Comics The Official ROGUE Discussion Thread

[Rogue's Hand]

And that's a good thing...????

Yes, I'm tired of so many people making fun of Rogue.
I would love for her to kill their favorite mutant.
She's tried being nice, why not take the ruthless route? LOL

 

[Canemacar]

She's tried being nice,

When was this?

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

M-U-R-D-E-R.

Unless it's desperate back-against-the-wall self-defense...

If she does it, she doesn't get to lead a team and talk/preach about doing the right thing. Ever.

 

[Rogue's Hand]

M-U-R-D-E-R.

Unless it's desperate back-against-the-wall self-defense...

If she does it, she doesn't get to lead a team and talk/preach about doing the right thing. Ever.

She went against the grain as soon as she injected Creed.
It's her rules, and now they'll have to deal with them.
Hillary is running for president, it's a new day, LOL.

Ofcourse they'll make it seem like she's defending herself,
but judging by the way she's acting after what happened in issue # 199,
she seems a whole lot more aggresive. I doubt she'll be playing defense
in # 200.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

She went against the grain as soon as she injected Creed.
It's her rules, and now they'll have to deal with them.

Was under the impression that poor command decision most certainly WOULD bite her back in the a$$ and make her lose her top position.

Ofcourse they'll make it seem like she's defending herself
but judging by the way she's acting after what happened in issue # 199,
she seems a whole lot more aggresive. I doubt she'll be playing defense
in # 200.

Dragging Creed around and going homicidal aren't quite the same thing.

 

[spark627]

I really don't think Rogue is behind the death in 200. Making her a murderer is an awful idea.

 

[Canemacar]

I really don't think Rogue is behind the death in 200. Making her a murderer is an awful idea.

She used to be a terrorist working to achieve Mystique's genocidal goals. And she loved it (not my opinion, it's fact that she did).

 

[spark627]

She used to be a terrorist working to achieve Mystique's genocidal goals. And she loved it (not my opinion, it's fact that she did).

I'm fully aware (is that now the tenth time you have said this?).

That is not who she is now. After all this time, I don't think she would turn around and be a murderder, at leats not intentionally. But we don't know what Carey has planned, I never said it was impossible, I said I thought it was a bad idea.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

She used to be a terrorist working to achieve Mystique's genocidal goals. And she loved it (not my opinion, it's fact that she did).

That, and it's not as if Rogue had short fuse or anything.


P.S. Almost done with my last college-related all-nighter of the year. Booyah. t:

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

But we don't know what Carey has planned, I never said it was impossible, I said I thought it was a bad idea.

We *can* all agree on that, right? t:

 

[Canemacar]

P.S. Almost done with my last college-related all-nighter of the year. Booyah. t:

Just pulled an all-nighter myself. High School sucks.

That is not who she is now. After all this time, I don't think she would turn around and be a murderder, at leats not intentionally.

What do you consider leaving someone stranded, without even a shirt, in the middle of Antarctica to be?

 

[spark627]

Just pulled an all-nighter myself. High School sucks.



What do you consider leaving someone stranded, without even a shirt, in the middle of Antarctica to be?

omg, you love to repeat yourself. Rogue of today (and the Rogue of the past how many damn years) is not a mutant terrorist murderer. End of story. IF she were to kill a member of her own team, it wouldn't be so cut and dry. And for the third time, I said this is my opinion, never said it was impossible (just didn't agree with it).

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

What do you consider leaving someone stranded, without even a shirt, in the middle of Antarctica to be?

I *still* can't believe *anyone* would defend Rogue when it comes to that specific offense. t:

I mean, you don't see us Cyke fans defending him regarding the Maddie debacle, now do you??? t:

 

[Canemacar]

omg, you love to repeat yourself. Rogue of today (and the Rogue of the past how many damn years) is not a mutant terrorist murderer. End of story. IF she were to kill a member of her own team, it wouldn't be so cut and dry. And for the third time, I said this is my opinion, never said it was impossible (just didn't agree with it).

she didn't do that during her terrorist days, she did that as an X-man, *to* and X-man.

