Overeem won the 2010 K-1 Grand Prix. These tournaments bring forth some of the world's best strikers varying from Muay Thai, Shotokan/Kyokushin Karate, Savate, Kickboxing, etc.
Now let's move on to his ground game. Overeem won the European ADCC, and has the world's deadliest Guillotine choke (the most feared submission by wrestlers). Enough said.
K-1 is kickboxing. Not MMA.
European ADCC is submission grappling. Not MMA.
I'm sure the best of the best
strikers in the
world fight or have fought there... however in truth being a K-1 Grand Prix champion means as much as being an NCAA champion in MMA.. nothing other than they sound good on your fighting C.V. during your introductions.
Velasquez is a wrestler first and a Boxer second.
Dos Santos is a one-dimensional Boxer.
Carwin only depends on knock power (has never thrown a single combination).
There's your top three HWs in the UFC. Neither of these guys could stand and trade with strikers like Badr Hari, Tyrone Sprong, and Gokhan Saki.
Actually Lesnar would be ahead of Carwin however it is still a moo point I feel. None of the guys you've highlighted ever aspire to be K-1 champions. They aspire to be MMA champions which is the inclusion of ALL disciplines.
Velasquez has a brown belt in Guerrilla Jiu-Jitsu.
Dos Santos has a brown belt under the Nogueira Bros.
Carwin has a purple belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu.
Once again, there's your top three, and their career highlights in the submission game. Two out of the three have yet to lock in a submission.
Again I feel this is another moo point. Dos Santos has hardly grappled at all inside an MMA cage because nobody has managed to get hold of him & get him to the ground without getting KO'd.
None of the fighters are submission specialists either, 1's a boxer/striker & the other 2 are wrestlers that just so happen to be able to strike a little.
It's not hard to believe though that considering they've all got some form of Jiu-Jitsu qualification that they are in some capacity competent in regards to submissions & sweeps.
Don't forget, Overeem was only a ADCC European champion. Let me put that into perspective. Audley Harrison is the EBU European Heavyweight Champion in boxing. He is in the same weightclass as the Klitschko's who would both be eligible to fight for this title if they wanted to.. do you see were I am going with this. The real top boxers
(or in Overeem's case, grapplers) are competing at a world level. While it is fairly impressive to win this for a guy that is primarily a striker.. it's hardly something to sing & dance about in my opinion nor does it mean he is some sort of ground wizard.
While Overeem's win over Werdum wasn't impressive -- I could point out Anderson Silva-Damien Maia or Anderson Silva-Thales Leites or Jose Aldo-Mark Hominick or GSP-Jake Shields. Amazing... I guess you have a short memory when it comes to the UFC's own. Alistair's gameplan was to simply stop the takedown, and he did 85% of the time. Werdum has below average knock out power, Overeem was never in trouble.
...and were have I given you any sort of an indication that I felt any of these performances were impressive wins?
I'm talking about Allister Overeem, not GSP, Silva or Aldo.
By the by, I love that people are also downgrading Fabricio Werdum. The guy who manhandled and derailed two hypetrains in Gabriel Gonzaga and Brandon Vera -- who both are still in the UFC oddly enough. Werdum lost to Arlovski (on points in a close decision) and Dos Santos (who is currently the #2 to #3 HW in the world). Furthermore, Werdum wasn't cut, he walked away just like Tim Sylvia and Andrei Arlovski. The man is the most feared ground specialist in the HW division.
Gonzaga is retired from MMA & now only competes in BJJ. Brandon Vera was cut, then rehired after his 3rd straight lose was to Thaigo Silva.. who had failed a drugs test after the fight.
I don't downgrade Werdum I just don't find him that impressive. He hasn't beat anyone that I personally consider to be a top guy.. Fedor included.
Gonzaga is/was an idiot fighter. He pretty much had a grappling advantage over everyone in the HW division & rather than fighting to his strengths & trying to use his decent striking ability to initiate grappling he tried to exclusively stand with guys. His hype train was ended by Couture btw because his train only started after he'd KO'd Crocop.
Brandon Vera's train was was ended by Tim Sylvia before Werdum.. enough said. Vera has no heart, quits too easy when he is getting controlled on the ground.
In summary, Alistair Overeem is NOT some lacky or mediocre talent that is getting a fortunate chance in the UFC. Overeem is a fighter that has paid his dues in a long career, and is a well-rounded specimen.
I don't think hes a bad fighter if that's what you are getting upset about, however for me personally I don't feel hes any higher up the rankings or more well rounded than Cheick Kongo at this juncture.