Which is probably why it happened in the first place. If you had a 'cheating isn't that bad' attitude before you even cheated on someone, then that explains why you never stopped to think 'Oh, no, I shouldn't be doing this' and didn't do it...
Well...yes. Of course how I felt morally and intellectually about a concept informed my decisions when it came time to make this choice.
Everything you're saying is a justification.
How can everything I’m saying be a justification when I have yet to actually try to justify it? I'm not trying to justify it. I'm saying I don't hold the same values many people do about it.
It'd be much more understandable if you were saying 'I cheated once. It was a really terrible thing that I did, and something I regret a heck of a lot, but my partner was incredible enough to give me another chance to be a better, less selfish and thoughtless person, and since then I have'.
And I wish I could say that. But I can't.
But what you're basically saying, is that you're not sorry, because these things happen and cheating isn't that bad anyway... which is just ridiculous.
I never said it wasn't bad...just that it isn't the end of the world. I wasn’t even talking about my own situation all that much...where have I said anything to remotely indicate whether or not I feel sorry about what happened?
I really would love to know the situation for contexts sake. I mean, I am not beyond flexibility with my opinions, but I need to know exactly what you mean, and not just vague attempts to make your cheating sound better than it was
My wife and I had been married for three years. Together for almost ten. She had cheated on me two years into our relationship, I had forgiven her, because it wasn't really that big a deal, and we'd moved on with our lives.
A year and a half or so ago, I was the lead in a local musical. There were two women in the cast around my age. In the manner of theatre people, the three of us hung out after the rehearsals, bonded/flirted, etc. One of them, the younger one, who was my colead, supposedly really liked me, which I found out about through my wife.
So the two women hinted at some kind of sexy cast party hijinks. And I told my wife about this. And my wife decided that it was okay, being theatre people, if the women and I were to mess around a bit at a cast party, while hanging out, etc.
And the show ended. And since nothing had happened at the cast party, the married woman and I flirted via text for a few days.
And my wife was out of town for a choir competition. And the two women and I hung out for the married woman's birthday, and we went back to the younger girl's house to watch a movie and hang out and they ripped a lot of my clothing off and duct taped me. And we played spin the bottle, as adults do...And we all got hammered, and the younger girl kept trying to mount me, which I politely declined, and one thing led to another, and later that night, after the younger girl had passed out drunk, the married woman jumped me and we made out for a few minutes.
And my wife came home the next day and I told her about what had happened. And she was okay with it, because she'd told me I could. At which point she told me she had something to tell me as well.
So I said "Did you sleep with someone?" And she nodded. And I said "Was it INSERT NAME OF MY BEST FRIEND". And she nodded. And so I said "Hnnh". Because it was a bit of a surprise, as he had professed to be a virgin.
And so we talked it out like adults, and decided to think about trying a more open relationship, because obviously the whole "one person" thing wasn't working all that well. And we discussed it like rational adults. And then, a few hours later, she got really angry and physically attacked me. At which point we had a seven hour screaming fight, and she left the next morning. She told me she was leaving so I could have time to do what I felt like I needed to do. So I hung out with the married woman a few days later, and we did some mildly sexual things.
Which of course only made things worse, because that was also a test. And my wife had moved in with someone else. At which point I found out she lied about sleeping with my best friend, and gotten him to lie about it as well, and she was just "testing me" there to see what I would do.
It didn't go too well from there. I tried to get to the bottom of things, to get to a point where we could communicate about things, but she ended up dishing out lots of mental and emotional abuse, physically attacking me several more times, starting and then refusing to follow through with several different counseling sessions, threatening suicide, and eventually committing herself to a mental hospital before things just fell apart and she found someone else.
That's kind of the basic version.
I just don't understand that at all. If it's about their own insecurities more than their love and respect for their partner... then how is that NOT selfish.
It is selfish…I'm not saying it's not. Thinking of yourself is selfish. But it’s not always necessarily about the partner.
I don't believe in any kind of set of rules. I believe in what I feel in my gut, and what I know from experience, and what my mind tells me is logical.
And all those things tell me that if someone cheats, they either don't love you, or are too selfish for any kind of real relationship.
See, that kind of feels like a rule to me.
He was physically abusive to her as a kid, and has never been there for her or me for our entire lives.
He is not capable of love. He loves as much as a man like him can, and it's not IMO enough for me to give a crap about him. Not at all.
I’m not asking you to give a crap about him, but what I’m saying…is just because he can’t “love” to other people’s specifications, does that mean he does not love? As much as he can, obviously, but isn't that still love?
I think you're missing my point.
I'm saying they are completely selfish in that situation.
I'm not saying all cheaters, the minute they cheat, suddenly go on this blacklist of selfish people and should be shunned
Everyone has the capacity to be selfish. We are all selfish sometimes.
But if you LOVE someone, and you are in a committed relationship with them, then you CAN'T be that selfish. It's not okay.
I would agree with most of that. But "can’t" means cannot. It means impossible. "Should not", I get. "Cannot" is a bit more hard and fast.
And this is why I call cheating a mistake. People make mistakes. What you're basically saying is that its not okay to make this mistake. Which...I get, but beyond "It's not okay", its the attitude of "It's not a mistake I can forgive" that I find counterproductive.
Once you've made that commitment, once you've decided you're in love, that should mean you care about the other person as much as you care about yourself. Or even more in some cases!
And that means never doing anything to hurt them. It means never making a conscious decision to not give a **** about them for however long, while you get your rocks off with another girl for you're own personal pleasure, despite the pain it's going to cause the other person.
And that's a nice sentiment. That's definitely the way to proceed when approaching love. And it would be nice if that was the way the mind and heart worked for everyone...but unfortunately, it's not. There are times when, through no fault of your own, regardless of how much you've thought something through, you simply don't consider someone else's feelings or the impact your actions will have on their lives. Because that's just not where your mind is.
And if you break that committment, then you have to wonder if you really were ready for it. If you really were ready to love someone as much as you love yourself. If you were really 'In Love' at all.
I agree that there's a question of readiness, but there’s that “retroactive” thing I’m talking about. As well as the “rules” I spoke of.