Re-cast Mary Jane for ASM3/ASM4

Deborah Ann Woll

 

Nice one. I'm in the Levy camp but I would approve of that.

 

Hell no to the last 3 suggestions.

 

Levy is nice. She could be Emma's sister, though.

 

Yeah Levy as MJ could be a WTF? moment for audiences. It would almost be like Gwen resurrected in red hair. Kinky for sure, but something tells me this isn't the effect the filmmakers would go for. t:

 

Can't be resurrected if they're together in a scene.

 

Okay you guys are going overboard with the look-a-like issues. They're somewhat similar but they aren't twins. People won't be confused.

 

There would be a website or two dedicated to how similar they look.

Seriously, I have no problem with Levy if she got the part, I'd just be surprised if she does considering how much she looks like the character that will be killed off. How could there not be a sense of deja vu?

 

Why am I the only person who doesn't see them casting someone who falls outside of the same 'beauty profile' as Shailene?

Not counting my own suggestions, there have been exactly 3 actresses suggested who fit the same beauty profile as Shailene: Levy, Holland Roden, and Emma Watson.

 

Gal Gadot? i loved her in Fast and Furious 5.

 

How about Phoebe Tonkin?

 

Maybe.

 

^ Someone else - a Tumblr blogger - made the suggestion, but I like the idea and thought I'd share it.

 

The odds of finding someone who looks like a hot model and can hold a scene with Garfield will definitely narrow the field, if not eliminate it. So I think searching for a good actress who's attractive will give the producers the widest field of candadates to draw from. This philosophy is what will dictate the "beauty profile" more then anything.

Levy, Holland Roden, and Emma Watson are all different profiles to me, but all attractive nonetheless.

 

When I look at pics of Emma (Watson), Shailene, Holland, Phoebe (Tonkin), and Saorise (Ronan), I see women who are all beautiful but who still look like the 'girl next door'; Levy has that same 'look' as well, but it isn't a constant with her in the pics I've seen the way it is with the other girls I just listed.

That's what I mean when I talk about actresses with Shailene's 'beauty profile'.

 

Gotcha.

 

Problem is people trying to find exactly same "beauty profile" as Shailene's...if they cast another "beauty" like that i'll again not approve casting. Every time i buyed comics i remembered how lucky was Peter to find such hot and beautifull girl, who loved him as geek. I remmeber how people were jelous on Peter where did he meet such a girl, hell i dreamed always to meet such girl. I never imagined Mary Jane "cute" in that role i always saw more Gwen, similar as Emma Stone is. She is for me more cute girl then hot model girl. And i am sorry to be superficial
but boobs, hotness and top model figures sell stuff. I started watching Arrows just because Katie Cassidy was there and same happend when i started watching Veronica Mars, just because Kirsten Bell was there so and i didnt regret.

 

Although I don't think there's any actual substance or truth to what they're claiming, a Movieweb article posted a few hours ago did put another 'Woodley profile' actress on my radar: Sarah Gadon.

 

Knowing very little of her and not remembering her in what I've seen her in, no real comment really.

I mean, she's no really how I can picture MJ, and I guess she's not the worst a rumor can be based on.

 

I didn't know who she was and didn't initially think she fit the Woodley profile (based on the pic I saw [which was the same thing that happened for me with Levy]), but I checked out a few additional pics and she'd certainly work.

 

"Woodley profile" is the most ridiculous thing I've heard in a while.

 

Agreed, however I would take that terminology over the ridiculous not-hot complaints from trolls.

 

Yeah that's mean spirited. I do hope we get a new MJ though.

 

zeroapoc and Majik, I already explained what I mean when I use the term 'Woodley profile': a woman who's beautiful but still has a girl-next-door 'look' about her.

 

Regarding the rumor, Gadon seems like the antithesis of Woodley in her personality. Not just in the roles she's played but in reality. Woodley comes across as having more spunk and attitude, where Gadon comes across as being more refined around the edges.