MARVEL WHAT-IF: REIMAGINING SEQUELS & FILMS THAT NEVER WERE

Frodo, it seems you have been focusing on Marvel castings. (if you did DC I didn't see)
I would love to see who you would come up with for DC.
Batman
Superman
Aquaman
Wonder Woman
Justice league to name a few

Well, you're in luck. I've done a tone of them. They're over in the What if/ reimaging , DC films thread that BobJM started a while ago.

I've done several different versions of Batman, Superman, WW, and The JLA. I've done everything from a John Hughes Smallville High based series of films, to Younger JLA film, to a Teen Titans film, to Kingdom Come, to WW 1984, To a Howard Hawks version of the Snyder films, to a 50s version of TDK trilogy, to a trilogy of World's Finest films with Routh and Bale.

So , i've pretty much been all over the map.

My favorite of mine is the Francis Ford Coppola directed Batman from 1974, with Clint Eastwood as Batman. That one seemed to go over well, but you'll probably have to go back through the first few pages to find that one.

I did several other Clint Eastwood Batman films in the thread ,but they're spread throughout the thread, so it'll take a bit of a hunt if you're game for it.

But yeah, they're all there if you're interested.
 
Frodo, it seems you have been focusing on Marvel castings. (if you did DC I didn't see)
I would love to see who you would come up with for DC.
Batman
Superman
Aquaman
Wonder Woman
Justice league to name a few
I smile a little by reading this. The DC forum thread is filled to the brink with Frodo's DC castings. One page after another. How could you have missed them?
Maybe you thought they were HERE, in THIS thread?
 
marvel-75th-anniversary-fantastic-four_marvel_feature.jpg

THE FANTASTIC FOUR! In Technicolor (1954)



b9598a5162d39c9ff444b2a40ea3850a.gif

Sue Storm: Grace Kelly

W22C.gif

Johnny Storm : James Dean

8108bb6c2cf9116714b7db176c0f167c379a99ae.gifv

Reed Richards : Robert Stack



6072897.jpg

The Thing :Ernest Borgnine

30069.gif

Alicia Masters : Debbie Reynolds

a20ffe21ed9b9600d9ab0e2734da6e5e--jack-palance-photo-portrait.jpg

Namor : Jack Palance

db7137c6be181740e144c9717627f9f5--christopher-lee-horror.jpg

Doctor Doom: Christopher Lee



 
Last edited:
I smile a little by reading this. The DC forum thread is filled to the brink with Frodo's DC castings. One page after another.

I smiled to myself as well. I've basically done everything DC except for The Muppet versions of the DC characters.:funny:.

I actually started posting more in the Marvel thread recently since I've done so many castings and alternative timelines and films in the DC thread.
 
tumblr_pf0blyaxW81wzvt9qo1_400.gifv


Simu-Liu-is-set-to-star-as-Shang-Chi.jpg

giphy.gif

Staring : Bruce Lee

D_9h7hhUEAExkpw.png

Hpl7.gif

Staring : Vincent Prince


5bd4992e17634-captain-marvel-logo-2-1138465

ac-rio-bravo-02-400x266.jpg

Staring : Angie Dickenson


217-2173884_ghost-rider-logo-ghost-rider-logo-png.png

tenor.gif

Staring: Peter Fonda




h04yuoapj5dz.jpg



200w.gif
224964179d171e101cf56353e7d85fa3.gif

Staring : Dustin Hoffman and Carrie Fisher



Thor-Ragnarok-Logo-thor-ragnarok-38813421-600-350.jpg

1da35c1e8abfe2e92be15ee5f22360d6.jpg

tenor.gif
tenor.gif

Staring : Jon Voight, Roddy McDowell , Bill Bixby, and Lou Ferrigno


Screen-Shot-2018-09-27-at-20.43.39.png

tumblr_omorsqF0WX1qczbido1_500.gif

Staring : Katherine Ross, Clint Eastwood, Yul Brynner, Max Von Sydow, and
Richard Dreyfuss
 
mMGTspXomuNHl6RgJUTuAntfqX7PFgEwYwPQCut7_D41bIQiOEjfvjfhH3y1k0qcZiFg-QC4MuVld2J2gp7CxnZCxmghk6Q

