My question is, is it the the acting/directing, or the character/writing.
I feel like overall, Laurel has never been written well. She had what seemed to be a saving grace at the end of season 2, but then they focused more on Felicity and making her the lead, that Laurel was just a background character.
Like I'd really love to see her and Oliver just get along without drama or fighting. Like, show that they are friends and respect each other.
it's the writing my man here's why this same happen in small ville with Lana season 2 til 7 and cloe season 9 til 10 and bit with lois
but I'll list the problem the way they started off with laurel was overly toxic, with how they had her relation ship with oliver with him cheating on her. but what messed her up was season 2 where we were supposed to sympathize with her but they screwed it up when Sara came and save her but this was during Laurel's drunk addicted to alcohol period and she chose to attack her sister at the time sara save her and too k back to her apartment.
now also the issue with laurel she pick up ever bad habit oliver has which we discovered he picked up from his parents cause she and sara were some how be raised by the queen both of them stated in the show that they did all their growing in the queens mansion.
in any case most of the secret keeping that back fires on them both is a queens thing. and as we saw with Oliver so is this weird ego problem and not listing to people when they warn him about something.
remember last season when Oliver in arrow finally told us via diggle the reason of how he got into this mess with Raz was that he was mad that he lost a fight to him at all on that mountain .
they were suppose making statement about oliver having
PTSD but it became about ego with the way he stated it.
which indeed scream ego . he had the city endangered for it made it go on longer then it should have do to all this . he also let Malcolm play around with that supposed fake threat of releasing that video of thea killing sara and said Malcolm was never gonna do that after he met Ra'z
So it was pointless protecting Malcolm at all . Oliver could have ether let raz have Malcolm the entire time or told captain Lance (woh still doesn't the detail til this day not from laurel or Oliver)what went down and it was malcoms doing but again chose to act stupid.
laurel did the same with her self this season with choosing to make stupid chose and then act beyond bull head acting like Oliver then had people repeated have to point it out to her with her acknowledging it til it was beyond too late pretty much like oliver did with the Raz Al ghoul situation.
oh with Lana this happen every she was with clark and three things happen she blame him for certain events acted like a hypercritical person was rarely called out for it til later season's by cloe and sadly people started hating the actress due to the writing of the show for all this and the fact the writers were weirdly turning the show about her in between season's 2 to 7 . and it looked like the story of Lana the girl that got away instead of it about it being Clark's story for a bit and the fact it was about clark that lana missed out on being with.
oh Cloe yeah alot of people forget this part. this happened when oliver was around for it too . but season's 9 to 10 cloe became a manipulative and hypercritical person character her self.
her marriage with jimmy fell apart and when he died she tried to have clark use time travel to get him back be for when jimmy was playing spy for Oliver and met that gambling villain Roulette she had that same villainess try to kill off Oliver hit man/ I should say woman style and some of the stuff she accused Lana of she started doing and she kinda forgot jimmy fast when she entered her relation ship with oliver.
but part of that later part was speeded up due to the show trying to end. but there was some weird bad stuff there.
there's Lois no not how she always ragged on clark but during the college arc and how she started working at the daily planet with lex cone brother Julian who just had her work there she didn't earn her way in beside the fact most of the people there didn't work their like cloe did. but the worst part of the bad writing was the fact that the writers made her ignore the fact jimmy died and her and him were good buddy when she did start acting like a reporter for the planet. but she didn't he was murdered and didn't utter a word about him being missing or her missing him. Nada
the only person that missed Jimmy Olsen beside clark was Oliver but the writers were so having go after his wife in fast manner too.
the issue yeah with other writers yes Laurel is seen differently and more fun you know why they are bring the annoying baggage of strain that arrow has and the atmosphere in flash was always different from arrow where every is made to be at each other throats due to every fallowing the bad habits of Oliver with doing the same things he does after he's done it.
Cisco hasn't fallen into this trap in flash the only person doing this the most is Joe west so far . barry fallowed joe for a bit with iris. but he's having other issues. but the difference there is they aren't putting strain every where you with the show of flash. it's fun atmosphere show
also to point out and keep in topic of this thread kendra /shy'era did do some that was trouble some but she bounced back with her apology to Rip hunter cause she was decking and blaming for him being shot when she was the one that made sure that son of her's was taken with them . this is something almost never done on arrow where oliver and laruel involved cause they are beyond bull headed after they have acted stupidly.
kendra /shy'era owns up to her mistakes. it take day's for oliver and laurel to admit they are in the wrong next to captain lance too.
alot of people always tend to blame the actor's . or in this case the actress's but in truth they are only doing what in the script and I'm sure they always consult withthe director on the emotions that are supposed to be conveyed afterthe writers done with the script.
the fault isn't with the actress's but the fact that the characters are doing stupid things and aren't being honest when they are in the wrong or being beyond bull head when they warned about doing some or saying sorry. it takes alot for the main characters in arrow to do this. while the atmosphere flash and legend (for the time being with the latter show) is different they aren't that many hypercritical characters compared to the show they sun off from. and there more fun instead of let's pour on the strain