The Dark Knight BOF: Harvey Dent Already Cast?

Since the announcement of who is playing Harvey Dent in The Dark Knight is "imminent", I guess I'll put out one last listing of my favorites for the role. Odds are none of them will be cast, but it'll be fun.

So, without further ado...

MY FAVORITES 4 HARVEY DENT

4. Eion Bailey
baileycomparisonww7.png

Allegedly one of Nolan's frontrunner's for the cape & cowl had Christian Bale passed on the film, Bailey is my fourth choice to play the dual-faced district attorney in The Dark Knight. He's got a terrific look for the part and has this uncanny ability to make his face just look like the coldest and desolate place on Earth. He's not half bad of an actor, either. The first time I saw him appear on ER, my position against him playing Superman at the time completely changed. However, Routh got that part. But Dent would probably pose more of a challenge for the young (but older looking) actor.

3. Leonardo DiCaprio
dicapriotdzl5.png


The biggest 'name' on this list. I probably don't need to say too too much about the actor since most people have known of him (and were probably sick of him) since they saw him freeze in Titanic.

The guy is talented, smart, and handsome. He'd be a terrific choice for Dent and would fit in with the cast already established quite well. He was a wonderful child actor in What's Eating Gilbert Grape, a terrific anti-hero in Catch Me If You Can, but finally made his first tremendous impression on me with his incredible turn in The Departed. If you haven't seen it yet, go out and see it as soon as possible. It's amazing. While DiCaprio may not be the most original or inspired choice for the role, he is certainly capable and would fans of Dent & Two-Face mighty proud in the end.

2. Jeffrey Donovan
pilot01it4.jpg

attachment2bp6.jpg

Best known for his gripping performance as Detective Creegan on 'Touching Evil', which had the actor portraying a police officer slipping into madness. Widely seen in the recent Will Smith romcom 'Hitch' and is getting praised for his role in the sundance darling 'Come Early Morning'. Had memorable guest stints on 'Monk', 'Threshold', 'Yes, Dear', 'Crossing Jordan', and 'CSI'. He's been a favorite of mine for quite a long time and I still am of the opinion that he'd kill in the Dent role. He was originally my #1 for the role, but those things can change...

1. BRADLEY COOPER

He's got the 'prestige':

017jpgmi6.jpg


He's got the look:

aliasdvdpartyqc1.png


He's got the range:

082jpguw3.jpg


Jeffrey Donovan has been, at least for the last year or so, my #1 pick for the role of Harvey Dent in THE DARK KNIGHT. He has everything I (and hopefully Nolan too) look for in an actor and would be a great Dent. But he has played the whole bright & shiny - to - destructive and demented before in 'Touching Evil'. He's also out of the primary age range that seems to have been chosen as the ideal age for the character.

That brings me to Bradley Cooper, who will never in a thousand years get this role because the universe is both cold and cruel.

The man is an outstanding actor, performer, and personality. He has the charm, intelligence, passion, and aggression for the role of Harvey Dent, a role that one would presume to lead into the big 'Two-Face' story-arch eventually. Cooper really hasn't had a prime opportunity to show his dark side besides a few excellent episodes of Alias and a villainous turn in the comedy 'Wedding Crashers'. With the talent he possess, he should get a chance to stretch his legs a little.

He recieved rave reviews whilst starring opposite Julia Roberts and Paul Rudd in the recent Broadway production of 'Three Days of Rain'. He actually recieved better reviews than both of the other actors combined and I believe was nominated for (not entirely certain if he won) a tony award for his role. Many consider that Alias 'died' when the creators dropped his character from the position of 'series regular'. The show hit high points in seasons 3 & 5 when he made single episode guest appearances. The man deserves to be a household name. He's got that potential.

All he'd need is a role like Harvey Dent in Nolan's new Batman franchise to kick him up into the uber-mainstream range. I'm fairly certain he will get there eventually, but getting Dent would certainly help move things along.

Of course it's too late. Nolan has his Dent and is most likely thrilled with him as he is Ledger as Joker. I'm certain whomever Nolan does cast as Harvey will be a terrific actor and will do great things with the role. That said, I think that Cooper would be an ideal choice and his inclusion would be pretty much the only thing that could get me more excited (during the pre-production/casting stage) for THE DARK KNIGHT than I already am.

Thank you for reading.

Good night, and good luck.
 
Mr. Socko said:
Just like the casting of the Joker, the casting of Dent will probably someone no one will think of.

Probably... I'm tired of hearing the old rumors resurface about Gyllenhal, Shreiber, Cusack, Phillipe, etc... it think we won't see them just because there names have been mentioned over and over again... I think they should go young... wouldn't mind Phillipe/Leo one bit (if the go Gyllenhal I'll be like w/e)... I don't see why so many people are just so enamored with the veteran guys like Schreiber and Pierce... those guys aren't Oscar caliber (not that they would be winning Oscars for the role of Dent) but there work really hasn't been THAT impressive if you know what I mean
 
Well, Donnovan looks good enough as Dent, but I would go with another actor.
 
