I'm not usually one to dissuade somebody from chasing potential dead ends, as I am one to chase them myself.... but do you have any idea how difficult it would be to create a cypher/puzzle that has TWO separate solutions? The complexities of such a puzzle are mind boggling. If they were two completely separate portions of the puzzle that would be more possible, but using the same pieces to get two completely different outcomes? Highly, HIGHLY unlikely.
If this hasn't convinced you, I understand if you keep chasing this lead. I, unlike some others, won't condemn or laugh at you for chasing rainbows.