This is a very valid argument, but I still feel like there's a little niche market for ghoulish Joker that hasn't been tapped yet.I honestly hope they keep Joker looking normal physically. I wouldn't be opposed to something akin to Penguin where there is makeup and prosthetics but just done in a realistic manner. Reason being that it could seriously add to the scariness factor if Joker "looks" normal in terms of his physical anatomy and it's just his eyes/smile that play into it. My main idea has always been essentially Anthony Hopkins' Hannibal Lecter but shot like he was Michael Myers. Rather than homicidal clown, go more "A Pure Embodiment of Evil Itself." Could you imagine this, but with a manic grin
![]()
in THIS type of a shot?
![]()
It'd be the stuff of nightmares. And it'd be far more effective if Joker looks "normal", physically (not counting the makeup). Because then you get into uncanny valley and that type of human response. Making Joker look like a physical monstrosity with the biggest chin in the world ala Tim Sale would take away from that, in my opinion
I just don't think the Drops are going to factor into things very much. My gut is that they're world-building set dressing and nothing more.
I've said it before, but in the event that The Drops turn out being a hallucinogen, we could get the best of both worlds in that the Joker could look relatively normal, but be an absolute nightmare ghoul when seen from the perspective of someone who's tripping on The Drops.
It's a cool thought, just seems a little too Begins to me. No guarantee Reeves'll ever use Scarecrow, but maybe it's best leaving that stuff for him or similar villains. Of course Joker can be involved in drugs and stuff, just don't know that we need any trippy nightmare-hallucinations with him specifically.
Guy should basically be terrifying just normally. Not even necessarily super messed-up facially (wouldn't want the scars & stuff again), but like...yeah, nobody's going to need any chemical encouragement to be p*ssing themselves when in the presence of Joker even at his mildest-looking. The unsettling behavior and unpredictability's enough.
In other words it’s a escapist drug. Escape From Gotham lol. A nightmare hallucinogen is more Scarecrow’s calling card.
For the love of all that is holy do not give The Joker a clip-on furry tailWhy not give him a tail. Just one scene. He turns around, and a big fluffy tail rides up from under his trench coat, wiggling about from side to side as he saunters away. And then it's never seen or mentioned again. Just a one scene tail.
For the love of all that is holy do not give The Joker a clip-on furry tail


I knew he was joking but my response was genuine just in case anyone got any ideasAndy, do you maybe sometimes have trouble recognizing sarcasm?![]()
*Gen-ZClip-on cat ears and broadcasting weird threats from a Youtube video-reaction channel, spurting goofy-ass millennial slang and all.
Let's get nuts.

In my defense there are still people who unironically want that to happenLMAO that brings me back to yesterday where Monsieur Andy took the Brody/Glover comment seriously![]()
*Gen-Z![]()
