Norton Reprising the role of Banner = Up to the fans

He is a good actor, but he is no Bruce Banner.
He could play Bruce Banner in his sleep, as a matter of fact he is too good for what will probably be a bit role. I was so bored by Norton in TIH, I'm sorry but I was.

He played repressed brillaintly in Two Lovers.
 
I want someone that looks nerdier than Joaquin and doesn't have as much as a presence as he does. Norton was quiet and reserved in TIH and that is Bruce Banner. Joaquin as Bruce is just as much of a sore thumb as Bana was as Bruce.
 
I think Stephen Moyer (True Blood) would make a good Dr. Bruce Banner.
 
Norton hasn't really been in any films that have the slightest chance of making big money (apart from TIH), he tends to do more grown up films rather than mainstream films for the masses.
then he shouldnt ask to have so much control then. I honestly dont think he wanted alot of control on Avengers but Marvel probably didnt want to go through what they went through on TIH.
 
yet they knew what he was like BEFORE casting him in TIH, and they knew they were building a shared movieverse with their characters, and they knew they were going to include Banner in The Avengers

they knew it all beforehand, yet, they still chose to recast because Norton's, "not a team player"??? Like they're just figuring out his personality NOW?

B to the damn S

I recall a certain little saying that goes something like "don't start what you can't finish"

yet Marvel is punking out like some little *****es
 
This is stupid news. Charge me up as someone who actually liked TIH and Norton in the role as Bruce Banner. Might as well bring back Bill Bixby............. Yeah that'll work.
 
Joachim Phoenix as Banner ? I can't see it. Why didn't they choose to propose him the Namor role ? I'm sure he could shine in the role. But as Bruce Banner, no, I can't see him.
 
yet they knew what he was like BEFORE casting him in TIH, and they knew they were building a shared movieverse with their characters, and they knew they were going to include Banner in The Avengers

they knew it all beforehand, yet, they still chose to recast because Norton's, "not a team player"??? Like they're just figuring out his personality NOW?

B to the damn S

I recall a certain little saying that goes something like "don't start what you can't finish"

yet Marvel is punking out like some little *****es

see this is the part I dont understand. They worked with him on TIH and obviously some friction came out of that...yet weeks ago and even months ago Feige was mentioning how he'd want to see Norton return. So if the reason why Norton isnt coming back because of bad blood from TIH set why even hold negotiations with him???
I know if I was a producer or a director and I had a bad experience with an actor I wouldnt cast them again...unless we decide to bury the hatchet.
Why is it only after negotiations that they deemed Norton as a non team player???? Did he ask for a goblet of green M&Ms in his trailer every day???? Did he request Hulk has to stand in front of everyone else??? Did he request top billing???
IMO this was a pure money decision. This is going to be a big movie and they are going to need to scrimp some change from somewhere. Marvel doesnt have unlimited bank (even though Disney is behind them)
 
It's their loss. Good luck finding a better actor than Norton for the part.
 
I don't see Joaquin Phoenix as Banner.

Also, Norton is hard to work with, but a wackjob like Phoenix is their next choice?
 
marvel can suck the big one 7 ways to sunday, these types of moves are what can turn your audience against you. first you ask us to forget the 2003 hulk ever happened and accept a new actor in the title role and after he was well recieved then you fire him and ask us to do the same all over again. To have a successful character and franchise you need stability and consistency, with the hulk weve had a new actor each movie, atleast with batman, spiderman and ironman and even wolverine there was consistency with the same actors. you end up building an audience and getting them comfortable with this character and the actor portraying them, if you screw that formula up you end up screwing yourself.

atleast dc isnt too quick to suggest a new batman over bale.
 
marvel can suck the big one 7 ways to sunday, these types of moves are what can turn your audience against you. first you ask us to forget the 2003 hulk ever happened and accept a new actor in the title role and after he was well recieved then you fire him and ask us to do the same all over again. To have a successful character and franchise you need stability and consistency, with the hulk weve had a new actor each movie, atleast with batman, spiderman and ironman and even wolverine there was consistency with the same actors. you end up building an audience and getting them comfortable with this character and the actor portraying them, if you screw that formula up you end up screwing yourself.

atleast dc isnt too quick to suggest a new batman over bale.

Fully Agreed
 
I like how popular my comment was, in less than 10 minutes :up:

71939435.jpg
 
I really liked TIH and Norton. This saddens me.
 
Norton wasn't difficult to work with because he's egotistical or just a bit of a clown, he's widely known as a perfectionist and there was a lot of his personal input which went into the whole making of TIH - hence his unwillingness to yield to Marvel on certain issues. As you all know, a number of scenes which were in his version of the script were deleted from the final cut and having watched these on the DVD, I felt they added extra depth to the Banner character in the film and showed Norton having a clear understanding of Banner's motivations and also his angst.

Marvel now want an actor who will simply do what he's told, yet by definition that means we will likely get someone who simply does not have the intense interest and care in the character that Norton developed.

From an acting standpoint, I personally thought Norton played the Banner role very well - he came across as quiet, intelligent, disciplined, determined and also phsyically very close to how Banner is portrayed in most media. Bana didn't do a bad job in the Ang Lee Hulk, but in comparison Norton absolutely nailed it.

Norton's response to Marvel's decision was, as I would expect of him, gracious and diplomatic:

“I am very sincerely grateful to Marvel for extending the offer and even more so for giving me the chance to be a part of the Hulk's long and excellent history,” Norton said before also thanking the fans who’ve supported him as he tried on the iconic role.
I grew up with Banner and Hulk and have been a fan of every incarnation,” Norton said. “I'm really proud, and very blessed, to have been one of them and will be thrilled to see him live on through other actors. Hulk is bigger than all of us, that's why we love him, right?”
 
Norton wasn't difficult to work with because he's egotistical or just a bit of a clown, he's widely known as a perfectionist and there was a lot of his personal input which went into the whole making of TIH - hence his unwillingness to yield to Marvel on certain issues. As you all know, a number of scenes which were in his version of the script were deleted from the final cut and having watched these on the DVD, I felt they added extra depth to the Banner character in the film and showed Norton having a clear understanding of Banner's motivations and also his angst.

Marvel now want an actor who will simply do what he's told, yet by definition that means we will likely get someone who simply does not have the intense interest and care in the character that Norton developed.

From an acting standpoint, I personally thought Norton played the Banner role very well - he came across as quiet, intelligent, disciplined, determined and also phsyically very close to how Banner is portrayed in most media. Bana didn't do a bad job in the Ang Lee Hulk, but in comparison Norton absolutely nailed it.

Norton's response to Marvel's decision was, as I would expect of him, gracious and diplomatic:

Well Said.
icon14.gif
 
Agreed, Elgaz. That was a very nice point.

Still pissed me off, this whole ****ing situation. >l
 
That's funny as hell. We should spam the Marvel updates. Show 'em who's boss! >O!
 
We have 8 more days until we find out if this is a fluke or not. Really hope this is Marvel pulling our legs.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"