Damn Threshold... talk about no names... I'd prefer they sign a big name... this guy is gonna be the third most important character in the trilogy for Pete's sake... all trilogies have that fantastic YOUNG trio... (so I won't include Oldman, Freeman, and Caine)... I'd never thought I'd say it... but I'll be pulling for Leo...
 
:hyper:
FaT_tONle said:
Damn Threshold... talk about no names... I'd prefer they sign a big name... this guy is gonna be the third most important character in the trilogy for Pete's sake... all trilogies have that fantastic YOUNG trio... (so I won't include Oldman, Freeman, and Caine)... I'd never thought I'd say it... but I'll be pulling for Leo...

Fantastic and Famous are not the samething. I am not sure of the credibility of "All trilogies have a fantastic young trio" I will play along for this bit. When I think of fantastic film trilogies, I think of both Star Wars trilogies and X Men right of the back. In the name of expedience, I will only address the Original Trilogy.

The "Fantastic Young Trio" of The Original Star Wars was Fisher, Ford and Hammil. Only one of those was a known actor, though all of them were fantastic in the film. So while 3 of the 4 actors Threshold mentioned are not household names, that doesn't mean they will not be fantastic in the role (after all Bale was not a household name pre-Begins) and thus does not go against your questionable theory.
 
StorminNorman said:
:hyper:

Fantastic and Famous are not the samething. I am not sure of the credibility of "All trilogies have a fantastic young trio" I will play along for this bit. When I think of fantastic film trilogies, I think of both Star Wars trilogies and X Men right of the back. In the name of expedience, I will only address the Original Trilogy.

The "Fantastic Young Trio" of The Original Star Wars was Fisher, Ford and Hammil. Only one of those was a known actor, though all of them were fantastic in the film. So while 3 of the 4 actors Threshold mentioned are not household names, that doesn't mean they will not be fantastic in the role (after all Bale was not a household name pre-Begins) and thus does not go against your questionable theory.

I'll give it to you that whoever they cast for Dent might become a house hold name later on... I don't think Bale is a house hold name just yet... agreed Leo might be too big a name which is probably why he won't get the role... but you look at some recent trilogies... like POTC... LOTR... the Matrix... Spiderman... Xmen... they all have that core... I think it is still lacking in Batman only because we only have one movie to go by... don't get me wrong... it's not even imaginable to think of a better trio than Freeman, Caine, Bale... but I'd prefer they add even more significant pieces rather than just building around Bale... not Burton like where he isn't the main guy anymore... but maybe a notch below that... Ledger/Bale/Decaprio... well that's too good to be true... as well as stellar role players... whoever they choose I am sure he will do great
 
Mr. Socko said:
Just like the casting of the Joker, the casting of Dent will probably someone no one will think of.

I highly doubt it. Ledger was a rare thing. I think the main reason no one thought of Ledger was his age. They weren't expecting someone that young. But with Dent, people've been casting all ranges of age. So many names have come up for Dent that for them to cast someone no one mentioned, they'd have to cast someone no one ever heard of, or who's completely wrong for the part.

I just dont get why everyone's expecting casting like Ledger to happen again. So what if Nolan has done surprise casting a few times, he's also done some very obvious casting.
 
Katsuro said:
I just dont get why everyone's expecting casting like Ledger to happen again. So what if Nolan has done surprise casting a few times, he's also done some very obvious casting.
His only obvious casting would be Bale, Freeman, and (to a lesser extent) Neeson. Everyone else has been pretty much off-beat so to speak.
 
FaT_tONle said:
Damn Threshold... talk about no names... I'd prefer they sign a big name... this guy is gonna be the third most important character in the trilogy for Pete's sake... all trilogies have that fantastic YOUNG trio... (so I won't include Oldman, Freeman, and Caine)... I'd never thought I'd say it... but I'll be pulling for Leo...

I suppose because I am an actor myself, I tend to gravitate less towards the 'namey' actors and more towards the actors who have that special something and could really do something memorable and fresh with the material. That said, I originally was reticent to drop LeoDiCap on to my list, but I figured that one 'namey' actor wouldn't mean the end of the world.

Cooper was my #1 favorite because he's got all the components that a great Harvey Dent requires. The looks, the charm, the intensity/gravitas, and the fact that he hasn't really gone there yet. It's not something he's done. For some of you that may mean 'off of the list', but I guarantee that if you doubters would watch the first two seasons of J.J. Abram's spy drama 'Alias' (watch 'em even if you aren't doubters, those seasons are incredible!), the tenth episode of the third season, and the twelve episode of the fifth season (which is episode #100 for the series)... You'll be thinking that he could do wonders with Harvey Dent as well.

