AVC: Weve kept a close eye on the saga surrounding Henry Cavills mustache, which had to be (hilariously) CGId out in DCs Justice League reshoots. Can you shine a light on what the whole situation here was?
CM: Honestly, its a really tragic set of circumstances. Ive skirted any of the fun and the high-fiving that people have been having on the internet because I genuinely felt terrible for those guys. It was an unfortunate set of circumstances. Henry just finished Nomis and had a big beard and the mustache and long hair, and when he came to work he had cut his hair but still had that mustache and he asked, What do you think? I thought about it for a second and said, You know what, lets go for it. That was all that was ever said about it.
When the DC thing came up, we were in a very weird and very difficult situation: If Henry shaved his mustache, DC doesnt have a problem, but we do have a problem. DC said, Well, our thought is that you can shave the mustache and as it grows back you can augment it with CG. I thought, Ehhh, thats not really gonna work. Ive worked with fake mustaches before. You can get away with it for a shot or two, but it doesnt work over the course of a movie. It certainly doesnt work over the course of a movie in 35-mm anamorphic with a 75-mm lens in close-up. And, if you dont believe me, just go look at any movie where someone wears a bad mustache for the whole film. Its egregious. Its almost comical.
Our producer Jake Myers said, All right, let me figure out what that would cost. And he worked out, based on his considerable experience, the number of shots that Henry Cavill would be in and how much those shots would cost. It was estimated to be at about $3 million. Well, he said, what well do is shut down and you guys just pay us the $3 million. Well shut down while Henry Cavill grows his mustache back. Paramount Pictures heard about this and were like, What are you doing! Youre not shutting the movie down! We have a release date!
The sad irony was that, after the fact, Tom broke his ankle and the movie did shut down, but it wasnt in the time that it could help DC. So, it was just a tragic set of circumstances. We would have loved to have done it, but there was no way we could have done it without compromising the film. I just felt terrible for them, and I still do think its a real bummer.