If this was Pre-Starhawk Aleta, there isn't any 'clear chance of victory' and even Post, Photon's easily more experienced with the same basic powerset. Hell, I doubt she'd have to resort to staying in energy form the entire fight, she's more than capable and has fought heavy hitters before without having to do so.
Aleta's no Gladiator or Mar-Vell, let's not get carried away here.