SPOILERS FAN reviews SPOILERS do NOT enter if you don't want to be spoiled!

I still stick with my review. DS needed to be at LEAST 10 to 15 minutes longer for adding the character's back stories that are the main focuses.
I'm getting a tad miffed with the prelude comics. Granted I like them, the story that was in the Kaecilius prelude SHOULD have been shown in movie.
You can argue he's a throw away villian, the movie's not about him BUT, his story is connected to everyone else's in the film too. It shows more of what is going on with everyone else before Strange shows up.
Doctor Strange 2 will be too late to do that imo, if you're going to show Mordo's history there.
 
I still stick with my review. DS needed to be at LEAST 10 to 15 minutes longer for adding the character's back stories that are the main focuses.
I'm getting a tad miffed with the prelude comics. Granted I like them, the story that was in the Kaecilius prelude SHOULD have been shown in movie.
You can argue he's a throw away villian, the movie's not about him BUT, his story is connected to everyone else's in the film too. It shows more of what is going on with everyone else before Strange shows up.
Doctor Strange 2 will be too late to do that imo, if you're going to show Mordo's history there.

I definitely think that was one of the bigger problems of the movie. In any case DS is a fine movie. Although it's without moments where Stephen Strange struggled with his powers and had significant trouble beating his adversaries, it all seemed really easy for him IMO. The prelude comics sounds like a better version of the movie, I hope better writers are hired for the sequel. There is huge potential.
 
I went in not knowing too much of Dr Strange and walked out thinking i could have done a better job. It felt too clichey. It definitely went with style over substance.
I felt the CGI cape was pointless and took me out of the movie - funnily enough. I also thought how RDJ would have been a better fit, even Christian Bale. I think it being an origin story was it's down fall.
For what it's worth, i would have rather the film started off with a fully 'grown' Dr Strange. He introduces us to his bazaar world. I feel and again i could be wrong but i wish they had went with a Dr Who style formula.

My pitch - the world has changed, meta humans, aliens, robots, nothing appears strange anymore.
It's 1986, Halloween, kids are goofing around, around the streets kids dressed as ET, Han solo, even a vintage capt america and are trick or treating down a neighbourhood, in a shed, a few teens are playing with a ouiji board, one pulls out a spell book he has had in his family for years.
They have no idea what anything means and they carry on pretending to recite spells and ask the ouiji questions until something is awoken - as if, by magic, the teen appears in a trance - his eyes darken and he recites a spell.
From outside the shed glows and kids scream as a bolt races out and into the sky.
News reports circulate and the press go crazy for halloween antics go wrong as a girl is presumed kidnapped. The teens say it was a demon with a black heart - the police have no leads.
Credits role.
This day, a man in his 30's has made it his life's mission to find his sister and it doing his best to contact the avengers and get his story heard - could they help him?
The man ends up in asia, years of research leads him looking for the ancient one - he doesn't succeed, but.. someone finds him. In a remote village, the space before him opens up and out steps Dr Strange.
Dr Strange conforts the man, he tells him that he is on a path of evil if he is to continue misusing 'magic', falling short of selling his soul to the devil's helper Zadkiel himself. He agrees to hand over this spell book, stop his work if Strange will help him, which he agrees to do.
They enter the under world, other dimensions and battle inner demons as well as Black heart himself to retrieve his sister.
At the end, he has a choice - to stay with his sister in another dimension or create a paradox in time - As Strange walks away, a crack in the sky appears, behind it, an eye.
For the man that contacted strange was indeed the possesed teen trying to find a way back to the under world with his sister - they were indeed the children of the black heart project.

