DarkKnight88
Avenger
- Joined
- Aug 23, 2002
- Messages
- 12,771
- Reaction score
- 11,908
- Points
- 103
I think specifically cause it’s Tatooine why it looks out of place. Coruscant they’d all fit right in.
I do agree.I think specifically cause it’s Tatooine why it looks out of place. Coruscant they’d all fit right in.
Yet every ship, weapon, greeble and grommet in SW is pulled from earth's past, from Samurai to Roman legion helmets, WWII, to buck rogers deco designs, to 60s vehicles.obsessed with an earth subculture from the past
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
We have Moleculad & Elektra Lass, we just need Kid Comet to show up, for their own spin-off series.
![]()
![]()
![]()
I'm calling this one Kid Comet
![]()
That's Star Wars. It's why we have samurai, biker gangs, 50s diners, hot rods, etc.I don’t mind color or chrome in Star Wars.
I just think it’s stupid to have mods and vespas in Star Wars
It just kinda looks like a group of kids that are obsessed with an earth subculture from the past and that doesn’t make a bit of goddamn sense.
That's Star Wars. It's why we have samurai, biker gangs, 50s diners, hot rods, etc.
I think specifically cause it’s Tatooine why it looks out of place. Coruscant they’d all fit right in.
The idea of the gang, is in theory, they clash with Boba. That they don't, that Boba sees their rebellious spirit and is like, "these are my kind of people" is very much the point imo. Which is why having them be super basic and threatening like the Porky Boys would be boring and repetitive. We've seen Boba bond with mutiple different types. Fennec, the Tuskens, the Mods, Black K, a rancor, etc. He's an island of misfit toys type of guy. Considering his flashbacks to Kamino, it's probably tied to something with papa.Exactly, here they stick out like poor aesthetic. It makes the show look cheap and feel more like CW or power rangers. Add in the fact that this is easily top 3 worst action scenes in SW and it's not doing the property any favors. Just helping them add memes.
There's a way to make this work, mainly by having this crew be a threatening addition or by having their action well depicted. But this was not the way. These were probably cutting room floor Alita characters.
The idea of the gang, is in theory, they clash with Boba. That they don't, that Boba sees their rebellious spirit and is like, "these are my kind of people" is very much the point imo. Which is why having them be super basic and threatening like the Porky Boys would be boring and repetitive. We've seen Boba bond with mutiple different types. Fennec, the Tuskens, the Mods, Black K, a rancor, etc. He's an island of misfit toys type of guy. Considering his flashbacks to Kamino, it's probably tied to something with papa.
It's why their look "clashing" with Tatooine works rather well imo. Also, I know I've watched way too much Star Wars, but that was far from a "top 3 worst" Star Wars action scene.
They looked no cheaper then the Mando in his beskar armor. I'd argue they look obviously better, because the worst thing was one eye piece that looked a little plastic, compared to good ole Din. He looks like he's walking around in ill fitting plastic most of the time.The concept or idea of it isn't so much my issue, this could have worked definitely under the right guidance and budget. Instead it feels far below standard for an IP that even in it's lowest has pushed boundaries or been ahead of the game in vfx, character design and action.
I like the prequels. But this revisionist history, which honestly applies to most of Star Wars. There is cheap looking stuff in every saga and every show so far. Hell, my favorite TV show for Star Wars is Rebels, and you can tell it didn't have the budget of TCW. A large problem with the prequels is while the costume design, sets and concepts are great 90% of the time, the big environments and a lot of the CGI creations feel "cheap". For every great one, there's stuff like the cutout heads for the clones in ROTS. Half the time in AotC, the film suffers from green scene obviousness. I'm not complaining. I'm just acknowledging it's there.Even when comparing some of the cringe moments in the Prequels (admttingly I'm a defender of) there is so much ILM craziness going on that I'd argue the entertainment value/eye candy is high. This visually feels tv cheap. Something more along the lines of a tv series that wants to be Star Wars but lacks the creative or money. Or just random ai in Cyber punk 2077.
I mean I could bring up a lot of early TCW and Rebels, but I don't even need to. Mando, the hallway chase during episode 4 of season 2 which was cut from hell and back. The original film is amazing. It also involves a stick fight between what feels like to very untrained elderly men moving in slow motion and Han getting in a shoot out by firing at dudes and just slapstick running away while everyone hilariously misses. And I want to be clear, I am not complaining. I love it. I even love the carebears and their sticks and rocks who show little to no ability to actually hurt people with them.I really can't remember an action set piece so slow and dull in Star Wars upon it's release. But maybe I'm forgetting some and my disappointment here is clouding my judgement. I'll trust your opinion that I am overlooking.