THE AMAZING SPIDERMAN (1958)
Director : Nicholas Ray
Motion Picture soundtrack featuring : The Crickets, Little Richard, The Coasters, Elvis Presley, Ricky Nelson, Dion and the Belmonts, Fats Domino, Eddie Cochran , Chuck Berry and more!





s-l300.jpg
images

Spiderman/ Peter Parker : Ricky Nelson

eddie-haskell.jpg

Harry Osborn : Ken Osmond

UGC6h-1443478312-blog-209.jpg
armoredcarrobberytalman.jpg

The Green Goblin / Norman Osborn : William Talman

280690__75214.1342528291.380.500.jpg

Gwen Stacy : Tuesday Weld

MV5BOWY4YTg2ZTMtNTUwNi00YTQ2LTg3MjItZjY3NzEyYjc3ZjJkXkEyXkFqcGdeQVRoaXJkUGFydHlJbmdlc3Rpb25Xb3JrZmxvdw@@._V1_CR0,60,640,360_AL_UX477_CR0,0,477,268_AL_.jpg

Flash Thompson : Troy Donahue

ti115583.jpg

Kraven The Hunter : Guy Williams

9e350c66e9c68d029cd215a89a8ef74e.jpg

Doctor Octopus : Theodore Bikel

72d139e789129e5615b9c3814d603d6f.jpg

The Lizard/ Curt Connors : Russell Johnson

BkRPGmYUNcSS2btT6Edxb7mjYBikeBDFWrUlwRR_mouCgPlF8tTNg1guMyIBtII3WGaCLkzUJ9QqEKL25VY0RAIQ_pOWyBo-skBhnN5j0AF7N9ToZDRxuh41cmLrV2GWP_k_9wvk4FKp1EhO54T_GN0DUymkxos

Vulture : Basil Rathbone

914b45a4db2f971f3e7271f028fc3f3b.jpg

Sandman : John Russell


MV5BMTI0MTQxNjMwMF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwMDY2MDQ2._V1_.jpg

Aunt May : Clores Leachman



 
I smile a little by reading this. The DC forum thread is filled to the brink with Frodo's DC castings. One page after another. How could you have missed them?
Maybe you thought they were HERE, in THIS thread?

I missed them like I missed the wit absent from any of your posts. : )
 
Staring : Bruce Lee

D_9h7hhUEAExkpw.png

Hpl7.gif

Staring : Vincent Prince


5bd4992e17634-captain-marvel-logo-2-1138465

ac-rio-bravo-02-400x266.jpg

Staring : Angie Dickenson


217-2173884_ghost-rider-logo-ghost-rider-logo-png.png

tenor.gif

Staring: Peter Fonda




h04yuoapj5dz.jpg



200w.gif
224964179d171e101cf56353e7d85fa3.gif

Staring : Dustin Hoffman and Carrie Fisher



Thor-Ragnarok-Logo-thor-ragnarok-38813421-600-350.jpg

1da35c1e8abfe2e92be15ee5f22360d6.jpg

tenor.gif
tenor.gif

Staring : Jon Voight, Roddy McDowell , Bill Bixby, and Lou Ferrigno


Screen-Shot-2018-09-27-at-20.43.39.png

tumblr_omorsqF0WX1qczbido1_500.gif

Staring : Katherine Ross, Clint Eastwood, Yul Brynner, Max Von Sydow, and
Richard Dreyfuss

Ah, you're heading for the future
 
Ah, technicolor. I get vibes of dreamy nostalgia and escapism.

That's what I was going for:cwink:.

I was trying to evoke that real 1950s sci fi vibe but with a big Hollywood production and budget of a Hitchcock , or Howard Hawks film, as opposed to a lower budget, black and white, sci fi film, which was also typical of that time.

I also wanted to use 4 icons of that decade with Grace Kelly and James Dean as The Storms, Ernest as Ben Grimm, and Robert Stack as Reed.
 
Last edited:
I love Dolph but he has a very limited acting range, which would work for the funny version of Thor that Hemsworth plays, but not for Cap.

