Talk about "off-topic".
Quite why U.S. comics were delayed a day for Thanksgiving, which was on a Thursday a week prior, is beyond me. There probably is some reason, and it probably is stupid. This was a short week, and I am feeling pretty crummy with a cold right now, so I will try to keep it brief. Or at least as brief as I can until OMD #3.
As always, full spoilers are revealed. Let's bid November farewell.
Dread's BOUGHT/THOUGHT for 11/29/07:
BLUE BEETLE #21: In October, BLUE BEETLE actually made it onto the Top 100 list for the first time in ages. That could have been due to the lack of many late Marvel books (causing DC to reign supreme that month), or due to the SINESTRO CORPS crossover, or whatnot, but it was a nice sight. This issue is done by a "guest" team (guess it sounds better than "fill-in", although it reminds me of a George Carlin routine where he claims "changing the name of something doesn't change what it is", or words to that effect) of Justin Peniston writing and Andy Kuhn on art. I have a bit of secret information in that Mr. Peniston is a friend of the SHH's own mod,
Dew K Mosi, and they talk quite often. Peniston is one of those rare breeds; a "DC Zombie" who has literally fended off offers from Marvel to work for DC titles for the moment. From the impressions of this issue, that's for DC's gain. As for Andy Kuhn, he was the last artist on Kirkman's MTU run and probably the worst, but here he seems a little better (of course, it had been a year or so). Kuhn seems more adapt at drawing superhero characters than regular civilians to me, which is fine for most superhero works. BLUE BEETLE is maintaining something that has become a lost art; stand-alone stories that work as one-shot tales in and of themselves, yet maintain a subplot for long-time readers as well as inevitable trade readers, which is the best way to go. Unlike most "guest" runs, this story fits seamlessly into what Rogers is doing and even goes into long-running themes from past issues, such as Jamie getting used to his powers, the status of Peacemaker after last month (thankfully, he survived, but is still hospitalized; this is good because Peacemaker had too good a rapport with Beetle to die on me), and Jamie's budding feelings for the mystically powered heroine, Traci. The plot of the story focuses on Blue Beetle responding to a prison riot, but it appears to be more than that; the Spectre has appeared and is doing his "God's Vengeance" thing on some prisoners, and Beetle seeks to oppose him, not caring for "vigilante" style murder, which is a perfectly solid superhero reaction and one that is becoming rare there days, with many characters at Marvel & DC casually watching minion's die or allying with killer anti-heroes. The scarab wants to unleash weapons that would flatten the entire city, which Jamie opposes, but without that, he is merely an annoyance for Spectre. Involved in the riot is also an inmate named Luis, the man who was responsible for Jamie's father being partly crippled and needing a cane at all times. Peniston doesn't quite have the "classic one-liner" charm of Rogers and Giffen, but he still does the job very well for this sort of story and gets in some amusing quips when appropriate. At first stunned when his father asks him to forgive Luis, Jamie decides to go for it after Traci essentially explains that reasoning with Spectre is the only way to quell his attacks (short of nuking the city, that is). Naturally, the message here is that prison and even addiction are worse enough punishments to criminals than outright murder, which is fine for traditional superhero comics like this, especially starring characters with traditional values. Jamie later describes Luis as "not evil, but weak", and his addiction to his "fix" as "a cage". He uses this to get Spectre to relent, especially as the guard Luis injured during the riot survives at the end. The theme of the tale is faith, not just in God but in oneself. This was one of those rare fill-in's that manages to tell a good story, fit the tone of the regular creative team, and manage to advance the subplots a little bit as well. Peniston "got" what Blue Beetle is about and that is what matters most for a writer in the comic biz, to "get" what characters are about, rather than IMPOSING what said writer THINKS THEY SHOULD BE. This was probably the best comic I read all week. Granted, it was a short week, but that says something. I wouldn't mind seeing Peniston do more issues on this title in the future.
