I don't think it's revisionism so much as seeing what was there in starker contrast after Solo flopped. The box office said it all. TLJ opened almost as strong as TFA when the only reviews came from critics that Disney could influence. Once enough real people had seen the movie and talked to their friends, the numbers dropped like a rock. That's the REAL audience reaction isolated from pre-release hype by Disney and the professional critics.No doubt. My point in all if this is there seems to be a lot of revisionist history going in when it comes to TFA in light of TLJ. Suddenly because people hated TLJ so much, the merits of TFA (which were there all along) have been brought to light. That's all I'm saying. Fandoms lose perspective on these things because everything these days is about the "here and now", this moment. When the emotions subside, that's when the real analysis kicks in.
OW for TLJ was $220 million, down only 11% from TFA's $248 million.
2nd WE for TLJ was $71.6 million, down 52% from TFA $149.2 million.
By the 5th and 6th WE TLJ was at $11.9 and $6.5 million vs TFA at $26.3 and $14.1 million. That's a drop of 55%.
DVD sales tell the same story. TLJ has sold fewer DVD's total than TFA did just in it's first week of release.