The Swedish accent doesn't help things either...
 
SecretBabyishInsect-size_restricted.gif

c5096d05393623aa78eab6f5d45d3a16.jpg

INTO THE SPIDERVERSE (1984) THE CBS SUNDAY NIGHT MOVIE!
Airdate : May 20th 1984



Todd-Bridges-as-Willis-Jackson-diffrent-strokes-18022600-640-480.jpg

Spiderman/ Miles Morales : Todd Bridges

mini-series-airdates-september-30-october-1-2-1981-nicholas-hammond-picture-id472947432

Spiderman /Peter Parker : Nicholas Hammond

Scott-Leva-almost-starred-in-Cannon-Films-Spider-Man-movie.jpg

Spiderman/ Peter Parker : Scott Leva

Rick+Nelson-1981.jpg

Spiderman/ Peter Parker 1958 era : Ricky Nelson


maxresdefault.jpg

Spiderman/ Peter B Parker : Michael J Fox

68747470733a2f2f73332e616d617a6f6e6177732e636f6d2f776174747061642d6d656469612d736572766963652f53746f7279496d6167652f675435705962757667776f3936513d3d2d3635353833333438322e313536393061366662323534316262333639353930393039363439392e676966

Mary Jane Watson: Kerri Green

tumblr_o9pucmz4881s2wio8o3_500.gif

Electric Company Spiderman

200w.gif

Japanese Spiderman :Shinji Tôdô


giphy.gif

Doctor Strange : Vincent Price

220px-Cloris_Leachman_-_1975.jpg

Aunt May : Cloris Leachman

06652d159066062138020e90ecb17f3b--elisabeth-shue-hairstyles.jpg

Spider Gwen/ Gwen Stacy : Elisabeth Shue


pointing-and-laughing.gif

Demond Wilson : Jefferson Davis

494924956fc1febebd0f5836362c39cf--eddie-murphy-iconic-women.jpg

The Prowler / Aaron Davis : Eddie Murphy


tumblr_plplbgSyNT1qm6uzxo1_400.gifv

Doctor Octopus : Lilly Tomlin

tumblr_mrcg4yKNqm1rqd0kpo1_400.gif

Kingpin/ Wilson Fisk : Paul Sourvino

hqdefault.jpg

Spiderman Noir : Jimmy Stewart

173a893f306c916d4b2544cdbe49593d--marvel-heroes-marvel-comics.jpg

Special Guest Appearance by Stan Lee
 
Last edited:
marvelsecretwars.jpg

THE AVENGERS: THE SECRET WAR (1979)
Director: Irving Kurshner
Screenwriter : Nicholas Meyer, Mario Puzo

MarlonBrando_Superman.gif

Thanos : Marlon Brando

5Pqb.gif

Doctor Doom : Christopher Lee

DecisiveFrightenedCreature-max-1mb.gif

The Leader : Peter Cushing

tumblr_ojzr1zIFvs1rxmn3vo4_500.png

Magneto :Max Von Sydow

7pDs.gif

Red Skull : Omar Sharif

columbo-for-your-eyes-only.jpg

Doctor Octopus : Topol

tenor.gif

Loki: Roddy McDowell

tenor.gif

Galactus Voice : Ray Milland


G7rsvJob9r5LFH9Rfj6kifv0vJcEPiem7u-Y-s00syTF0jvZZ3uPjOke01uX7fLIWwE2cQ5s-8FaUK2eh17no336YAdLQMmtu9tjy6EdzmsfBLE_YqajbRsgwg

Wolverine: Clint Eastwood


3fafb3a518e3ff3347cc5b8b59538aad.gif

Captain America : Robert Redford

tenor.gif

Iron Man : Burt Reynolds

ClosedHiddenAldabratortoise-size_restricted.gif

Thor : John Voight

PepperyGreatHammerheadshark-max-1mb.gif

Spiderman : Nicholas Hammond

MV5BMTg4OTQ2OTAwMV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwMzk4NDM2._V1_UY317_CR0,0,214,317_AL_.jpg