I *still* can't believe *anyone* would defend Rogue when it comes to that specific offense. I mean, you don't see us Cyke fans defending him regarding the Maddie debacle, now do you???

It boggles my mind. I'm one of the biggest Gambit-fans you'll meet, but even I can acknowledge when he's screwed up.

 

[spark627]

she didn't do that during her terrorist days, she did that as an X-man, *to* and X-man.

Again, I'm aware of that. But that was not murder. I have never defended Rogues actions or denied that leaving Gambit was odd and a stupid thing to do.

You are using that action to say that Rogue will and can be a murderer, that makes no sense, two totally different things.

 

[Canemacar]

Again, I'm aware of that. But that was not murder. I have never defended Rogues actions or denied that leaving Gambit was odd and a stupid thing to do.

You are using that action to say that Rogue will and can be a murderer, that makes no sense, two totally different things.

HELLO! Leaving a man with no clothes in the colest place on Earth, with temps *well* below 0 degrees Farenheit and with no way back to warmer climates, or even food and water or a way to obtain food and water, *IS* murder.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

But that was not murder. [...]You are using that action to say that Rogue will and can be a murderer, that makes no sense, two totally different things.

Leaving someone for dead *kinda* qualifies as murder.

And just for the record, my opinion on said debate has more to do with Rogue's short fuse and how she *might* do it in a combat situation if *really* pissed. t:

Leaving Remy behind was more of a *scumbag* than *murderer* move in my book. Murderers at least watch their victims die and...

No, you know what, I've got *killer* and *murderer* confused. It totally qualifies as attempted murder. t:

 

[spark627]

HELLO!
Whatever, your opinion. Want me to say you win? Will that keep you happy?

Thank god Gambit is coming back, now his fans can stop their nonstop *****ing

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

What we're saying is that her leaving him to die isn't so much an OPINION as a FACT. t:

 

[spark627]

it is a fact, never said it wasn't. Canemacar is using that to defend his theory that Rogue could/is a murderer and it doesn't add up.

It was a stupid thing to do. It was also stupid that he survived and forgave her. The whole plot is ridiculous. Just like the whole Mystique/Foxx plot was ridiculous. Are we really to believe that the alleged affair occured after Remy knew it was Mystique and that his defense might be that she might have been in the disguise of Rogue?

In the real world, Rogue would be held accountable for leaving Gambit, but those logics don't exist in comics, so I can't relate that story to the possibility of murder.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

it is a fact, never said it wasn't. Canemacar is using that to defend his theory that Rogue could/is a murderer and it doesn't add up.

Well, throw in Rogue's short fuse in the equation and it kinda does.

Am not saying she'd go indiscriminately murder anything in sight, but a killing (note I'm not using the plural) in a fit of pique? Not too far fetched. If at all.

 

[spark627]

Well, throw in Rogue's short fuse in the equation and it kinda does.

Am not saying she'd go indiscriminately murder anything in sight, but a killing (note I'm not using the plural) in a fit of pique? Not too far fetched. If at all.

Sorry, I don't think murder is that simple.

I said anything is possible, obviously. I'm arguing that Rogue would go out and murder someone. Could it happen in a battle in a fit of fury, sure, could happen with any character. In my opinion, I don't think Rogue is the cause of the murder (I have stated that I could be completely wrong).

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Having to deal with a killing would make sense, what with that "tough year" ahead.

Not saying it *will* happen, but it wouldn't be a nonsensical farce from a narrative POV.

 

[spark627]

It def could be a part of the tough year ahead. who knows.

A lot of signs point to Mystique being the murdered. She is the only one Mike has not made commented on in terms of the future. (We know Cable, Cannonball, Iceman and Rogue all have things coming up in the next year). Also in the ads for issue 200, Mystique's face is singled out.

 

[DarthCyclopsRLZ]

Just for the record, Can and I are NOT talking about #200 alone.

Not sure I dig the 'grieving over mommy scenario', though. See it happening, but I can't help but worry about Carey going overboard with the inevitable pity party. Oh well.