SENSATIONAL SPIDER-MAN #41: The final issue before all 3 Spidey titles merge into ASM, or ONE MORE DAY Part 3. Some people at THE BEAT are calling this "One More Delay" as this has fallen behind almost immediately, and the lack of this on the calendar likely helped DC beat out Marvel by a thin margin in October. It is especially embarassing because the EIC himself is penciling the story, and HE of all people should know the realities of his own schedule and whether or not he could release interior comics at a rate to make it a weekly (or bi-weekly) endeavor, as originally planned. Todd McFarlane took a lot of heat for his art woes when he ran Image (it literally took him a decade to complete work for an anniversary Image special), and Joe Q should expect some here. I mean, Erik Larson's SAVAGE DRAGON doesn't come out as often as it used to, especially with him running Image now, but at least he rarely makes false promises on the schedule. Joe Q's Marvel has made a REGULAR HABIT of severely overestimating their creative team's out-put speed on one series or run after the other. Yes, yes, "DC does it too", but that is no excuse; you're supposed to improve upon your competitors, not shrug when you mimic their errors, at least from a leadership standpoint. The other problem with OMD beyond schedule is that it is yet another one of Marvel's events that procedes PRECISELY as every single rumor and spoiler image predicted it would, song and verse. Picture a movie that not only is mediocre at best unto itself, but one that follows so faithfully to the teaser trailer that you really didn't have to invest in the film at all in order to know the story and every hook. ONE MORE DAY has become that. People were saying half a year ago that this was Joe Q's masterstroke to remove the Parker Marriage from the mythos, which he and other brain-dead writers feel have "ruined" Spider-Man. I've mentioned what sort of shark-jumping stunts and underdeveloped areas have really killed the Spider-verse, and I really don't feel like repeating them. The marriage is what a writer made of it, and many clung so much to the 60's that they cannot fathom the idea of Peter Parker actually growing up. It seems especially silly when you consider ULTIMATE SPIDER-MAN, which has a young, unmarried Peter still in high school like every single middle aged fanboy writer seems to want for the character for the rest of his published existence, still sells at around 90-100k in the Top 20-25 every month. People who want younger Peter go there, people who wanted an older, more mature Peter had 616. I believe Joe Q HIMSELF said something along those lines years ago when Ultimate launched. The story begins with Peter talking to his Red-Head Maguffin Brat (call her Mayla Liller for the moment) until he meets some oddball people in an oddball neighborhood, who both end up to be alternate versions of himself that became an isolated video game designer/fantasy geek, and a corporate, lonely billionare, respectively. Both are brought out by Mephisto, who has apparently heard Peter's mystic plea and is offering his Faustian deal; Aunt May's Life in exchange for The Parker Marriage ending. Good GOD, haven't we been saying this would happen for at least 7 god damned months!? Couldn't there have been more to it? Anyway, the title is revealed as the Parkers have until Midnight, or ONE MORE DAY, to make their decision, as well as to be together. Now, Mephisto's involvement isn't in itself too much of a stretch; he has ranged from being cosmic with Silver Surfer & Dr. Strange to being petty, as when he decided to randomly murder Mockingbird to spite the Avengers. Spider-Man's a longtime hero who has battled pretty much every kind of threat there has been, and likely ran into Mephisto or his agents at some point or another, so him offering this deal to Peter after he magically begged for it across the cosmos isn't far-fetched. But, good LORD, it is following the entire checklist of Joe Q's marriage-ending obsession. Why can't Peter have both? Why can't writers invest in stories about characters and not stunts, or create new supporting cast characters to replace old ones, or amp up and develop the other members of Peter's rogues gallery besides Norman ****ing Osborn for the 8 Trillionth time? No, they blame it on the marriage, and essentially the woman (MJ)...typical male response. "It all went wrong when he got hitched", isn't that the most male cliche explanation for someone's ills, ever? People mock ARCHIE, but at least those comics are honest with their Neverland intentions.