Reed Richards : Robert Stack

a747e4d23633a8eb4a72428e021a653f.gif

Daredevil: Jack Lord

giphy-20.gif

Black Panther : Billy Dee Williams

tumblr_n51vkdEWAx1s2wio8o1_500.gif

Hulk : Lou Ferrigno

giphy.gif

Blade : Richard Roundtree

9ArF.gif

Starlord : Dan Akyroyd

2x4A.gif

Hawkeye : Steve McQueen

RX47.gif

Antman : Dustin Hoffman

1d9b7c2977adf82c67f69f558c66c93c.gif

Doctor Strange : Vincent Price

tve13348-462-19751005-0.jpg

Namor : Jack Palance

033cbac8e730382696c16586af880684b26082d4.gifv

Vison : Leonard Nimoy, Nick Fury: Peter Graves

tenor.gif

Scarlett Witch: Diana Rigg

6a00d8341c2ca253ef0240a51e3d4a200b-800wi

Black Widow : Honor Blackman

giphy.gif

Ghost Rider : Peter Fonda

tumblr_lrpwtu1csI1qbvn8yo1_250.gif

The Punisher : Robert DeNiro

 
THE AVENGERS: THE SECRET WAR (1979)
Director: Irving Kurshner
Screenwriter : Nicholas Meyer, Mario Puzo

MarlonBrando_Superman.gif

Thanos : Marlon Brando

5Pqb.gif

Doctor Doom : Christopher Lee

DecisiveFrightenedCreature-max-1mb.gif

The Leader : Peter Cushing

tumblr_ojzr1zIFvs1rxmn3vo4_500.png

Magneto :Max Von Sydow

7pDs.gif

Red Skull : Omar Sharif

columbo-for-your-eyes-only.jpg

Doctor Octopus : Topol

tenor.gif

Loki: Roddy McDowell

tenor.gif

Galactus Voice : Ray Milland


G7rsvJob9r5LFH9Rfj6kifv0vJcEPiem7u-Y-s00syTF0jvZZ3uPjOke01uX7fLIWwE2cQ5s-8FaUK2eh17no336YAdLQMmtu9tjy6EdzmsfBLE_YqajbRsgwg

Wolverine: Clint Eastwood


3fafb3a518e3ff3347cc5b8b59538aad.gif

Captain America : Robert Redford

tenor.gif

Iron Man : Burt Reynolds

ClosedHiddenAldabratortoise-size_restricted.gif

Thor : John Voight

PepperyGreatHammerheadshark-max-1mb.gif

Spiderman : Nicholas Hammond

MV5BMTg4OTQ2OTAwMV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwMzk4NDM2._V1_UY317_CR0,0,214,317_AL_.jpg

Reed Richards : Robert Stack

a747e4d23633a8eb4a72428e021a653f.gif

Daredevil: Jack Lord

giphy-20.gif

Black Panther : Billy Dee Williams

tumblr_n51vkdEWAx1s2wio8o1_500.gif

Hulk : Lou Ferrigno

giphy.gif

Blade : Richard Roundtree

9ArF.gif

Starlord : Dan Akyroyd

2x4A.gif

Hawkeye : Steve McQueen

RX47.gif

Antman : Dustin Hoffman

1d9b7c2977adf82c67f69f558c66c93c.gif

Doctor Strange : Vincent Price

tve13348-462-19751005-0.jpg

Namor : Jack Palance

033cbac8e730382696c16586af880684b26082d4.gifv

Vison : Leonard Nimoy, Nick Fury: Peter Graves

tenor.gif

Scarlett Witch: Diana Rigg

6a00d8341c2ca253ef0240a51e3d4a200b-800wi

Black Widow : Honor Blackman

giphy.gif

Ghost Rider : Peter Fonda

tumblr_lrpwtu1csI1qbvn8yo1_250.gif

The Punisher : Robert DeNiro
So many stars!
Wouldn't expect otherwise, this is Avengers at Endgame-level.
 
Last edited:
So many stars!
Wouldn'y expect otherwise, this is Avengers at Endgame-level.

Totally.:D , And with the director of The Empire Strikes Back and the writer/director of The Wraith of Khan, and The writer of The Godfather and Godfather 2, it would certainly be epic.

