Discussion in 'Man of Steel' started by protocida, Jul 27, 2010.
If it's true, then .
Thats kinda old, but since they missed out on their prediction about Flash, WW, Aquaman, and JL, i'm not gonna buy the rest either.
Read this on CBM. I think it's utterly false. Here's why:
1-I'm not saying the new film won't borrow from existing comic arcs, but this really just seems like the writer took elements from Geoff Johns' "Superman: Brainiac" and "Superman: Secret Origin" and then tossed in the Metropolis PD angle because somehow, a Superman movie with Nolan as producer would have to involve police after TDK.
2-I seriously doubt that sensitive information of a film of this stature would be passed around on paper through folks like the writer claims to be. Seriously, I'd think writers/producers/execs would be sharing info digitally and securely and very likely don't even print out "notes" anymore.
Ultimately, I think this is just someone trying to tap into the buzz around the new movie with a "leak" that is nothing more than fabrication.
That said, the film would do well to be inspired by the arcs mentioned.
Haven´t they said that the new superman film wouldn´t be nor a sequel nor a reboot, with it being another superman story with superman already intalled in metropolis?
meh... previous reports sounded waaaay better. Hope this isnt true.
Yeah, we already learned of superman origins, chris nolan said that they were trying to make it set when clark is already superman because they wanted to make something new.
Yeah think its fake dont worry
I actually wrote a script for Superman that was alot like this fake report.
I hope in the actual film the police and Daily Planet staff play a good sized role
In my invented superman film stories i always imagined supes 1 with lex and metallo, the supes 2 with parasite and bizarro, supes 3 with zod and other criminals, supes 4 and 5 shot back-to-back with supergirl, the superman red and blue arc, darkseid as the villain in the 4th and brainiac as a minor villain in the 4th and he main villain in the 5th, then my story of the 6th was pratically with doomsday.
I prefer the original idea of having the film set when superman is already fighting crime in metropolis for some time, because that´s new and fresh.
How is that "new and fresh"?
Its been like that in comics for decades
and tehn every film besides Superman: The Movie have been like that
Not saying its a bad idea
Yeah, but for a reboot they should for now stay away from the origin, the other films have been sequels, even superman returns was kind of a sequel to superman the movie and superman II.
I think that's fake, but I would have loved for that to be true.
While i prefer the version of superman already extablished i think that Nolan knows what he´s doing.
I don't. "Neither a sequel or a reboot." Hasn't Warners learned their lesson from Bryan Singer's failed attempt at a re-quel?
Ask that to nolan, it was that what he said before.
I want a full on reboot too but they apperently can't do it because of the whole legal battle over the character and his world.
I've expected that we aren't getting a full reboot and I've gotten over my crushing disappointment about it.
And I really don't believe that story because it sounds far too much like TDK. Sounds like nerd fanfic to me.
If that were true it would be proof that Goyer and Nolan were turning Superman into their Batman. And yeah, I'd be pissed off about that but again I'm not because I don't believe it.
They're only making this film to settle the lawsuit problems.
They initially had zero interest in doing another Superman or rebooting the franchaise.
It makes sense Nolan's new movie isn't a reboot or sequel, but just his take on Superman.
It honestly wouldn't suprise me. I've said for a very long time that Nolan is wrong for this. Warner's is making the same mistake they made with Singer. Giving complete control to a good director who has had success with other comic movies but is in no way right for Superman. I expect the results to be just as bad. Especially sine its turning into little more than an exercise in Hollywood nepotism.
Street Gangs... Luther funding criminals? Sounds like BB with the lead dressed up as Superman... I am all for realism to the utmost extent but this is Superman. It will be interesting to see how they incorporate the super villain into the movie, whatever it ends up being about.
I hope this is true because it sounds like the best Superman movie ever. Its hilarious that people are complaining about it. Instead, we should have a petition for it TO BE TRUE. It would be a dream Superman movie!!!
Chis Nolan is not going to direct this, it is going to be his brother jonathan nolan who is going to do that.
LETS HOPE THIS IS TRUE. I can't believe you guys are complaining about this storyline. REALLY! C'MON!
I´m only complaining about making this is an origin story, they can´t do that because of the tribunal desputes.
Jonah Nolan is little more than a puppet for Chris to whom this project really belongs.
yea this was talked about last week in the nolan thread, and as cool as the details do sound for it we dont know if its true or not. And for me i still say what ever this reboot is it should have some origin elments for krypton, and why clark becomes superman and all that.