Alas, it's not going to be "meant to be" and some british guy named Jude is going to get it and illicit my first 'meh' of the history of this sequel's production. Yes Christopher Nolan, that was a threat. ;)
 
Majik1387 said:
I haven't seen him in anything so I'll hold my opinions about him till I see him in The Prestige.

He's not in 'The Prestige', I just used the word prestige cause it fit what I was trying to say and it's also the title of Nolan's film. Cooper isn't in it. He'd make a great Dent, but I'm not entirely certain he'd be at home in a 'turn of the century' magician revenge drama.

fabman said:
what about rufus sewell?

Dude, no offense cause I love hearing who people want to play Dent, but Rufus Sewell has to be just about the most boring actor on the face of the Earth. He delivers the most bland and cliche performances and has not an once of intelligence when it comes to chosing his roles. I'd be incredibly disapointed in Nolan if Sewell gets into this film.

ROBOCOP CPU001 said:
On the comeback trail..

Ben affleck.

Again, when I read BOF's Jett write that the movie was going to get a lot of hype and that not everyone will be happy about the name he heard... My first thought was 'Ben Affleck'. I'd just seen Hollywoodland and thought he was terrific in it, easily a career reviving turn if I've ever seen one. He also seems like the kind of guy Nolan would not be adverse to casting as Dent. But I don't know Nolan, I just know his films. REALLY well. :)

Crooklyn said:
His only obvious casting would be Bale, Freeman, and (to a lesser extent) Neeson. Everyone else has been pretty much off-beat so to speak.

Caine wasn't too shocking... But yeah, even Neeson came as a bit of a shock and thinking back, you're right about the off-beat casting. Gary Oldman, Tom Wilkinson, Katie Holmes (to the least extent ;) ), Cillian Murphy, etc... Very shocking selections.

Back to my whole Bradley Cooper thing (which must be getting a tad bit annoying to at least someone by now), he has received rave reviews in an incredibly high profile play and got awards recognition for it. Nolan seems like the kind of guy that, while not being a man who creates and dabbles in live theatre, must certainly have an appreciation for it.

Cooper won't get picked because his film roles haven't lived up to the roles he's taken in television and stage. Which is really too bad, but at the same time, perfectly understandable.

FaT_tONle said:
i can assure you it won't be Jude Law ^

Fat Tonie, I pray to the heavens that you're right... :batman:
 
Why on earth would you believe Law to be a favorite... I think Cusack, Lucas Shreiber, Gyllenhal (heck even Jackman) all have a better chance than Law... let Law kill Superman in that sequel... not Batman's sequel...
 
Cusack I could see as a lawyer- couldn't see as Two Face. Couldn't see him as Two Face at all actually.
 
The more I think about it though, the more I like Affleck for Harvey Dent.

affleck_ben.jpg
 
StorminNorman said:
The more I think about it though, the more I like Affleck for Harvey Dent.

affleck_ben.jpg

He doesn't fit the quality of actor that Nolan normally chooses, though. I mean, he's crap compared to the likes of Bale, Ledger, Caine, Oldman and Freeman.
 
Saint said:
I'd prefer an actor.

Why? I think his Bennifer persona could really benefit this movie.

"How ya like dem apples, Bruce?"

(I know, it was Damon's line, so sue me)
 
StorminNorman said:
The more I think about it though, the more I like Affleck for Harvey Dent.

affleck_ben.jpg

You know, I never even thought of Affleck. He can act when he's given good material, and not crap like Armageddon and Gigli. I'd give him a shot.
 
MulligaN Stew said:
He's a quality actor.

And I'm sure when he's not kissing his reflection in the mirror, he tells himself that.

Who, besides yourself of course, really cares if you don't see TDK?

God. He gets furious when I don't watch Batman movies. It's my purpose in life.

Why are you making homosexually inclined references?

Because they're funny?

Why are you contemplating the thought of having your genitals so close to Baldwin?

Because I'm gay for him, obviously. :heart: Either that or "I wouldn't piss in his ear if his brains were on fire" is a funny-ass line, and I thought I'd use it.

So who are you, his wife? Grow up.

Dog's are a man's best friend; Baldwins hate every one.

Actually Stephen LOVES everyone. Shows what you know. :)

Also, there's no apostrophe in "Dogs." There are, however, six of them in "friend".

Next time, save this sorry excuse for a post with actual reasons as to why he wouldn't fit into the role. Thanks.

Seriously, are you married to the guy? Or are you, in fact, Alec Baldwin? Wait, that's the same question. Sorry.

I didn't say he wouldn't fit into the role.

I SAID I HATE HIM.

Different argument entirely.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
202,288
Messages
22,079,640
Members
45,880
Latest member
Heartbeat
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"