IMDb to close "message boards" on February 20, 2017

It could've been managed though. That stuff can always be regulated. You guys remember when Youtube was just starting out? THAT place was an absolute cesspool of the worst human beings on the planet to leave comments on. Youtube cleaned it up, though. I dont think its necessary for a full shut down but whatevs, i never posted on IMDB anyway. The Hype is more than enough for me :)
 
I'm a little sad just because I joined IMDB and the Hype around the same time, in a body cast and stuck at home with nothing to do, joined both for the same stuff... anything and everything Marvel...

The couple current shows I do actually engage in on the forums from time to time have periods of no activity, like right now, no real activity since mid-December, so it's not too much of a big deal on my end.
 
Hmm... I guess I didn't use it enough to see the cesspool side of it.
 
I have to admit that this is a good thing.

IMDB's comment's section IS (and now WAS) the place for people who don't understand movies.

And often, it just attempts to legitimatize racism, homophobia, and other nonsense. For the longest time, IMDB allowed users to rate films before they came out, and often trolls would give a movie like "I'm Not Your Negro" one star...even though it's not out yet.

And I can't count the times I've read where people would mock someone's race (or attempt to say they're ashamed of their heritage), religion or sexuality.

And while Yelp's metric/curving system is a double edged sword, it helps weed out the fake or trollish reviews. That's something that Amazon should try to use to.
 
Last edited:
The problem is that for every useful or interesting thread, there's ten that are just trolls looking to start fights, unrelated political arguments, or threads in which posters simply insult each other or tell anybody who likes the movie or TV show that they're stupid. Moderating a site with tens of thousands of message boards is impossible, since there's a board for every title and some of them are massive and full of trolls. They just have just gotten to the point where it wasn't worth the trouble to keep it going.
 
I think it's easy to say "good riddance" if you don't use the site anyway. I personally have never used the message boards on there, but a friend of mine has been on there for years. I can imagine a lot of people are bummed out because they probably made a lot of friends over the years.
What kind of friends do you make in a place like IMDB?
 
I used IMDB for a very short period. Maybe 30 posts. I still read some of the lesser used threads for shows I could not find a lot of conversation about. Even still, the majority of those places were built around, "this show sucks", "this actor sucks", "why is this show on".
 
I never joined the IMDb message board. The software always felt outdated to me. Any other good movie boards?
 
The problem is that for every useful or interesting thread, there's ten that are just trolls looking to start fights, unrelated political arguments, or threads in which posters simply insult each other or tell anybody who likes the movie or TV show that they're stupid. Moderating a site with tens of thousands of message boards is impossible, since there's a board for every title and some of them are massive and full of trolls. They just have just gotten to the point where it wasn't worth the trouble to keep it going.

I've read a theory from elsewhere that they are doing this because of Trump. maybe, IMDb finally realized that the alt right's strategy of spreading propaganda outside of their niche sites have real world consequences.
 
I agree with you in a way but tell that to the trolls who made that place home for the last decade. It's their fault you're losing out on some obscure but fascinating discussion of a 50's movie.

IMDb is really the only site I know where you have a separate message board for literally everything. From a movie to every single actor, producer, writer and crew person who worked on it. Think of the hundreds of thousands of separate pages that site must have and to maintain it all.

For instance, if you wanted to talk about the Oscars or BAFTAS, there were boards for that. If you wanted to talk about RPG games, philosophy, music or politics there were boards for that. If you wanted to discuss specific genres like sci-fi there was a board for that or cinematography there was a board for that too.

In that regard, I always thought how amazing IMDb was in that regard that you can not only look up any film, show or actor (not to mention all the other boards there that doesn't even have anything to do with films or shows) but the fact everything gets its own independent board.
 
Yeah, it was very thorough like that, and I doubt any other board will attempt that.
 
I'll miss it for certain things, but overall I think I'll be okay. It's probably for the best
 
Good luck finding another website that has it's own forum for Space Jam.
 
