Rewatching Batman vs Superman!! Movie has held up better with time!! Only bad thing is WB screwed the pooch big time by rushing justice league!! They should’ve kept building and even if the “new” justice league movie came out after endgame I feel it would’ve been way better than the piece of **** they rushed out!!
The Whedon reshoots swelled
JL’s budget to about $300M. And based on a final gross of $658M (which isn’t insubstantial), it’s been calculated that the movie lost about $60M. (It could have been worse. E.g.,
Blade Runner 2049 lost ~$80M.) But assuming the same gross for a slightly cheaper (say $250M) theatrical Snyder cut, WB might have been looking at a breakeven tally. Or perhaps even a modest profit. Or… would some version of a Snyder cut have made
more than $658M? According to many side-by-side comparisons of the theatrical cut to
ZSJL, almost all of Whedon’s additions and alterations have been deemed conspicuously inferior to the original material. So we might speculate that going with the original/better Snyder stuff (though, obviously not a four-hour version) would have translated to a bigger box office. Of course, quality doesn’t necessarily correlate to box office success (see, again,
Blade Runner 2049). So, who knows? This is all based on hypotheticals and the advantage of hindsight — which, as they say, is 20/20.
(And I agree about
BvS. I just rewatched the Ultimate Edition. It's still impressive.)