"I'm not sure how much the original cut was the super powered horror film people were expecting. A friend of mine was in a test screening for New Mutants, and he said he didn't know that it was supposed to be a horror movie until he watched the trailer afterwards. /1"
"Without spoiling anything, he described it as "A romantic dramedy with a little Breakfast Club thrown in. Really lethargic pacing. Occasional bursts of PG-13 'scares'." /2"
I just asked him and he said "4.5/10, nothing offensive".
He said it wasn't "Catwoman bad", but mostly "awkward" and "boring" with a few good performances from some of the cast.