Nah the old Neversoft Spidey game on N64, my preferred system of that generation

, rocked.
Yeah it's dated now and doesn't have the cool graphics of today. But it is incredibly fun in it sarcade like gameplay and still can be a bit challenging and every single boss fight was COMPLETELY satisfying and the gameplay was never monotonous but constantly fun and enjoyable. It's like a double nostolgic trip now to play.
SM3 by comparison is either pretty on 360 and bland or ugly and bland on Wii, but with a cool swinging mechanic. Friend or Foe sucks. Yeah...things have "really gotten better."
I will say Spider-Man 2 on PS2 and Gamecube is probably THE best Spider-Man game to date and is amazingly fun and captures a free-roaming adventure that is a lot of fun. But hey, the free-roam is no longer innovative and the graphics are out of date, so should we turn on it? ****, I still get more fun out of Super Mario Bros. 3 than I do most video games released in the last decade.
Anyway the 2000 game has an arcade type feeling that makes it addictive. The first movie game is disposable fun but outside of the GG fights is not worth really remembering, SM2 and USM were good games but USM was too short with little replay. And the last two Spidey games sucked.
So, I think in 2000 everyone was blown away by that game and now the best reaction we can get is "crap" for the last year, then the 2000 game still is worth playing again before SM3.