No poll? Well, right now I think an "8" - the island parts mostly bored me, but that's just because I'm not interested in the island. Other than that, it was good.
Tommy is being mostly mature and decent. He's is making all the unselfish decisions here. He's the one that looks like an insensitive clod (especially with the timing), and he does it. He deliberately takes all the blame on himself. For Laurel's sake and for Oliver's (who he is having issues with) and yes, for himself, too, for his own sense of worth and respect. He's like the anti-SmallvilleLex -Lex always said how he wanted to be good but when it came to decision time, he typically made the decision that got him what he wanted, even when he knew it was wrong. Tommy is declining what he wants for the sake of a greater good. Yes, for his own self-respect, too. But he made the suggestion to go to Oliver's, despite the fallout and knowing Laurel's feelings about the vigilante. Her safety was more important. And then he cast himself as the bad guy instead of setting up a scenario to villify Ollie/the vigilante. I don't know if it'll hold, but he's being awesome, IMO. I am not seeing imminent villain-hood for him. To me, he seems to have his priorities in all the right places for the time being. As you can perhaps tell, I really do like Tommy. I did find the "close your eyes" thing a bit cheesy, though.
I guess Moira's going sugar-free didn't take.
We have a firm-ish count on how many the vigilante has killed. With some margin for error for the ones he didn't kill with arrows.
I really, enjoyed Thea's saying she and Roy would find the vigilante together. It was a wonderful "together" moment. I'm not yet invested in Roy, but it was a nice moment. But he means the world to her?! How long have they known each other now?
I totally get why Diggle walked out that door, too. I can understand his anger and resentment. I couldn't really fault Oliver for choosing Laurel in general (that's what love is, and he should choose her if they were actually in a relationship), but, as Diggle said, as far as they knew, the boy was safe. Of course, we know the boy actually wasn't safe, given what eventually happened, but that's a completely separate thing. Nice that Felicity backed him.
Speaking of Felicity - given her tendency to babble, I'm a little surprised she's kept this secret.