It'd be quite a three hour treat for a late 1970s film going audience.
 
I love Dolph but he has a very limited acting range, which would work for the funny version of Thor that Hemsworth plays, but not for Cap.

The Swedish accent doesn't help things either...

I dont think he is as bad as most think.
I'm not saying he is going to win an academy award for his acting, but, do we really go to see a Marvel or DC movie because we want that kind of performance?
I don't.
Not for any movie really.
If it happens in hindsight, then bravo.
But I think he can be cast as Cap or Thor & do a decent job.
 
Last edited:
Totally.:D , And with the director of The Empire Strikes Back and the writer/director of The Wraith of Khan, and The writer of The Godfather and Godfather 2, it would certainly be epic.

It'd be quite a three hour treat for a late 1970s film going audience.
:)

I wonder how the world would have been like if we got an epic like this back then. Not many films could overshadow it.
The 80s film landscape would be totally different. Perhaps less glossy films, not such classics as BTTF or Ghostbusters. No Karate Kid either.
Also, goodbye to the muscle action of that decade. No Rambo or Arnold.
I think we would have got more violent noir/crime flics, and dito dramas, with small budgets. It would be a reaction to the grandeour of the 70s.

You pointed out directors in your reply.
How do you pick them for your various projects? Is it because they are known for working in a similar style/genre as the hero(-es)?
I mean, Coppola is an archetypical Batman director. isn't he? :)
And the same for other directors and DC characters, in films we created from the 1940s up until today.
And since this is a Marvel board, I have to mention Oliver Stone and Captain America again.

Isn't the director a little more important than the cast? He sets the tone for the whole thing, and may have a finger in the writing too. The actors just act out their classic on-screen personas that made us them cast in the first place, in all these alternate films
 
Last edited:
:)

I wonder how the world would have been like if we got an epic like this back then. No many films could overshadow it.
The 80s film landscape would be totally different. Perhaps less glossy films, not such classics as BTTF or Ghostbusters. No Karate Kid either.
Also, goodbye to the muscle action of that decade. No Rambo or Arnold.
I think we would have got more violent noir/crime flics, and dito dramas, with small budgets. It would be a reaction to the grandeour of the 70s.

You pointed out directors in your reply.
How do you pick them for your various projects? Is it because they are known for working in a similar style/genre as the hero(-es)?
I mean, Coppola is an archetypical Batman director. isn't he? :)
And the same for other directors and DC characters, in films we created from the 1940s up until today.
And since this is a Marvel board, I have to mention Oliver Stone and Captain America again.

Isn't the director a little more important than the cast? He sets the tone for the whole thing, and may have a finger in the writing too. The actors just act out their classic on-screen personas that made us them cast in the first place, in all these alternate films

Picking directors is tougher for me than picking actors for the projects.

I can go with fit , i.e. similar styles in genres , but other times ,it's tougher for me since I only know the name of a handful of directors from each decade of the 40s-70s.

Coppola and Batman seemed to fit like a glove for a dark, noir, 70s Batman film. Hitchcock also seemed like a natural for a noir, thriller, mystery- like Batman film in the 50s.

I did a Mike Nichols Spiderman based film , based off of his handling of The Graduate . Since the Spiderman film was more of a dramedy with some action elements in it, I felt Nichols at that time(1966), could deal really well with Peter's bad luck with women, his struggle with balancing school, work, and being a superhero, etc.

I could see Nichols handling that type of film better than an action director from around that same time period.

Hammer productions also seemed like natural fit for a 70s era Blade film with Richard Roundtree , given their classic horror catalog and reputation.

In Secret Wars's case, I wanted to use some of the top talent who could handle sci-fi, drama, with humorous and human emotions, in addition to delving into the psyche of these larger than life characters.

So I went with Kurshner as the director, Nicholas Meyer who wrote and directed The Seven Percent Solution as one of the writers, and I went with Puzo who wrote the Godfather films and Superman films, to be the co writer. I imagine that the studio would have gone with the top hot talent of the late 70s.

I agree , the director is important. Unfortunately, my knowledge of directors, writers, and producers is shallow at best during the post war through late 70s era. I'm much better from the 80s to today.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"