OK, so the game arrived last night and spent a good two-three hours with it. The thing that hit me was the information overload - there's just so many things you can do as Batman, it's jarring at first. And since I didn't play the demo, this was my first time with the game and I loved it. And the combat is really something. It didn't look that impressive when I saw it in the videos, but now that I've played it myself I can see that it was the player that was lacking, not the game itself. I just go stand still in the middle of a group of enemies and just counter and cape stun like crazy - it looks amazing and almost like a film fight scene. You truly do get the feel that as Batman, your opponents are ridiculously outmatched.
I hear that this is a short game, but it feels like one of those titles gets better as you get better at it.