We don't need Nic Cage back. For that matter, MSJ can stay far away as well. We just need someone who understands that Daniel Ketch is what made the character worthwhile, so we can get a serious horror film from Marvel the second time around.
At this point, Blaze's origin and Cage's on-screen performance go up there with the biggest complaints from the first. There's no reason to bring back those issues.
The whole leather jacket with chain wearing, motorcycle riding anti-hero is just such an 80s concept and doesn't really click with modern audiences.
Recast with Dan Ketch. Or just don't make another Ghost Rider movie. Seriously, the character from conception on is stuck in the 80s. If you want to make a Ghost Rider movie relevant today you need to entirely reboot. The whole leather jacket with chain wearing, motorcycle riding anti-hero is just such an 80s concept and doesn't really click with modern audiences.
A guy makes a deal with the devil to save his fathers life and gets screwed. Whats so crazy about that???
There's a difference between wanting to save somebody and making a deal with the Devil. When you want to help somebody, you're looking towards sources where the situation won't be made worse. In some cases, you look towards people of dubious record...it happens. But when a character makes a deal with Satan himself, there's no sympathy from the audience. It's common sense that you're going to be screwed over no matter what before you even make the deal, and when a character is stupid enough to sign on the dotted line anyways it's easy to dismiss the entire thing as stupid.
Prime example: The Tragical History of Doctor Faustus. I didn't feel a single shred of sympathy for Faustus when he made that pact with Lucifer. Mephistopheles acted as the audience by warning him on making a deal for any reason with the prince of devils, and still he wouldn't listen. Why should I feel sorry for his stupidity as he learns his lesson the hard way? What's worse is that it at least ended for Faustus with his eternal damnation...with Blaze, it's the cornerstone of his origin. That makes him more than just a flawed character. It makes him a joke of a hero.
So, like I said- working with Ketch in a reboot is a much better way of wiping away the disappointment that was the first film.
That it took a while is what's so flawed about him. For normal people, this would click instantly. An immortal personficiation of Evil approaching you with a deal (who apparently has the power to make his shadow look hella spooky) is the point where common sense overrides most character flaws. Age does not factor into this. Even small children would see the hints of something majorly wrong and GTFO out the same room. This isn't on the same scale as "Spidey being irresponsible" or "Bruce Banner developing a destructive mystery weapon." This is the king of all bad ideas.
It's even worse in the comics...at least MSJ's Johnny didn't try to summon Satan beforehand.