6.14 Trespass - Discussion Thread (Spoilers)

[triplet]

If anyone is still interested in this episode... Hulkster kindly let me fill in for him again and my review is now up at The Kingdom.

Trespass - Kingdom

(Might want to put a pot of coffee on first... I went a little long with this one. Not 27 pages long , but long.)

Excellent review...

Yours is far more analytical of the story elements than mine usually is, so you brought up good points I missed in mine.

 

[Serene]

I was just feeling like a coffee. Thanks for the excuse.

Thanks for the help.

Very nice review, I think it is the best one you've done so far.

Very sweet of you to say. I'm glad you liked the humor. I actually had to dial back a few snarky comments that I found funny.. but I'm afraid not everyone would appreciate my sense of humor.

Excellent review...

Yours is far more analytical of the story elements than mine usually is, so you brought up good points I missed in mine.

Thanks, bud. I certainly don't have your technical expertise when it comes to production matters. That the fun thing about reading reviews from people who actually like the show, we still all see different things and it's nice to share those observations with others who actually care.

That said, I'm not sure that I could do this on a weekly basis like you guys do. It's VERY time-consuming.

Thanks guys. (Especially Hulk)

 

[triplet]

Thanks, bud. I certainly don't have your technical expertise when it comes to production matters. That the fun thing about reading reviews from people who actually like the show, we still all see different things and it's nice to share those observations with others who actually care.

That said, I'm not sure that I could do this on a weekly basis like you guys do. It's VERY time-consuming.

Well, it does take a lot of time and I'm actually glad to have a hiatus coming up so I can take a breather and work on other writerly things.

*sigh*

BTW, if anyone was wondering I did turn in a review for this, I'm not sure why Craig hasn't posted it. He's working on his next book, so maybe he's been busy.

I gave this a four....

 

[triplet]

My review's up, finally.

http://www.kryptonsite.com/trespassreview.htm

Maybe in a way it's good news that Craig was working on his next book, he linked to its page over on amazon:

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1840239573/gijoevid

I was getting worried they were going to stop with Season 3.

 

[avidreader]

My review's up, finally.

http://www.kryptonsite.com/trespassreview.htm

Great review Triplet. Nice job!

Maybe in a way it's good news that Craig was working on his next book, he linked to its page over on amazon:

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1840239573/gijoevid

I was getting worried they were going to stop with Season 3.

I thought they were stopping too, in fact I thought I had actually read somewhere that they werent doing any more.

Thanks for pointing that out, 'cause I completely missed it.

 

[triplet]

Great review Triplet. Nice job!

Thanks.

I thought they were stopping too, in fact I thought I had actually read somewhere that they werent doing any more.

Thanks for pointing that out, 'cause I completely missed it.

Well, he pointed that out when he apologized for taking so long to post my review on the news page... I didn't know what he's been working on until I clicked on the link.



It's a good thing. Frustrating that he put off posting my review but I'm glad they're finally doing another one.

 

[jr24tw]

I liked you review too triplet. I always do. Because aside from the obvious Tommy boy love you manage to usually point out the obvious without bias (aka bashing and such).

Just one thing about the Trespass review. You really should be used to them not getting the camera thing right. Where you talk about the fall through the glass. They never get that kind of stuff right. I'm used to it by now. I got used to it trhough the Clana kisses (or almost kisses). They rarely got those right too. The head is always on the wrong side when they switch camera sides.

 

[Riva]

Good review, as always, triplet. I like what you've said about the Clark/Lex barn scene, especially.

 

[triplet]

I liked you review too triplet. I always do. Because aside from the obvious Tommy boy love you manage to usually point out the obvious without bias (aka bashing and such).

Thanks, I try. Craig's previous reviewer apparently had a shipper bias of some kind, but I never read hers so I'm not sure which ship she preferred...

So, he's glad about me not being biased at all (even despite my very obvious Tom/Clark one). I told him when I agreed to "working for him that keeping shipper talk out of the reviews is not a problem, but I am an unashamed Tommy lover and he'd have to put up with that..

He was cool with it, so I'm good with him.

Even given that, I don't give Tom a free pass when I see that he's not doing his best.

Just one thing about the Trespass review. You really should be used to them not getting the camera thing right. Where you talk about the fall through the glass. They never get that kind of stuff right. I'm used to it by now. I got used to it trhough the Clana kisses (or almost kisses). They rarely got those right too. The head is always on the wrong side when they switch camera sides.

Well, that's a minor problem compared to this... this made the scene confusing and the reveal with Clark's feet less effective.

The over the shoulder shots being on the wrong side doesn't always *look* wrong, and it doesn't break the positional awareness of where people are within a scene... them screwing up with this did.

Good review, as always, triplet. I like what you've said about the Clark/Lex barn scene, especially.

Thanks....