As a Punisher film I give it a 1 for effort. As a stand alone action film that appears on your tv late night and your too lazy to turn over and turn off the tv I'd give it a healthy 7. The fact that they made this big deal that the film would be more like the MAX comics, yet the film doesn't showcase them in their respective time lines, indicates to me that Marvel considers all of us dumba$$es. The film just throws all the great characters like Mginty, Bulat into 1 big nasty stew. It's disrespectful for Marvel to raise our hopes up like that, and feed us this crap. I don't know why they are so ****~ing stupid, they are a company who over the course of over 30 years have amassed a fortune from a large cult following of dedicated readers, yet they can't get their films right in respect to the fans. I repeat, that its the simple fact that they marketed this film as MAX when they know full dog on well any sensible person who has read the Max line knows Punisher doesn't hang from chandeliers and break dance fight on table tops during dinner time. Punisher is a serious character who has amassed a huge bodycount, by diligently, and carefully planning attacks. No, in this go around we get the moral question of if it's right, because I don't wanna be responsible for any new Punishers that may crop up from a bad film! ACK THE AGONY!!!!! If you really read the frikin Max comics like you said, you would realize that no fool would want the life Frank Castle has. If so, Id be out there Punishing criminals,and Marvel film writers. Hey, Im nuking futz!
Maybe if the names Bulat, Mginty, etc
(except for Jigsaw he sucks, so do whatever you want with him)
were different and retitled 1990 Punisher summer special written by an overworked, stressed out, Marvel writer
(who just discovered his girlfriend was cheating on him and his goldfish is pregnant)
just maybe, I will call this a Punisher film. Sadly my fellow Punished Punisher fans, this is Marvel's direct way of telling us that we are stupid to ever support Marvel since they began as Timely Comics. We were stupid to be inspired by Punisher, or (boo!) DareDevil (a.k.a TheRedClown) , or GhostRider, or Elektra, that we were foolishly led to believe that they would be given Oscar caliber film treatments, instead we get this "Barney Saves Xmas" crap you shove down our throats! If the University of Phoenix wants to establish themselves as the Wal-Mart of education, then I guess that makes you the "Target" of bad comic book films.
Ok, so I got jumped once when I was a teen, but I wouldn't have had the courage to stomp the living **** out of those cowards had I not read "Circle of Blood" for the first time. But instead of Circle of Blood you dummies could have easily adapted, you spoon feed us 2 police officers and giant loogy stew. I'm sorry for all the people in high school I argued with when I defended Marvel as the best comic book company, you guys have done it to us, me 3 ****ing times already!!! I really hope every DC film that comes out the next 10 years hands all of you your asses. I so mean that...........
To quote Stan Lee
~nuff said.