That was still one of the most significant stories in the comics... Spiderman needs someone close to him to die at some point and we know it won't be MJ. And it can't be Aunt May getting sick... how many times do we need that garbage?
No, the real significance behind Gwen's death was that it turned the superhero genre on it's head. The hero always gets the girl, but the death of Gwen Stacy was a story where the hero failed and the girl died. It's considered the end of the "silver age of comics" because, at that point, comics were no longer "innocent."
This doesn't really translate to films where audiences aren't so naive. Besides, is it really necessary for Peter to lose someone close to him again? At some point, losing the people around him becomes monotonous for people, considering he has already lost his uncle and best friend.
IMO, killing off Captain Stacy would be a much better idea than killing Gwen.
FaT_tONle said:
They'd have to give a different take on Ned if they use him... but there really isn't much they can do with that character... they can expand a John Jameson role a bit more... make him in charge of his own reasearch or some sh:t like a mini Oscorp. Maybe they can tie him in to other villains. Maybe rekindle something with MJ if things continue not to go well with Parker... not a love triangle... but maybe a pity moment... like Swann/Norrington in POTC 3. Just throwing out some random ideas. Again the whole 20 minutes of Brock really hurts the sequels from the supporting male lead aspect... but what can you do?
I don't see any point if bringing back John Jameson, especially since what you're suggesting
is a love triangle. Again, if you want a male supporting character, introduce Ned Leeds. As a friend of Peter's and a co-worker at the Bugle, he fits fine into any story. Bringing back John Jameson inherently requires continuity from SM2, which is stretching too far back. It would be like trying to bring back Flash Thompson in an expanded role.
FaT_tONle said:
If Gwen isn't back? Bryce will be in her late twenties by SM4... she may pass on the role... I'd hate a recast this soon.
She
wants to do it again, though.
And again, I don't see the appeal in Black Cat. In addition to her being a Catwoman rip-off, Black Cat doesn't really add anything to the story.