Dregride said:
-I don't think its safe to say she's a weapon. An "abomination"(unnatural human kree hybrid) maybe. The kree wouldn't have just abanded the project if they got their desired affect of creating weapons.
Vin-Tak also said they needed killers, and whether one calls it a weapon of a slave enhanced soldier, they have military use.
But that aside, the Kree didn't abandon the project. One faction of the Kree made them, and another faction (who considers them "abominations", etc.) decided to exterminate them, ending the project. Vin-Tak is from the latter faction, and he came to Earth to eliminate anyone changed by the mist and erase any memory of them. He also said that if the government of the Kree empire knew their experiments succeeded, they would likely resume them.
Dregride said:
In episode 12 May gets skye far enough away from the kree that during the fight the earthquake didn't reach them, and in episode 16 we get an overhead shot of Skye using her powers on Calderon and Bobbi her wave reaches like maybe 20 feet max.
In episode 12, she was trying not to use her power, and was not using it at full power (e.g., she didn't bring down walls, like after the transformation, which may or may not be at full power). And in episode 16, she was weak to the damage caused by the gloves, plus she probably didn't intend to use as much power as she could; also, that was a single shot, not a sustained use of power.
So, I think we don't know how powerful she is.
Then again, I suspect (based on other Whedon's shows, though those were Joss Whedon's, but still, they seem to work together to a considerable extent), that either not much more, or we'll see a serious permanent loss of power due to permanent damage caused by the gloves. Or something.
Dregride said:
At the most you could call them more useful solders given that their abilities could come in handy, but they are still sentient organisms (unnatural but viable hybrids) that have identical mental processes of humans.
While a few of their mental processes are somewhat different (e.g., they perceive the world around them differently, for instance Skye can feel the vibrations of everything around her. It's like having one or more extra senses), you hit the nail on the head, because the mental processes that they do share with humans (nearly all), include all of those relevant to make them "not a thing" in the sense Gonzales uses the word "thing". The differences in mental processes are comparable to the differences between, say, the mental processes of a blind person and most people. There are some differences, but those aren't relevant in this context.
Dregride said:
They don't consider them "human"( Calderon called skye an "it") and believe they should be killed( Calderon and his men brought guns when ICERs would have been just as fine).
It seems icers wouldn't have been fine, either. They already had Skye in the Retreat. But supposed they iced her. Then what would they have done? Permanent sedation is horrific, and they have no other way to hold her.
The right course of action was not to do anything against her. Then again, the right course of action was not to attack the Playground in the first place, but even after they did, they shouldn't have attacked Skye.
Dregride said:
This isn't abiut disagreeing with Coulson( even though Coulson can at least where they're coming from unlike vise-versa) this about them acting nazi-like, in the sense of their insistence of dehumanizing and killing people with powers regardless if they're dangerous or not just because theyre different.
Yes, and they shouldn't de-personalizing them even when they are dangerous, or even when they are justified in killing some of them.
Dregride said:
Saving the ship was the best decision they've ever made, it all kinda went downhill after that.
For the most part, that decision was made by other people. Gonzales was against it. Weaver wasn't there. And neither was Calderon. Of the five members of NUShield's present-day executive, only two of them made that choice.