then why is the public perceiving it to be one?
and what do you even mean it's not a real short list?
Quite simply, because the public is ravenous for Spidey info and a report through a supposedly reputable site would keep them at bay.
then why is the public perceiving it to be one?
and what do you even mean it's not a real short list?
Ok, but then this also technically means o'brien hasn't even auditioned yet if he even plans to, yeah?The title of the article makes it seem like they are the final five actors in contention.
They aren't. Jeff Sneider even says so in his article. He says that they are among many who have simply read for Marvel. Also, that many will screen test soon, and there is no guarantee they will be among those to screen test.
And if you know anything about this process, you'd know there is no shortlist until screen test offers have taken gone out, and initial screen tests had.
sneider lost a lot of reputability on my end for the whole 95% black spiderman thing.Quite simply, because the public is ravenous for Spidey info and a report through a supposedly reputable site would keep them at bay.
Ok, but then this also technically means o'brien hasn't even auditioned yet if he even plans to, yeah?
sneider lost a lot of reputability on my end for the whole 95% black spiderman thing.
then, it still flies. but honestly...do you even trust the reddit leaker anymore if you did in the first place?How about the idea that this *new* report is based on info that is actually old?
touche.Hence my use of the word supposedly.
Ok, but then this also technically means o'brien hasn't even auditioned yet if he even plans to, yeah?
what's the difference between "reading" for the studio and waiting for a screen test offer?If O'Brien has read for Marvel (based on the Paleyfest incident, I'd say he has), then he's in the position everyone else is right now, and is awaiting a screen test offer.
well it is sneider. do you not remember the bullcrap he tried pulling some odd weeks ago?
well there's that, and now this apparent clickbait shortlist of actors.Oh I remember, but I'm not dismissing him completely.
He reminds me of John Campea in a lot of ways.
then, it still flies. but honestly...do you even trust the reddit leaker anymore if you did in the first place?
These lists are at least good to see what they're planning on going for.
As I've said, the age is really the key here.
I really don't get what you're trying to say here.It doesn't still fly. It may have flown at a certain time in the past, but the current truth is different from the past truth, and the reason the past truth is reported as current news is to sway people's attention away from the current truth they want to keep hidden until they're ready to reveal it.
He's saying it's all an illusion... Mysterio CONFIRMED!I really don't get what you're trying to say here.

what's the difference between "reading" for the studio and waiting for a screen test offer?
na forreal though I want to get what he's saying. at first I asked him if he thinks o'brien never even auditioned and hence kinda told the truth at paleyfest and then he responds to me with what the redditleaker said in response to the shortlist coming at all. but after that it sounds like he's arguing against it. i need him to clarify.He's saying it's all an illusion... Mysterio CONFIRMED!![]()
Ok, so was it you who said that o'brien is in the same boat as everyone else?Reading is the basic audition phase. They have a bunch of actors (dozens, hundreds) come in and read some lines that will give them a sense of their range and fit for the role.
The screen test is basically the callback. Getting a screen test means you're a serious contender. After the screen tests are completed, that's when the list is shrunken to the final group (THE shortlist). And either that group is invited back for a final test (which is usually what happens) or (should one stand out completely over the rest), the actor is chosen.
That age bracket is crazy narrow though. 18-20? Like, dang.
"new" reddit person?Does someone have a link to this new reddit person?
I really don't get what you're trying to say here.
Ok, and are you telling me this as a devil's advocate or do you think o'brien is spiderman?Hypothetical scenario:
Redditleaker reveals that Dylan O'Brien has been cast as Spider-Man from a source.
For the sake of what I'm trying to get at, treat this as actually being true, and then put yourself in the shoes of Marvel. They don't want to announce it themselves just yet. So, knowing that Redditleaker is not a reputable source, Marvel has other people deliberately leak information to seemingly more reputable sites that is either false (i.e. not true at all) or dated (i.e. used to be true but not anymore). And because this information is being revealed by more seemingly more reputable sites, people perceive it as truth, and they perceive it as happening at the time it's reported.
And these seemingly reputable sites are told this from their sources. They're not witnessing these things happen firsthand. They're not scoping out the Marvel and Sony offices like special forces snipers.