Now, this took me 5 minutes to come up with, using google. But it feels a lot different that the cookie cutter movie we got.

anigif_optimized-6840-1422748946-26.gif
 
I definitely think that was one of the bigger problems of the movie. In any case DS is a fine movie. Although it's without moments where Stephen Strange struggled with his powers and had significant trouble beating his adversaries, it all seemed really easy for him IMO. The prelude comics sounds like a better version of the movie, I hope better writers are hired for the sequel. There is huge potential.
Well, they aren't too bad but you get why of WHY Kaecilius was crying for one
 
I finally saw it and I gotta say, I thought the movie was perfectly fine. Not gonna set the world on fire, but I also didn't see some of the flaws some posters here keep harping on. Gave it an 8 out of 10 on the 'rate' thread, so i place it near the top of origin films, but not quite in the top tier Marvel films overall.

Could the film have used extra time? Yes, but I always think that. If every Marvel film were a half hour longer, I'd be more than happy.

Could Kaecilius have been fleshed out more? Yeah, but only one more good scene, maybe between him and Mordo, would have sufficed.

Did it tick the 'origin' boxes? More or less, but it also felt completely different from IM, Cap, Thor, or any of the established MCU characters. In the history of comics and film, we've seen similar before, but not in the modern era MCU.

Could Rachel McAdams have had a bigger role? Maybe, but I actually liked that she was this person in his life, we understood the context of their relationship without it having to be spelled out, and she served a decent purpose in the story. If it was just a guy friend of Strange's, nobody would question how fleshed out the role was, it just seemed weird because everyone assumes Rachel McAdams would have a large love interest role, but that's not really her purpose in the film.

All in all I really liked it without fully loving it, but I saw very little flaw to the film. The acting was uniformly phenomenal, I enjoyed the awkward humor, and the visuals were terrific. And that third act tho! It was competent and at times astounding, and hopefully next time it leans more heavily on the 'astounding'
 
Last edited:
Well, they aren't too bad but you get why of WHY Kaecilius was crying for one
You also see that where Mordo is Strange's teacher, DRUMM is Kaecilius', that's one reason there's a familiarity between the two in the movie
 
So are people just not counting The Incredible Hulk or something? Flawed or not- though I still enjoy it a lot- it's still an origin story and part of the MCU.
 
Well, I saw the movie last week and I really liked it though I had some minor issues with it.

I saw it today for a second time, this time in IMAX 3D, and the movie got a lot better. Not just because of the format, but I found the movie much more cohesive this time. I noticed things I didn't the first time. The villain is still a bit underdeveloped, but a few things that bothered me were not there.

It is a much more interesting film than I thought. The Ancient One speech in the balcony was good stuff. I felt her dialogue. That's one of the key scenes in the whole film for me. Tilda Swinton is the soul of the movie.
 
Just got done seeing this.

Didn't connect with the movie all that much - was too formulaic. The Multiverse and Dark Universe save the material. I just didn't see what everyone else did when it comes to Cumberbatch being synonymous with Strange the way RDJ has been for IM.

The way Strange negotiated with Dormammu at the end didn't feel like a great payoff that this kind of movie should have. Seemed more like something you'd see out of a role playing game than a CBM blockbuster.

The events of this movie also seem to happen uber fast.

I just got back from the theater with my wife and kids. I'd say all 4 of us agree with this. Two of us rated it 7/10, my wife 6/10, and my fourteen year old son said "stupid/10".
 
First post for this long-time Strange fan.

I gave it an 8/10 in the poll thread; it felt a little rushed, not quite as fine-tuned as some of the other films.

My biggest problem was that the magic was just a little too "sciency"; it worked well visually, but it seemed too much like advanced tech and not magical enough. I would have much preferred seeing Kaecilius immobilized with the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak rather than the magical bondage gear.

I know they were probably worried that using the incantations would come off silly, but for me, it loses something without them. I think they still could have used them, treating spells as "function calls", and made it work.

That said, I thoroughly enjoyed the film, and I think Cummerbatch nailed the role.
 
Last edited:
I would have much preferred seeing Kaecilius immobilized with the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak rather than the magical bondage gear.
The 'magical bondage gear' WAS the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak
The Art of Marvel Studio's Doctor Strange identifies the gear as such
 
The 'magical bondage gear' WAS the Crimson Bands of Cyttorak
The Art of Marvel Studio's Doctor Strange identifies the gear as such
Ah, thanks; I didn't know that. Still not the same as seeing the spell, for me.
 
