Aw that sucks you didn’t enjoy scream 2 or 3, for me its actually scream 4 that I have issues with. But you inspired me to make my own list:
1. Scream 2 - 10/10. IMO the best movie of the series, the main trio are given alot more to do, gale who is my favourite character is at her best here, the balance between comedy and suspense is perfect, the chase scenes/kills are super inventive, I love the setting of the college and the mystery/reveal is my favourite of the 4 movies.
2. Scream 1 - 10/10. The original, its classic and I absolutely love everything about it, not much else to say.
3. Scream 3 - 7/10. I used to not like this movie much at all but it has really grown on me over time to the point where I love it now. It’s just so much fun and I find the added backstory and history behind the murders really interesting. Sidney IMO is at her best in this movie and I find her arc and journey to overcoming her fears really powerful, including the ending shot which is probably my favourite ending of the series. I also LOVE carrie fisher’s cameo as the film archive clerk
4. Scream 4 - 5/10. For me this is the opposite of scream 3 in that I used to really love it and over time I’ve become more and more critical of it. First of all the look of the movie is just ugly and IMO has aged the movie terribly, it just looks old and dull and its only been 10 years. Sidney’s character here is the weakest and basically does nothing for the entire movie except look and act exhausted. Neve’s acting is still great its just that the character seems so checked out of the movie, up until her final scene. Woodsboro doesn’t feel like Woodsboro to me, the movie doesn’t have Red Right Hand and there’s not really one great chase scene. The one plus about this one is I do love Emma Roberts as Jill and I thought that aspect of the story was handled very well
Hoping scream 5 sits at the top with scream 1 & 2!