may have done some terribly ****ty movies (daredevil, man thing and punisher) but when they get it right, it's simply sublime. The best DC has managed to do in the last decade was Batman Begins, which to me was simply watchable, yet nothing special.
Just my opinion, but thats why I dont think DC will ever surpass marvel. They just dont have the heart and character.