The problem is that for every useful or interesting thread, there's ten that are just trolls looking to start fights, unrelated political arguments, or threads in which posters simply insult each other or tell anybody who likes the movie or TV show that they're stupid. Moderating a site with tens of thousands of message boards is impossible, since there's a board for every title and some of them are massive and full of trolls. They just have just gotten to the point where it wasn't worth the trouble to keep it going.

According to someone, who claims to be a former employee of IMDb, says the true reason for the shut down, is because IMDb can't monetize the message boards.

https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0804503/board/threads/265764337/

From a former IMDb employee

"This is no surprise whatsoever. I've worked at IMDb (the worst and most discouraging experience of my professional life ) and believe me, the company is a soulless, empty corporate shell that has one goal: to sell advertising. It's not about movies, TV, or being 'guardians of data' - everything is about making money. The entire site is setup to sell advertising, and movie data is simply a means to achieve that. End of story.

The reason IMDb is getting rid of the message boards is simple: they can't be monetised. If IMDb could make money out of the boards, they'd be staying, but there's no cash in it for them, so they're getting axed. The sell-outs who run IMDb will have looked at the 'metrics' (a risible corporate buzzword the Data Team loves so much) and decided that traffic is not high enough for them to make any real money.

It really is that simple. I've experienced first-hand the obsession with metrics, and making money (at the expense of customer satisfaction), and it really is pathetic to behold. No decision is made at IMDb without greed being factored into the equation, and believe me, they will also shut down certain data sections at some point if they get in the way of making money. Forget the fact that the site has compiled 20+ years worth of important data - if one of the sections can no longer be monetised effectively (Literature, for example), they'll just get rid of it.

In financial terms, keeping the message boards live costs IMDb basically nothing, bar the human cost of maintenance, which - when considered in the context of the site's huge annual profit margin - is less than miniscule.

There's no point complaining about it, making suggestions, or suggesting alternate, viable solutions - the hacks at IMDb don't give a toss. There's no money in it for them, so they're not interested. They'll fob you off with the usual hollow platitudes, but make no mistake, the IMDb that people love died years ago. Now, the site is just a shiny, corporate plaything, pimped out by Amazon for the purposes of making money, with greed - not customer focus - being its primary driving force.

One final note: it probably burns IMDb that the majority (over one third) of their users come from China, the audience for which is far less valuable to advertisers than, say, the USA and the UK. Only about 5% of IMDb's users come from the UK, which is ironic considering the site originated in England. But, I digress - this post will, of course, be deleted, but what the hell. I don't care!"
 
I figured they were making money via adverts or whatever. A lot of people use the damn thing.
 
According to someone, who claims to be a former employee of IMDb, says the true reason for the shut down, is because IMDb can't monetize the message boards.

https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0804503/board/threads/265764337/

This guy is really salty for whatever reason. It's not like a company trying to be efficient is anything new. Of course they're going to use metrics, THEY'RE AN ONLINE BUSINESS.

I use IMDb the same way I used it years ago. As a matter of fact, it has only become more useful.
 
This guy is really salty for whatever reason. It's not like a company trying to be efficient is anything new. Of course they're going to use metrics, THEY'RE AN ONLINE BUSINESS.

I use IMDb the same way I used it years ago. As a matter of fact, it has only become more useful.


I am angry that after all these years, McDonald's has revealed itself as nothing more than a company bent on providing prepared convenience food in exchange for money, rather than being the stewards of giving away burgers and toys for free.
 
I haven't posted in that forum for a long time. I still access IMDb for its database though.
 
Sometimes I go back to IMDb boards that I haven't been to for a long time, and amazingly enough the same trolls are there still picking the same arguments with people.
 
Sometimes I go back to IMDb boards that I haven't been to for a long time, and amazingly enough the same trolls are there still picking the same arguments with people.

Ignore list was your friend at IMDb boards.
 
Just had a peek unto a message board today. And holy sh**!

The venom in which being talked about an actor who I don't think has had any scandals ever is just crazy. I won't miss it one bit. It;s for this reason and similar thing like that it's why people have had enough.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,271
Messages
22,077,771
Members
45,879
Latest member
Tliadescspon
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"