Updating my initial review here:

Saw Dr Strange for the 3rd time ( I had built up points, on a movie loyalty scheme and got a free ticket).

Have to say, it was awesome. I expected it to be less enthralling, the third time, but was pleasantly surprised.

Dr. Strange has officially become my favorite cbm origin film - it's topped Iron Man, and Batman Begins.

Cumberbatch doesn't just nail the role, he owns it completely. The special effects are just icing on the cake.

Tilda Swinton was absolutely mesmerising as the Ancient One - a kind of complete opposite to Ben Kingsley's Mandarin (who we're hypnotized by how terrible the character was). I've never been a fan of Tilda, but despite not looking anything like her comic book counterpart, she manages to completely embody the essence of the character.

I admit that Mads Mikkelsen's Kaecillius is criminally underdeveloped - but hey, Dormammu !
 
Updating my initial review here:

Saw Dr Strange for the 3rd time ( I had built up points, on a movie loyalty scheme and got a free ticket).

Have to say, it was awesome. I expected it to be less enthralling, the third time, but was pleasantly surprised.

Dr. Strange has officially become my favorite cbm origin film - it's topped Iron Man, and Batman Begins.

Cumberbatch doesn't just nail the role, he owns it completely. The special effects are just icing on the cake.

Tilda Swinton was absolutely mesmerising as the Ancient One - a kind of complete opposite to Ben Kingsley's Mandarin (who we're hypnotized by how terrible the character was). I've never been a fan of Tilda, but despite not looking anything like her comic book counterpart, she manages to completely embody the essence of the character.

I admit that Mads Mikkelsen's Kaecillius is criminally underdeveloped
- but hey, Dormammu !

Agree pretty much with everything especially the bolded part was the only - for me. I think it's a curse. Comic origin films can't seem to have a great villain because most of that time is spend on introducing the origin character and barely any time left for the villain. I don't even think Kaecilius was bad but with casting Mads expectations went through the roof.

Batman Begins - Iron Man 1 - Dr Strange.
My holy trinity for now.
 
Why didn't Strange go back in time some more to save The Ancient One?
 
Late to the party... Wife, 16 year old daughter, 12 year old son and comic superhero fanboy daddy (me).

I'd give it a 5/10, decidedly average. I guess it lost me a bit when its possible USP for me (magic, dimensions, craziness) somehow missed the mark a little. The initial intro to it all through TAO was properly decent but the chase in the mirror world and attack at the NY Sanctum were a bit overlong and samey (somehow).

I thought all the actors did fantastically well (even to the point where I really REALLY wanted to know what got Kaecilus so riled), and I thoroughly enjoyed BC as Doctor Strange. I thought his seemingly quick success at grasping 'magic' was too quick, even for a genius.

Silly question; he used the eye of agamotto, gets blasted verbally by Mordo and Wong but they don't immediately take it from him?
I get the ending/win was different, but it just didn't hit me all that hard.

The rest of my family gave it a 7 / 10.
 
Well what happened to Kaecilus to bring him to Kamar-Taj was told in a digital comic sadly and not on the screen. BASICALLY he has a wife and child that die and he looks for a way to bring them back, which leads him TOO the spell in the forbidden book.
The Ancient one was using the spell as you know and she basically forbid Kaecilus to use it for bringing his family back
 
Bluray steel book is up at Best buy!
0PoTO7H.jpg
 
Bluray steel book is up at Best buy!
0PoTO7H.jpg
Nice!! :hrt:

And wait, do my eyes deceive me, is it actually a combo pack? (they haven't done a Blu-Ray/DVD combo pack since Iron Man 3, I believe) Nice (yes, I still like also getting DVD's, they're handy for loaning out to friends/family, or for watching in other rooms (that don't have Blu-Ray players) if the main tv room is occupied by others).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"