I love how many are willing to condemn Burton based on still pictures on things such as how they should be lit, etc.
The lighting is correct for those saying it isn't. The light is coming from the left side and we know this because its somewhat blown out in the top left hand corner. Alice is somewhat brighter on the left than the right. Plus, who's to say what the context is of the shot? None of us know.
Burton is experienced enough to know how to talk to his cinematographer and get basic lighting correct. Let's give him a little more credit than that. He knows more about movie-making than any of us here.