I've just been reading this thread because Tales of Vesperia headed to the PlayStation now got me thinking that Star Ocean will probably end up doing so as well. Especially since the PlayStation 3 is starting to outsell the Wii in Japan.
Glad that it is happening.
Nothing against the Wii, nothing at all, but i can´t find any logic for the the huge sucess it is.
To be a sucess, sure, kudos to Nintendo....but to be THAT sucessful...
What does it has for it....the motion control, that´s it.
It isn´t even the cheaper console in the market, the 360 Arcade is.
There is no big amount of amazing games in it (sure, there are those, but there is tons of shovelware too)
So, why?
But this post got me thinking about what you said Isildur and I can't help but completely disagree. What the Super Nintendo had going for it with JRPGs was that they were exclusive to the system for the time being and they were great. You had the Final Fantasy IV-VI, the Dragon Quest V and VI, Star Ocean, Chrono Trigger, Super Mario RPG, the Secret of Mana, Tales of Phantasia, EarthBound, etc. And they were all memorable and great.
I respect it, but what exactly to do disagree about?
I never said the 360 was the new Snes (they aren´t), i said they wanted to be, that´s different.
And, as far as a i can remember, even MS didn´t said they were going to acchieve that, they said they wanted to be the console to have for JRPGs, and, in comparison to last gen, they are doing it.
The problem with the 360 JRPGs are that they are ending up multiplatform like Enchanted Arms, the Last Remnant, and Tales of Vesperia. Unremarkable like Blue Dragon, and Lost Odyssey. Or pure crap like Operation Darkness and Spectral Force 3. Hell, the only one I find that has a good reception and is exclusive is Infinite Undiscovery. The PlayStation 3 has pretty much matched the Xbox 360 and is on the way to surpass it.
The only one i have is Blue Dragon, and i like it, but then again, i never was big on JRPGs, so, when people say that BD is a bit JRPG old school, i can´t compare it to anything, so, it isn´t for me.
As for the other, yeah, Operation Darkness and Spectral Force 3 are horrible for all i know.
And i think you must be mistaken, the one with better reviews, and said to be the best JRPG on the 360 (and this gen) is Lost Odyssey, not Infinite Undiscovery.
IMO, the problem is not the 360, but rather the JRPG genre, which is getting to a dead end, it doesn´t evolve.
Even White Knight Chronicles wasn´t very big on the Japonese market.
And the less we talk about Valkyria Chronicles the better, for the game made less than Blue Dragon in Japan.
The point is, the JRPG is dying outside the DS, let´s see if FFXIII can reignite the flame.
Frankly, I can't see neither the Xbox 360 or PlayStation 3 surpassing the Super Nintendo, PlayStation, PlayStation 2, or Nintendo DS
They will not, that´s a given.