I think your assessment is correct.I dont think that chase was the worst scene in Start Wars history or anything. But by that same token, it wasn't great either. In the end, I am just not connecting with this show.
The honor of worst chase in Star Wars history goes to TLJ when that First Order Destroyer was chasing that Resistance cruiser throughout most of the filmI dont think that chase was the worst scene in Start Wars history or anything. But by that same token, it wasn't great either. In the end, I am just not connecting with this show.
It didn't look great but the design had much more going for it imo as did the character. I just can't say that for these characters yet. Maybe they will be cooler in the next ep?They looked no cheaper then the Mando in his beskar armor. I'd argue they look obviously better, because the worst thing was one eye piece that looked a little plastic, compared to good ole Din. He looks like he's walking around in ill fitting plastic most of the time.
There are definitely cheap things in every series. My enjoyment on these rely more so on how the rest compensates for those moments. Saw TPM 11 times in the theatre back in the day (constantly made fun of for it haha) and wanted to know more about the world building, character design and action choreography. It's an odd and interesting film for me and one of my fondest movie going experiences. I love what Clone Wars did for the property even more.I like the prequels. But this revisionist history, which honestly applies to most of Star Wars. There is cheap looking stuff in every saga and every show so far. Hell, my favorite TV show for Star Wars is Rebels, and you can tell it didn't have the budget of TCW. A large problem with the prequels is while the costume design, sets and concepts are great 90% of the time, the big environments and a lot of the CGI creations feel "cheap". For every great one, there's stuff like the cutout heads for the clones in ROTS. Half the time in AotC, the film suffers from green scene obviousness. I'm not complaining. I'm just acknowledging it's there.
I mean I could bring up a lot of early TCW and Rebels, but I don't even need to. Mando, the hallway chase during episode 4 of season 2 which was cut from hell and back. The original film is amazing. It also involves a stick fight between what feels like to very untrained elderly men moving in slow motion and Han getting in a shoot out by firing at dudes and just slapstick running away while everyone hilariously misses. And I want to be clear, I am not complaining. I love it. I even love the carebears and their sticks and rocks who show little to no ability to actually hurt people with them.
I'm not even saying the scene is great or anything. I enjoyed it, but I'm also someone who enjoys RR's sense of humor a lot of the time. And I took the Mod kids chase for what it was. A goofy chase sequence, built on youth subculture of the past. Which is what a lot of my favorite Star Wars does. Could it have looked faster? Yep. Boba could have also just use his jet pack.
I would hardly describe Fett as "invincible" after that fight. Fett got his ass handed to him. It is still a Star Wars show, you are not going to see a lot of bodily damage.
I don’t particularly mind it, it’s just a bit comical that the speed doesn’t get any faster from when they start. Not really worth doing a chase scene if you’re not going to do it properly and give it some drama. As for the show overall this all still feels like a setup/intro to the much better stuff when Boba is properly established having built up his numbers - just hope we start getting that from next episode.I dont think that chase was the worst scene in Start Wars history or anything. But by that same token, it wasn't great either. In the end, I am just not connecting with this show.
I don’t particularly mind it, it’s just a bit comical that the speed doesn’t get any faster from when they start. Not really worth doing a chase scene if you’re not going to do it properly and give it some drama. As for the show overall this all still feels like a setup/intro to the much better stuff when Boba is properly established having built up his numbers - just hope we start getting that from next episode.
I think part of that was to show that a vulnerable Boba (in his boxer shorts and asleep) needs loyal followers to have his back to be a legit power player (otherwise anyone can get assassinated by one of these elite bounty hunters) and is getting the rewards of his earlier treatment of all those groups. Building his empire through respect!I mean they had Boba there in full gear, why not just use him in the chasing down of the Mayor's man, it feels like the shows scared to use him in action scenes unless its showing Morrison's face for some reason, they could use a stunt double plus would have shown in broad daylight Boba owns these streets in the present time.
Anyway just some odd choices for me in Ep3 but its in the past now, hopefully we move onto better things next week.
I think part of that was to show that a vulnerable Boba (in his boxer shorts and asleep) needs loyal followers to have his back to be a legit power player (otherwise anyone can get assassinated by one of these elite bounty hunters) and is getting the rewards of his earlier treatment of all those groups. Building his empire through respect!