Dan Slott is taking over ASM after this storyline ends, and I have full faith that he will explore Peter's universe to the fullest, perhaps improve upon the utter lack of any supporting cast or civilian life to Peter (which is what REALLY killed him, and JMS helped that along). But all of that doesn't mean the Parkers had to split up. And what really kills me is Mephisto goes on about his "you won't know you were married, but part of you will mourn it because I jerk off to your pain" stuff, but what about all their friends, family, allies? And beyond that, you KNOW it won't be 12 months befoere someone is teasing about a Parker/MJ reunion, especially if SPIDER-MAN 4 becomes more of a reality. It took less than a year for Marvel to retract on Peter's "public knowledge" identity by allowing Slott to fudge it into "widely speculated" territory in AVENGERS: THE INITIATIVE, and I will be surprised if the "divorce" lasts that long. Besides that, if Joe Q wanted to end the marriage, why NOT have them divorce? That would have been honest, and could have been a deep character story that people could relate to, especially in a country where many people in their mid 20's marry, yet about 50% divorce after a year. But NO, instead they make it some magic baloney story with Dr. Strange, demons, and costumes, NOT about human choices. Stunts like THIS have ruined Spider-Man comics, not him being married to the red-head of his dreams. I literally want to speak to a bunch of writers' wives to understand where this utter contempt for the Parker marriage comes from. For ****'s sake, let Peter Parker grow the **** up! Even Superman, the iconic example of a dusty franchise which couldn't find an innovative or modern idea for it's life (yay, have Donner pitch rejected 70's ideas with Johns!), allowed the Kents to stay married. Think about that; all of DC's OYL turmoil, and the Kent marriage is INTACT and people aren't pissing and moaning like man-babies that it ruined their character.
I'm sure Slott will perform masterworks with the new status quo, and I suspect Jackpot may end up an alternate reality MJ who became a superhero; now if THAT isn't a clue as to the current return of the 90's, I don't know what is. The 90's were CRAWLING with alternate reality versions of characters who were still alive and kicking just to make fanboy's heads explode. My final point? The marriage was not the straw that broke the web. Stunts like OMD were.
MOON KNIGHT ANNUAL #1: Just when I was growing tired of the regular series' creative team and anticipate the next, along comes a solid one-shot tale that shows there still is some life in the franchise. Actually, the story by Swierczynski and Palo is standard annual fare; unable to do anything major with the title character, they tell the story of civilian characters with the title superhero acting as a brief phantom to move the plot forward. Writers have told one-shot WOLVERINE or PUNISHER stories along this route for years. It also touches on a theme that Sam Keith has all but milked to death; women being raped. Unfortunately, it is still a too-common crime and this story touches on many of the angles of victimization, anger, despair, and even denial. Various women meet in a support group for victims of date rape and all tell tales, some interconnecting, of the same sleaze who takes on various identities and acts to date-rape women. One of the women manages to fall into Moon Knight's arms after a suicide attempt, and this puts the hero on the trail of the rapist, who gets his just desserts in the end. One could argue that Moon Knight himself isn't exactly required here; one could have told the exact same story with Daredevil, Wolverine, the Punisher, or any moderately violent hero in his place and only a few lines would have had to be changed. But, Moon Knight has usually thrived in this sort of urban material, and he works out here. The last woman in the group really needed a good smack, though (tasering superheroes is NOT cool). Still, this was a simple, effective storyline which was good for a one-shot read, but unfortunately may re-inforce critics who feel Moon Knight is too "interchangable" with other heroes. I liked having a down-to-earth urban story about the sort of criminals and victims that do exist in the world, especially after OMD #3 which has Mephisto Starring in DIVORCE COURT. Solid, enjoyable annual. The art's great, too.
X-MEN: FIRST CLASS #6: A horribly low selling title, but if you compare it to similar MARVEL ADVENTURES titles, it vastly outsells them all in the direct market. Something really weird seemed to happen to this issue, and it wasn't just mine after some AIM discussions; the stories were all over the place. The beginning and end pages deal with everyone in the X-Mansion waking up without their powers, and then Sentinals attack. The middle has a story where Xavier tries to make contact with alien life, which may or may not connect to the power-loss story. And then there is another adorable Marvel-Girl story from Coover that is adorable but ends abruptly. And the very first page of the comic is an ad. Hopefully this was some sort of disasterous printing error, because if not, I can only conclude narcotics were involved (which, actually, may explain a lot at the bullpen). Normally I enjoy this simple title, but not jarbled issues like this. Shame, because it has cute moments. But they're like cute boxes on a mangled Rubix Cube.
I also got
MARVEL ATLAS #1 of 2, which I haven't read yet, but from a simple flipping I can see it is yet another ambitious attempt to catalogue the MU from the Handbook crew, and I can only marvel at the amount of research and collaboration that it took (don't believe me, read some of the bio's for Vampires and whatnot from the MARVEL ZOMBIES handbook last month). It is appreciated. Now if only more editors & writers at Marvel would read the darn things.