Micromind
Avenger
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2009
- Messages
- 27,656
- Reaction score
- 10,840
- Points
- 103
This is the centre of your thesis, your defence for all of Batman's characterisation throughout this movie, yes?
Answer me this... why would Bruce Wayne be so traumatised by the Black Zero Event? This is supposed to be a man who has been on a twenty year mission to save Gotham. He's meant to have had all the experiences as Batman we know about from the comics. He's meant to have fought The Joker, Killer Croc, Mad Hatter, Clayface, Scarecrow, Ra's Al Ghul etc. etc. That's this version of Batman's USP. He's meant to have seen death, destruction, pain, hate, suffering and evil up close and personal for decades.
Your argument is that he was effectively 'classic' Batman after all of this, but before Black Zero. A non-killing, mentally stable Batman.
...and then two aliens knock some buildings down. Which throws Batman over the edge completely.
Ever talked to anyone in the emergency services, who's been in their jobs for decades, and had to experience something horrific? I have.
I know both police officers and medical staff who went through 7/7 here in the UK. Ordinary people who experienced absolute hell. And yes, it stays with them... but they didn't crack, or break, or change fundamentally as human beings. If anything, their previous experience of traumatic eventsn their jobs, lessened the mental impact for them.
But you think Batman would just fall apart, do you? That none of his previous experience would have toughened him up, and that he'd have a breakdown because it was aliens?
Please. This is meant to be ****ing Batman.
Did you miss how Bruce had already become more cynical, angry and lost hope after Robin's death ?
or, the fact that Bruce lost Wayne Enterprises Office Staff members in Black Zero event ?
or, How countless lives were lost during Zod vs Superman fight in Metropolis, and Bruce was present there at that time during the Zod vs Superman fight ?
Or, how Lex Luthor manipulated him gradually over the period of two years post BZ event ?
It's all there in the movie
